AS 101 - 2026-09-21 - Lecture 03
AS 101 - Lecture 03 - 2026-09-21
Week 3 · 17:32-18:29 · 57 min · Full transcript · Flashcards
Overview
This lecture finished Chapter 1 and started Chapter 2 of ASTRO, "User's Guide to the Sky". It opened with relativity: motion only makes sense compared with something else, which is why we don't feel Earth spinning. It then added spacetime and the cosmic calendar to last lecture's Big Bang. The rest covered how we name stars and rank their brightness with the magnitude scale, why astrology is pseudoscience, the celestial sphere model, where distances across the sky are measured as angles, and how the Sun will die.
Relativity and motion
This builds on "Position is relative" from Lecture 2.
Position needs a landmark
You never return to the same spot in space. Earth spins, orbits the Sun at about 30 km/s, and the whole solar system moves around the centre of the galaxy. So a position only means something compared with a landmark.
Why: Nothing in space sits still, so there is no absolute "here". People used Polaris, the North Star, as their landmark because it barely moves in our sky.
- Earth's axis of rotation is tilted 23.5° from the vertical.
- Polaris (the North Star) sits almost in line with that axis. As Earth spins, it stays put while the other stars circle around it.
Relativity
What you see depends on where you watch from. The lecturer compared it to moving to another culture: the food, dancing and greetings look different because you see them from a new point of view. Two observers can describe the same motion differently and both be right. The same laws of physics work for both of them.
Why: Each observer describes the motion relative to their own frame. In the truck example below, the thrower moves with the ball sideways, so they only see the up-and-down part.
The lecturer used the truck on the slides as one of Einstein's thought experiments. The lecturer said Einstein "did almost all the experiments with mind", in his head rather than in a lab, and mentioned that Einstein's office was at the Institute for Advanced Study in Princeton.
- A person in the back of a truck throws a ball straight up. To them, the ball goes straight up and straight down.
- Someone sitting on the road sees the same ball follow a curved path, because the truck is moving forward.
- The truck must move at a constant speed. It should not speed up (acceleration) or slow down (deceleration).
The lecturer credited Galileo and Lorentz with earlier work on relativity. (The lecturer said Lorentz came before Galileo. It was the other way round: Galileo lived around 1600, and Lorentz lived around 1900, just before Einstein.) They quoted Einstein as saying "I was standing on the shoulders of giants." (That line is usually credited to Isaac Newton.) The lecturer's point was that "science is not one person's achievement."
Know the truck example. "Who is correct? … According to physics, both are correct." Also remember the condition: the truck moves at a constant speed, with no acceleration.
Earth's spin speed
This is a recap of Lecture 2. A point on the equator travels once around Earth's circumference every 24 hours.
Why: Speed is distance divided by time. In one spin, the distance is one full circumference.
where
The slides use Earth's radius
-- put the radius into the circumference formula km -- the distance travelled in one day -- divide the distance by the time km/h -- do the division
Answer: about 1667 km/h. The lecturer said that is how fast we are moving right now. (That is only true at the equator. Farther north, the circle you travel around is smaller, so you move slower. In Waterloo, at about 43.5° north, it is about 1667 × cos 43.5° ≈ 1200 km/h.) The lecturer rounded it to "1,600 km/h", and the slide writes 1667.12, a small rounding slip.
Why we do not feel it
We don't feel Earth's 1667 km/h spin because everything around us moves with it at the same constant speed. "We are all in the same boat." You feel motion on a roller coaster because your speed keeps changing.
Why: You only notice motion when you compare yourself with something that is not moving along with you.
The lecturer's example was driving on Highway 401 towards Toronto. The trees close to you seem to rush backwards. The trees farther away seem to move along with you, because you judge them against the near trees. In fact, you are the one moving, and all the trees are fixed.
The Big Bang and spacetime
This extends the Big Bang and cosmic calendar from the end of Lecture 2.
Spacetime and expanding space
The Big Bang says that 13.8 billion years ago, spacetime suddenly began to expand, and it is still expanding. Space and time are not two separate things. They always exist together as spacetime.
Why: Galaxies are moving away from each other, but not because they fly through space. The space between them is stretching.
- Galaxies move apart, not individual stars.
- Space is not expanding "into" anything. By definition, everything is inside it, so it simply gets bigger.
- What came before the Big Bang, and what started it, are questions science cannot answer. The lecturer said science "does not have an answer for everything." They added that "science knows only 1% of the things", and that Newton and Einstein often said "I don't know."
Get the wording right: "You have to say spacetime, spacetime, not space and time." Also: "It is not the galaxies which are moving, it is the space between them is expanding."
Space is not empty
Take every bit of matter and radiation out of space, and something is still left. The class answer the lecturer accepted was that space is a field, a gravitational field. It is not a material, but it has properties.
Why: "Nothing cannot have a property." Space does have properties, so space must be something.
- The properties the lecturer named were gravity, the permeability of free space ("free space" just means vacuum), and the speed of light, which has one exact value in free space.
- Einstein described spacetime as acting like a fabric, like cloth, even though it is not a material.
Cosmic calendar
Carl Sagan's idea: squeeze the universe's 13.8-billion-year history into one calendar year, from January 1 to midnight on December 31.
Why: Its purpose is to compare astronomical timescales with human experience. Numbers in the billions mean nothing to us, but a calendar does.
Dates from the slides:
- Jan 1: Big Bang.
- Mar 1: the Milky Way starts to form.
- Aug 15: the solar system starts to form. The lecturer said this was about 5 billion years ago. (Most references give about 4.6 billion years. Use 4.6 billion unless the textbook says otherwise.)
- Sep 30: primitive life appears on Earth.
- Dec 15: complex life forms.
- Dec 25: dinosaurs roam Earth.
- Dec 30: dinosaurs die out. The lecturer said this was 65 million years ago.
- Dec 31: the pyramids were built 11 seconds before midnight. Copernicus said Earth orbits the Sun 1 second before midnight.
"What's the idea behind the cosmic calendar? Cosmic calendar is to understand astronomical time scales to human experience. If somebody ask what's the point of having a cosmic calendar, that is the answer. I will keep on asking that question again."
What we see in the night sky
This starts Chapter 2 of ASTRO. Its goal is to explain how we name stars, how the sky moves, the seasons, and the Moon's phases and eclipses.
Objects in the night sky
- Star: a ball of gas held together by its own gravity and powered by nuclear fusion inside it. It makes its own light, so it is luminous.
- Planet: a non-luminous object. It makes no light of its own, but it reflects light.
- The Moon: an astronomical body, but not a planet. It is a satellite, an object that orbits us.
- Clouds: water vapour and dust.
Stardust
The slides say 93% of your body mass is stardust. Most of the elements in your body were made inside stars.
The closest stars
The slides map the stars nearest the Sun. All of them lie within about 30 light-years of us, which is about
Constellations
Constellation
A constellation is a group of stars that looks like a shape in the sky and has been given a name. The name usually belongs to a mythological god, a person, an animal or an object. The word also means the region of the sky that holds that pattern.
Why: A shape and a name make the stars easy to remember. The shapes themselves are pure imagination. The slides quote Einstein: "Imagination is more important than knowledge." The lecturer joked that Capricornus looks nothing like a goat.
Examples from class: Leo (lion), Virgo (maiden), Gemini (twins), Cancer (crab), Sagittarius (a centaur archer), Cygnus, and Orion.
The 88 constellations
The International Astronomical Union (IAU) recognizes 88 constellations. Together, their boundaries cover every part of the sky. It is the same body that decided Pluto is no longer a planet.
- Of the 88, 42 show animals, 29 show objects, and 17 show humans or mythological characters.
- The lecturer linked the number to a piano, which also has 88 keys.
- The lecturer said you don't need to memorise all 88 or the 42/29/17 split: "I don't expect you to remember all those things."
Asterism
An asterism is a named group of stars that is not one of the 88 official constellations. The Big Dipper is the standard example, and the slides and the lecturer also name the Little Dipper, with Polaris at the end of its handle. In class the lecturer said both that the Big Dipper is "not part of any constellation" and that an asterism can be "part of a constellation". The second is right: an asterism is not one of the 88, but it often sits inside one. The Big Dipper is the brightest part of the constellation Ursa Major.
The zodiac
The 12 zodiac signs are real constellations. Long ago, their position relative to us was tied to the months, for example "born in September, so you are Virgo." The lecturer said that link no longer holds today.
Naming stars and their brightness
Stars are not on a flat screen
Stars that look close together in the sky may be very far apart in space. We see a flat, two-dimensional picture, but some stars in a pattern are much farther away than others.
Why: From Earth, we only see the direction of each star, not how far away it is. Working out distance takes calculation, and the lecturer said that comes later.
Star names
Most star names come from ancient Arabic, and modern astronomers still use many of them.
Betelgeuse (pronounced "bee-tuhl-joos") comes from the Arabic yad aljawza, which the slides translate as "armpit of Jawza". It is a very bright red supergiant in Orion, and much bigger than the Sun. For scale, the lecturer said the Sun itself could hold about 1 million Earths.
Greek letter names
Within a constellation, stars are ranked by brightness and given Greek letters. α (alpha) is the brightest, β (beta) the second brightest, then γ (gamma), δ (delta), and so on.
Why: It gives each star in a group its own label. The drawback is that there are far more stars than Greek letters, so the method only goes so far.
Keep the two systems apart. The proper names come from Arabic. The brightness letters come from Greek. The slides add that α Orionis is Betelgeuse and β Orionis is Rigel, and that in Orion, β is actually brighter than α.
"I want you to differentiate between these two things." Proper star names come from Arabic. The Greek letters rank stars by brightness inside a constellation.
The magnitude scale
The magnitude scale is astronomy's brightness scale. Hipparchus was the first to catalogue stars by brightness, and Ptolemy later used the same system. The larger the magnitude, the fainter the star.
Why: Hipparchus called the brightest stars "first magnitude" and dimmer ones second, third and so on. Think of it like a ranking where 1st is best. That is why bigger numbers mean fainter stars. Very bright objects go past zero into negative numbers.
- Flux is the flow of energy out of a surface. In other words, how much light is coming from an object.
- Apparent visual magnitude (
) is how bright a star looks to human eyes on Earth. - The lecturer once called this the "absolute magnitude scale". The slides, and the lecturer later on, say apparent visual magnitude. Absolute magnitude is a different quantity, so don't mix them up.
Values from the slides:
- Sun: −26.7
- Full Moon: −12.6
- Venus at its brightest: −4.4
- Sirius: −1.4
- Polaris: 2.0
- Naked-eye limit: 6.0
- Hubble Space Telescope limit: 30
The sign is the classic trap: "the larger the magnitude the fainter the star … It is really confusing." Brightest objects have the smallest (most negative) numbers. Faintest objects have the largest numbers. Also: "I want you to remember this name": Hipparchus.
Comparing magnitudes
To find how many magnitudes fainter one object is than another, subtract the brighter object's magnitude from the fainter one's. Keep the negative signs.
Why: Magnitude is a position on the brightness scale, so the gap between two positions tells you how far apart they are in brightness.
where
The full Moon has magnitude −12.6, and the Sun has magnitude −26.7.
-- the Moon is fainter, so subtract the Sun from it -- put the numbers in -- subtracting a negative means adding -- do the addition
Answer: the Moon is 14.1 magnitudes fainter than the Sun. The positive result confirms the Moon is the fainter one.
"Definitely, I will ask a question like that." And: "I'll give you the scale, I'll give you two objects, I will ask you to find out how one object is brighter than … How many time it's brighter than?" Give the answer in magnitudes, as the slide does. The lecturer said this shows the Sun is "14 times brighter", but a magnitude difference is not a "times" number.
Beyond this lecture: every 5 magnitudes is a factor of 100 in brightness, so 14.1 magnitudes is about
Astronomy versus astrology
Astronomy and astrology
Astronomy is the science of everything beyond Earth's atmosphere, such as planets, stars, asteroids and galaxies. It is based on research and observation. Astrology is the belief that the positions of stars and planets affect events on Earth and in your life.
Why: Astronomy uses the constellations to predict eclipses and planet movements, not your life. The lecturer said blaming the stars is a way of dodging responsibility, like blaming the prof for a bad grade: "You put the blame on me when you get a D."
Pseudoscience
Pseudoscience is a set of beliefs that appear to be based on scientific ideas but fail to obey the most basic rules of science.
Why: It looks and sounds like science and borrows real scientific words, like "nano", "solar" or "cosmic rays". But it never goes through the scientific method: test, validate, prove, predict. The lecturer's examples were online "nano devices" that claim to cure diseases or money problems, and rules about which way to point your head when you sleep.
"Astrology is called pseudoscience." The best way to define pseudoscience: "it will act like science, it will appear like science, it will use the exact scientific terms," but it is not science. "Every textbook in astronomy … will clearly say one thing. Astrology is not science."
The celestial sphere
The celestial sphere model
The celestial sphere is an imaginary sphere of very large radius around Earth. The stars seem to be attached to its inside surface. Earth sits fixed at its centre.
Why: It is one of the simplest possible models of the sky, so it is still useful for describing what we see. But it does not match what we now know about the cosmos. A scientific model is a concept that helps you think about nature and is not necessarily true. This links to "Models get replaced" from Lecture 1.
Three points from the slides:
- The sky's westward motion is caused by Earth's eastward rotation. (The lecturer first said it the other way round, that Earth spins east to west and the sky west to east, then corrected to this version. Go with the slides.)
- What the sky looks like depends on where you are on Earth.
- Distances across the sky are measured in degrees.
The lecturer stressed this more than once: "Keep in mind, this is a scientific model. This is not true, but we are still using it because it is one of the simplest model."
Celestial equator and poles
- Celestial equator: the imaginary line around the sky directly above Earth's equator.
- North and south celestial poles: the points on the celestial sphere directly above Earth's North and South Poles.
Angular distance
The distance between two stars on the celestial sphere can only be given as the angle between the directions in which we see them.
Why: We can't tell how far away each star is just by looking. So we measure how far apart they look, as an angle. Today you can just take a photo and measure the angle on it.
The units are degrees, arcminutes and arcseconds. The lecturer said plain degrees, minutes and seconds "represent angle", but with "arc" in front they represent "distance, not just angle": how far apart two objects look across the sky. They are still angles, so they do not tell you how far away the objects really are.
where
Estimating angles by hand
At arm's length, your hand is a rough angle ruler:
- A pinky finger is about 1°.
- Three middle fingers are about 5°.
- A clenched fist is about 10°.
The slide converts the three hand widths into arcminutes, using
-- pinky finger -- three fingers -- a fist
Answer: 60, 300 and 600 arcminutes. The lecturer said "300 arcseconds" for three fingers, but the slide's answer is 300 arcminutes.
Angular size
Angular size is how much of your view an object takes up, in degrees, arcminutes or arcseconds. Physical size is its real size, and distance is how far it is from you. If you know any two, you can find the third by rearranging the formula.
Why: Picture a full circle around you, with the object's distance as its radius. The object covers the same share of that circle's length (
where angular size is in degrees, and physical size and distance are in the same unit, for example km.
Rearranged to find the real size:
The slide works this one, but the lecturer did not work it in class. The lecturer only described the formula, then moved on to the quiz. The Moon looks about
-- put the numbers into the rearranged formula km -- the circumference of a circle with the Moon's distance as its radius km -- the length of one degree at the Moon's distance km -- multiply by the Moon's angular size
Answer: about 3300 km -- the slide's estimate of the Moon's real (physical) diameter, from how big it looks and how far away it is. (The measured diameter is about 3474 km. The estimate comes out low because the Moon is really about 0.52° across, not exactly 0.5°. For this course, 3300 km is the slide's answer.)
How the Sun will die
The lecturer ended with this, following up on stars and fusion from Lecture 2.
The Sun's end
A star shines by fusion, and as it gives off light it loses mass. In about 5 billion years, the Sun will run through its fuel and swell up. It will swallow Mercury and Venus, and probably Earth, possibly the Moon too. The lecturer added that "it might go to Mars". (Most references say the Sun will grow to about the size of Earth's orbit, around 1 AU. Mars, at about 1.5 AU, should survive.) What is left behind is a white dwarf. The lecturer compared it to a candle that flares up just before it goes out.
Why: A star lives off its fuel. Once the fuel runs low, it can't stay the same size.
Note (not from the lecture): the lecturer called today's Sun a "red giant" and said it will become a "supergiant". The standard textbook picture is that the Sun is an ordinary (main-sequence) star now, and will become a red giant near its end. Check this against the stars chapter in Week 7.
Exam checklist
- #Relativity: truck and ball; both observers are right, with constant speed.
- #Spacetime and expanding space: say "spacetime"; the space between galaxies expands.
- #Cosmic calendar: its purpose is to compare astronomical timescales with human experience.
- #Greek letter names: proper names are Arabic, brightness letters are Greek.
- #The magnitude scale: bigger number means fainter; remember Hipparchus.
- #Comparing magnitudes: subtract and keep the signs; the Moon is 14.1 magnitudes fainter than the Sun.
- #Pseudoscience: acts like science and uses its words, but fails its rules; astrology.
- #The celestial sphere model: a simple model that is not true, but still used.
Admin & deadlines
- Quiz 2 was done in class, with a password given out in the lecture.
- The lecturer joked that the Sun won't die "before your midterm". The midterm is on Monday, October 19, from 5:30 to 6:50 pm, in LH 3094.
Transcribed automatically from the lecture recording. Slides used: AS 101 - Ch. 02 - The Sky - Patterns, Cycles and Seasons (slides).pdf. Course info used: AS 101 - Syllabus - Fall 2026.pdf. Audio archived at /mnt/porsche/configs/lectures/archive/2026-09/AS 101 - 2026-09-21 - Lecture 03.opus.