EC 270 - 2026-10-06 - Lecture 08

EC 270 - Lecture 08 - 2026-10-06

Intermediate Microeconomics I · Logan McLeod · LH 1011

Week 5 · 11:30-12:46 · 76 min · Full transcript · Flashcards

Overview

This lecture finished Chapter 6: Demand, then started Chapter 8: Slutsky Equation. For Chapter 6, McLeod showed how the quantity demanded of good 1 responds to its own price, using price offer curves and ordinary demand curves for Cobb-Douglas, perfect complements and perfect substitutes. He then covered cross-price changes (gross substitutes and gross complements) and inverse demand. Chapter 8 began by splitting the effect of a price change into a substitution effect and an income effect, and the class got as far as the substitution effect and compensated demand.

Own-price changes

Last Thursday covered income changes and got as far as the ordinary demand curve. Today finished own-price changes, the second of the three comparative statics from Chapter 6.

Price changes and the budget line

A change in income shifts the budget line in parallel, and a change in the price of good 1 changes its slope. When p1 rises, the line pivots inward around the vertical intercept m/p2 and gets steeper. When p1 falls, it pivots outward and gets flatter.

Why: If you spend all your income on good 2, you can buy m/p2 units no matter what good 1 costs, so that end of the line stays put. Only the amount of good 1 you can afford, m/p1, moves.

p1x1+p2x2=m,slope=−p1p2

where m is income, p1 and p2 are the two prices, and x1 and x2 are the quantities.

Made-up example: a price rise pivots the line

Income is $60, p2=6, and p1 rises from 3 to 5.

  1. m/p1=60/3=20 -- most good 1 you can afford before the rise
  2. m/p1′=60/5=12 -- most good 1 you can afford after the rise
  3. m/p2=60/6=10 -- the vertical intercept, which is the same before and after
  4. −p1/p2=−3/6=−0.5 becomes −p1′/p2=−5/6≈−0.83 -- the slope gets steeper

Answer: The line pivots inward around (0,10), and its horizontal intercept falls from 20 to 12 -- the consumer can afford less good 1, while the most good 2 they can afford is unchanged.

Exam

In the recap, a student said the indifference curve moves out when income goes up. McLeod corrected this: "No, the budget constraint." Prices and income move the budget line. Preferences, and so the indifference curves, stay where they are.

Price offer curve

The price offer curve is the line through all the optimal bundles as the price of good 1 changes, drawn in x1–x2 space. It shows how the optimal amounts of both goods change as p1 changes. It is the price version of the income offer curve from last lecture.

Why: For each price (p1′, p1″, p1‴), the consumer picks a best bundle on that budget line (A, B, C). Joining them traces out how the optimal choice responds to p1.

Ordinary demand curve

The ordinary demand curve plots the quantity demanded of a good against its own price, holding income and the other price fixed. Each point comes straight from the consumer's optimal choice: the quantity of good 1 in bundle A at p1′, in bundle B at p1″, and so on. Price goes on the vertical axis and quantity on the horizontal axis.

Why: The demand curve from first-year economics is not a separate idea. It is the consumer's optimal choice read off one good at a time.

Exam

A student asked whether the course separates "demand" from "quantity demanded", as EC 120 did. McLeod said yes: "We are talking about quantity demanded... I will get lazy sometimes and slip and say demand... Call me on it when I do." A change in the good's own price moves you along the demand curve. It changes the quantity demanded, not demand.

He also asked why he only drew the demand curve for good 1 ("This isn't a trick question"). The answer: "ordinary demand curves look at quantity demanded as a function of the good's own price." The exercise only changes p1, which is not good 2's own price.

Cobb-Douglas

With Cobb-Douglas utility u=x1αx2β, the ordinary demands are the ones solved in Chapter 5. As p1 rises, x1∗ falls and x2∗ does not change. So the price offer curve is horizontal, and the demand curve for good 1 is a rectangular hyperbola (a smooth, downward-sloping curve).

Why: Here α, β and m are all constants, and p1 sits in the denominator of x1∗, so a bigger p1 must make x1∗ smaller. Since p1 does not appear in x2∗ at all, the amount of good 2 never moves. In the standard explanation, Cobb-Douglas consumers spend a fixed share α/(α+β) of income on good 1. Price times quantity stays constant, and that is what makes the curve a rectangular hyperbola.

x1∗=αα+βmp1,x2∗=βα+βmp2

where α and β are the positive utility parameters, m is income, and p1 and p2 are the prices.

Made-up example: Cobb-Douglas as p1 rises

Take α=β=1, m=120 and p2=3, and raise p1 from 2 to 4.

  1. x1∗=12⋅1202=30 -- good 1 at p1=2
  2. x1∗=12⋅1204=15 -- good 1 at p1=4
  3. x2∗=12⋅1203=20 -- good 2 at both prices, since p1 is not in its formula

Answer: Good 1 falls from 30 to 15 while good 2 stays at 20 -- the price offer curve is flat at x2=20, and spending on good 1 stays at $60 (2×30=4×15).

Perfect complements

With u=min{x1,x2}, the consumer always wants the two goods in a 1:1 ratio, so the indifference curves are L-shaped with corners on the ray x2=x1. Both goods have the same demand, m/(p1+p2). The price offer curve is that ray from the origin. The demand curve for good 1 slopes down: it approaches 0 as p1 gets very large, and it reaches m/p2 when p1=0.

Why: We don't look for a tangency, because the slope at the corner of an L is undefined. Instead, the best bundle is on the budget line and on the ray x2=x1. When p1 goes to infinity, the consumer can afford none of good 1, and so wants none of good 2 either. When p1 is 0, all income goes to good 2 (m/p2 units), and the consumer takes the same amount of good 1.

x1∗=x2∗=mp1+p2

where m is income and p1 and p2 are the prices.

Made-up example: perfect complements as p1 changes

Income is $120 and p2=2.

  1. x1∗=1201+2=40 -- at p1=1, and x2∗ is also 40
  2. x1∗=1204+2=20 -- at p1=4, both goods drop to 20
  3. x1∗=1200+2=60 -- at p1=0, the top of the demand curve is m/p2

Answer: The bundles (60, 60), (40, 40) and (20, 20) all lie on the ray x2=x1 -- that ray is the price offer curve.

Perfect substitutes

With perfect substitutes in a 1:1 ratio (McLeod's Diet Coke and Diet Pepsi), the indifference curves are straight lines, and the best bundle depends on comparing p1 with p2. If good 1 is cheaper, the consumer buys only good 1. If it costs more, the consumer buys none of it. If the prices are equal, any bundle on the budget line is optimal. As p1 rises, the price offer curve runs in along the x1 axis, then spreads along the whole budget line at p1=p2, then stays at the corner where only good 2 is bought.

Why: The slopes decide whether the consumer ends up at one corner, the other, or anywhere on the line. Raising p1 changes the budget line's slope but never the indifference curves' slope.

x1∗={m/p1if p1<p2anything from 0 to m/p1if p1=p20if p1>p2

where m is income and p1 and p2 are the prices.

So the demand curve for good 1 follows m/p1 below p2, is a flat segment from 0 to m/p2 at p1=p2, and sits at zero above p2.

Made-up example: perfect substitutes as p1 rises

Income is $12 and p2=3.

  1. p1=2<3, so x1∗=12/2=6 -- good 1 is cheaper, so the consumer buys only good 1
  2. p1=3=p2, so x1∗ is anything from 0 to 12/3=4 -- every bundle on the budget line is equally good
  3. p1=4>3, so x1∗=0 -- the consumer buys only good 2, 12/3=4 units

Answer: Quantity demanded falls from 6, to anywhere from 0 to 4, to 0 -- the demand curve jumps flat across at the price where the goods cost the same.

Exam

A student said raising p1 makes the indifference curve steeper. McLeod: "The slope of the indifference curve does not change as we change price. Indifference curves represent preferences and your preferences don't change based on prices." It is the budget line that changes.

Ordinary goods and Giffen goods

An ordinary good is one whose quantity demanded falls when its own price rises. A Giffen good is one where, at some prices, quantity demanded rises when its own price rises. McLeod's only real-world example was potatoes during the Irish Potato Famine, when "as the price of potatoes went up, quantity of potatoes demanded increased." (Economic historians dispute whether the famine data really show this. Use McLeod's example on his tests.)

Why: McLeod said Chapter 8 will explain why not all goods are ordinary. In the standard explanation, a Giffen good is a strongly inferior good where the income effect of a price change outweighs the substitution effect.

∂x1∂p1<0 (ordinary),∂x1∂p1>0 (Giffen)

where x1 is the ordinary demand for good 1 and p1 is its own price.

Made-up example: signing the own-price derivative

Cobb-Douglas with α=β=1 and m=120 gives x1=60/p1. Is good 1 ordinary at p1=2?

  1. x1=60p1−1 -- rewrite as a power so the power rule applies
  2. ∂x1∂p1=−60p1−2=−60p12 -- power rule
  3. −6022=−15 -- evaluate at p1=2

Answer: The derivative is −15, which is negative -- good 1 is ordinary (in fact it is negative at every positive price).

Cross-price changes

This is the last of the three comparative statics: how demand for good 1 responds to the price of good 2.

Gross substitutes and gross complements

If the quantity demanded of good 1 rises when the price of good 2 rises, the goods are gross substitutes. If it falls, they are gross complements. You find out by taking the partial derivative of good 1's ordinary demand with respect to p2 and checking its sign.

Why: If good 2 gets pricier, consumers move toward the now cheaper good 1 (substitutes). With perfect complements, a pricier good 2 means less good 2, and since the goods are used 1:1, less good 1 too.

∂x1∂p2>0 (gross substitutes),∂x1∂p2<0 (gross complements)

where x1 is the ordinary demand for good 1 and p2 is the price of the other good.

Example: perfect complements are gross complements

The ordinary demand for good 1 is x1=mp1+p2.

  1. x1=m(p1+p2)−1 -- rewrite as a power
  2. ∂x1∂p2=−m(p1+p2)−2=−m(p1+p2)2 -- power rule with the chain rule
  3. (p1+p2)2>0 and m>0 -- a square is positive, and income is never negative
  4. −(+)(+)<0 -- only the minus sign out front is left to set the sign

Answer: ∂x1∂p2<0, so the goods are gross complements -- "painfully obvious" since the preferences were perfect complements to begin with, which was McLeod's point.

Example: Cobb-Douglas goods are neither

The ordinary demand for good 1 is x1=αα+βmp1.

  1. p2 does not appear anywhere in x1 -- so changing it cannot move x1
  2. ∂x1∂p2=0 -- the derivative of a term with no p2 in it

Answer: The derivative is 0, so with Cobb-Douglas preferences good 1 is neither a gross substitute nor a gross complement for good 2 -- the same fact as the flat price offer curve.

Inverse demand

This closed out Chapter 6.

Inverse demand function

An ordinary demand function gives quantity as a function of price. An inverse demand function flips it: for a given quantity, it gives the matching price. You get it by solving the ordinary demand function for the price.

Why: It is the same relationship written the other way round. It matches how demand curves are drawn, with price on the vertical axis.

Example: inverse demand for Cobb-Douglas

Start from x1∗=αα+βmp1 and solve for p1.

  1. p1x1∗=αα+βm -- multiply both sides by p1
  2. p1=αα+βmx1∗ -- divide both sides by x1∗

Answer: p1=αm(α+β)x1∗ -- price as a function of quantity. McLeod noted that moving everything else across first also works, but moving just p1 and x1 takes fewer steps.

Example: inverse demand for perfect complements

Start from x1∗=mp1+p2 and solve for p1. The extra step is the p2 stuck in the denominator.

  1. x1∗(p1+p2)=m -- multiply both sides by p1+p2
  2. p1+p2=mx1∗ -- divide both sides by x1∗
  3. p1=mx1∗−p2 -- subtract p2 from both sides

Answer: p1=mx1∗−p2. Doing the same for good 2 gives p2=mx2∗−p1.

The Slutsky equation

Chapter 8 uses the model's theory to split a price change into two effects you never actually observe. McLeod called it one of the most fun chapters: it is where the model's theoretical power first gets used to predict behaviour, for example why Giffen goods can exist. It is named after the Russian economist Slutsky. McLeod's own professors claimed it was fun to talk about at parties. McLeod never found it so.

Substitution and income effects

When the price of good 1 falls, two things happen at once:

Why: A price change changes relative prices and real purchasing power at the same time. The model lets us ask how much of the total change comes from each.

TE=SE+IE

where TE is the total change in quantity demanded, SE is the part due to the change in relative prices, and IE is the part due to the change in purchasing power. The made-up example under "The substitution effect" below shows the split with numbers.

Pivot and shift

Slutsky's idea is to break the move from the old budget line to the new one into two steps:

Why: The pivoted line is a made-up budget line. It has the new relative prices but just enough income to afford the original bundle, so it isolates the effect of relative prices alone.

Adjusting income to hold purchasing power

After p1 falls to p1′, the original bundle costs less than m. The income m′ is the amount that makes the original bundle just affordable at the new price. Moving from m to m′ is like taking income away from the consumer.

Why: Write the two budget lines through the original bundle: m′=p1′x1+p2x2 (pivoted line) and m=p1x1+p2x2 (original line). Subtracting them cancels the p2x2 terms, leaving only the change in what good 1 costs.

Δm=m′−m=x1(p1′−p1)=x1Δp1

where x1 is the amount of good 1 in the original bundle, Δp1 is the change in its price, and Δm is the income change needed to keep the original bundle just affordable.

Made-up example: compensating for a price rise

The original bundle has 10 units of good 1, and its price rises from $4 to $6.

  1. Δp1=6−4=2 -- the price change
  2. Δm=x1Δp1=10×2=20 -- put the numbers into the formula

Answer: $\Delta m = $ $20 -- the consumer needs $20 more to still afford the original bundle, so the price and the income adjustment move in the same direction.

Exam

McLeod stressed it twice: "The change in income and the change in price are always going to move in the same direction." If Δp1 is negative, Δm is negative too. A price fall raises purchasing power, so to hold purchasing power constant "I have to take income away from you."

The substitution effect

The substitution effect is the change in quantity demanded of good 1 when its price changes from p1 to p1′ and income is adjusted to m′, so that purchasing power stays the same. On the graph, it is the move from the original bundle X to bundle Y, the best affordable bundle on the pivoted budget line.

Why: X was a tangency at the old prices. Once the budget line's slope changes, X can no longer be a tangency, so the consumer moves along the pivoted line to Y, where the slopes are equal again.

Δx1s=x1(p1′,m′)−x1(p1,m)

where x1(p,m) is the consumer's ordinary demand function for good 1, p1 and m are the original price and income, p1′ is the new price, and m′ is the adjusted income. You just plug two price and income pairs into the same ordinary demand function.

Made-up example: substitution effect of a price cut

Demand for good 1 is x1=m2p1. Income is $120, and p1 falls from $3 to $2.

  1. x1(3,120)=1202×3=20 -- the original choice X
  2. Δm=x1Δp1=20×(2−3)=−20 -- income to take away so X is just affordable
  3. m′=120−20=100 -- the adjusted income
  4. x1(2,100)=1002×2=25 -- the best bundle Y on the pivoted line
  5. Δx1s=25−20=5 -- the substitution effect
  6. x1(2,120)=1202×2=30 -- the actual new choice, with full income
  7. TE=30−20=10, so IE=10−5=5 -- the rest of the change comes from purchasing power

Answer: The substitution effect is 5 units of the 10-unit total change -- the other 5 is the income effect, which Thursday's lecture covers in detail.

Compensated demand

The substitution effect is sometimes called the change in compensated demand. The consumer is "compensated" for a price rise by being given just enough income to afford the original bundle. For a price fall, income is taken away instead, so that the original bundle is just affordable.

Why: It is the same thought experiment as the pivot, seen from the consumer's side: only relative prices change, and purchasing power is held fixed.

Exam checklist

Admin & deadlines


Transcribed automatically from the lecture recording. Slides used: EC 270 - Ch. 08 - Slutsky Equation (slides).pdf. Course info used: EC 270 - Math Appendix (slides).pdf, EC 270 - Rules of Derivatives.pdf, EC 270 - Syllabus - Fall 2026.pdf. Audio archived at /mnt/porsche/configs/lectures/archive/2026-10/EC 270 - 2026-10-06 - Lecture 08.opus.