EC 223 - 2026-09-22 - Lecture 04

EC 223 - Lecture 04 - 2026-09-22

Economics of the Canadian Banking and Financial System · Igor Antonio Araujo Carreira · LH 1009

Week 3 · 17:32-18:43 · 70 min · Full transcript · Flashcards

Overview

This lecture started Chapter 4 of Mishkin & Serletis, which is about how interest rates are measured. It began with present value, the tool for comparing cash flows that arrive at different times, and used it to define the yield to maturity for four kinds of credit instruments. It then showed that bond prices and yields move in opposite directions. The last part covered the rate of return and interest-rate risk: selling a bond before maturity can earn more or less than its yield, and long-term bonds are hit hardest when rates rise. The slides on real and nominal interest rates were not reached and will be finished next class.

Present value

Lecture 2 introduced debt instruments and maturity dates. This lecture shows how to value them.

Present value

Present value (or present discounted value) is what a future cash flow is worth today. It lets you compare assets that pay different amounts at different times, such as a bond paying $1,000 in one year and a bond paying $100 a year for 10 years.

Why: A dollar today is worth more than a dollar in a year. You can put today's dollar in a savings account and have more than a dollar later. For example, at 10% it becomes $1.10 in one year. Carreira also mentioned inflation as a reason, but set it aside until the end of the lecture.

Compounding a simple loan

A simple loan is repaid in one payment, principal plus interest, on the maturity date. With annual compounding, the amount owed grows by a factor of (1+i) each year.

Why: Each year the lender earns interest on everything owed so far, including last year's interest.

Payment after n years=Principal×(1+i)n

where i is the annual interest rate and n is the number of years.

Example: A $100 simple loan at 10%

A lender gives $100 today at i=10%. Find the repayment after one year and after two years.

  1. 100×(1+0.10)1=100×1.1 -- one year of compounding
  2. 100×1.1=110 -- repayment after one year
  3. 100×(1.10)2=100×1.1×1.1 -- for a two-year loan, n=2
  4. 100×1.21=121 -- repayment after two years

Answer: $110 after one year and $121 after two years. The extra $1 in year two is interest on the first year's interest.

Discounting a future cash flow

Discounting runs compounding backwards. You start from the future cash flow and divide out the interest to find what it is worth today. Carreira called the two directions the "flip side of the same coin." For a loan, the cash flow is the repayment and the present value is the amount lent today.

Why: If $100 today grows to $110, then $110 a year from now must be worth $100 today.

PV=CF(1+i)n

where PV is the value today, CF is the cash flow received n years from now, i is the annual discount rate, and n is the number of years until the cash flow arrives.

Example: Discounting $110 back one year

You know a loan will be repaid with $110 in one year and i=10%. How much was lent?

  1. PV=110(1+0.10)1 -- put the numbers into the formula
  2. PV=1101.1=100 -- divide

Answer: $100. That is the original loan, the same numbers as the compounding example in reverse.

Example: $250 due in two years at 15%

A simple loan has a repayment of $250 due two years from now, and i=15%. Find its present value.

  1. PV=250(1+0.15)2 -- put the numbers into the formula (n=2)
  2. (1.15)2=1.3225 -- work out the discount factor
  3. PV=2501.3225≈189.04 -- divide

Answer: About $189.04, which the class rounded to 189. It is less than $250 because future money is discounted.

Example: The same loan at a negative rate of -1%

Carreira then asked what happens if the interest rate is −1%. Negative rates came up in Lecture 1.

  1. 1+i=1+(−0.01)=0.99 -- a negative rate makes the factor less than 1
  2. PV=250(0.99)2 -- put the numbers into the formula
  3. (0.99)2=0.9801 -- work out the discount factor
  4. PV=2500.9801≈255.08 -- divide

Answer: About $255.08, which the class rounded to 255.1. With a negative rate, the present value is bigger than the cash flow: you borrow about $255 and repay only $250 two years later.

Credit market instruments

Every instrument is valued the same way. Only the pattern of cash flows changes.

Four types of instruments

Yield to maturity

Yield to maturity

The yield to maturity is the interest rate that makes the present value of all the promised cash flows from a debt instrument equal to its value today (its current price). It is the most important of the several ways to measure an interest rate.

Why: A price on its own tells you little. Carreira: "If I just tell you the price of a bond is $900, it usually doesn't mean much to you. But if I say that your yield to maturity is 5%, it's easier for you to compare with other bonds and other instruments."

Simple loans

A simple loan has only one cash flow, the repayment at maturity. You can therefore rearrange the present value formula and solve for i directly. For simple loans, the interest rate equals the yield to maturity.

Why: With one cash flow there is only one power of (1+i), so i can be isolated by hand or with a basic calculator.

PV=CF(1+i)n⟹i=(CFPV)1n−1

where PV is the amount borrowed (or the market price if the loan is traded), CF is the payment at maturity, and n is the number of years to maturity.

Made-up example: Yield on a two-year simple loan

You lend $100 today and are repaid $121 in two years. Find the yield to maturity.

  1. i=(121100)1/2−1 -- put the numbers into the formula
  2. 121100=1.21 -- divide
  3. (1.21)1/2=1.1 -- a power of 1/2 is a square root
  4. i=1.1−1=0.10 -- subtract 1

Answer: i=10%. This matches the compounding example, where $100 at 10% grew to $121.

Fixed-payment loans

A fixed-payment loan's present value is each fixed payment discounted by the number of periods until it is paid, all added up. The yield to maturity is the i that makes this sum equal the loan value.

Why: This is the same idea as always. Carreira: "In every sense, that's something I will reinforce. We just discount cash flows."

LV=FP1+i+FP(1+i)2+FP(1+i)3+⋯+FP(1+i)n

where LV is the loan value (or market price if traded), FP is the fixed payment per period, n is the number of payments, and i is the interest rate per period.

Because i appears raised to many different powers, you usually cannot solve for it by hand. You need a computer or a financial calculator.

Example: A $50,000 loan repaid in two payments of $25,000

You borrow $50,000 and repay $25,000 at the end of each of the next two years. Find the yield to maturity by looking at the numbers, not by solving.

  1. 50,000=25,0001+i+25,000(1+i)2 -- set the loan value equal to the discounted payments
  2. 25,000+25,000=50,000 -- the undiscounted payments already add up to the loan
  3. Try i=0: 25,0001+25,0001=50,000 -- with no discounting, the two sides match

Answer: i=0. Carreira said that with payments of $26,000 each instead, you would need a computer or a financial calculator.

Irregular payment timing

The formulas on the slides assume one cash flow per year. When the timing is different, keep the interest rate annual and make the exponent the time in years until each cash flow. For monthly payments, the exponents are 112,212,…,1212. For weekly payments, the step is 152.

Why: The exponent counts how many years of discounting a cash flow gets, so a payment one month away gets one-twelfth of a year of discounting.

PV=CF(1+i)t

where i is the annual rate and t is the time until the cash flow, measured in years (possibly a fraction).

Made-up example: A payment six months away

You will receive $1,000 in six months. The annual rate is 21%.

  1. t=612=12 -- six months is half a year
  2. PV=1000(1.21)1/2 -- put the numbers into the formula
  3. (1.21)1/2=1.1 -- square root
  4. PV=10001.1≈909.09 -- divide

Answer: About $909.09 today.

Made-up example: Growing cash flows

An asset pays $100 in one year and then 10% more ($110) in two years. The discount rate is 10%.

  1. PV=1001.1+110(1.1)2 -- discount each cash flow separately
  2. 1001.1≈90.91 -- first cash flow
  3. 1101.21≈90.91 -- second cash flow (1.12=1.21)
  4. 90.91+90.91=181.82 -- add them up

Answer: About $181.82. Each cash flow is discounted for its own time, then they are added.

Exam

Carreira: "People every time they ask, 'Oh, what could [you] ask in an exam?' Like, I could create these different structures of payments." Examples he gave were monthly payments, payments every 2 years or every 5 years, and cash flows that grow (such as $100, then $110, then $121). "That's something that you have to practice and think and understand... not just memorize that formula, because that formula is for a very simple case."

Discount bonds

A discount bond pays only its face value at maturity. It has one cash flow, just like a simple loan, so its yield can be solved directly.

Why: You buy it below face value, and the gap between the price and the face value is your whole return.

i=(FP)1n−1

where P is the current price, F is the face value, and n is the number of years to maturity.

Made-up example: A two-year zero-coupon bond

A bond pays $1,000 in two years and costs $640 today.

  1. i=(1000640)1/2−1 -- put the numbers into the formula
  2. 1000640=1.5625 -- divide
  3. (1.5625)1/2=1.25 -- square root
  4. i=1.25−1=0.25 -- subtract 1

Answer: i=25% per year.

Coupon bonds

A coupon bond's price is the present value of every coupon plus the face value at the end. The coupon is the coupon rate times the face value. With a 10% coupon rate and a $1,000 face value, C=100 every year.

Why: It is still just "discount the cash flows." A coupon bond is a string of coupons plus one final lump.

P=C1+i+C(1+i)2+C(1+i)3+⋯+C+F(1+i)n

where P is the market price, C is the yearly coupon payment, F is the face value, n is the years to maturity, and i is the yield to maturity.

Example: A 10%-coupon, 10-year bond priced at $1,200

The face value is $1,000, the coupon rate is 10%, the bond matures in 10 years, and the price is $1,200. Set up the equation for the yield to maturity.

  1. C=0.10×1000=100 -- the coupon is the coupon rate times the face value
  2. Years 1 to 9 each pay 100, discounted by (1+i)1 through (1+i)9 -- the coupon cash flows
  3. Year 10 pays 100+1000=1100, discounted by (1+i)10 -- the last coupon plus the face value
  4. 1200=1001+i+100(1+i)2+⋯+100(1+i)9+1100(1+i)10 -- the full equation
  5. Solve for i by computer: i=7.13% (Table 4-1)

Answer: The yield to maturity is 7.13%. It works both ways: plug i=7.13% into every term and you get back the price of $1,200.

Table 4-1: yields on a 10%-coupon bond maturing in 10 years, with a face value of $1,000.

Price of bond ($) Yield to maturity (%)
1200 7.13
1100 8.48
1000 10.00
900 11.75
800 13.81
Exam

"One thing that is very important and many, many people miss is that there is a coupon payment in the last period. If you're calculating, don't forget to add the C plus F at the last period. Don't put just the face value at the last payment." Carreira also said there are "two things that I could ask for, at least for you to lay down the equation": you are given the price and set up the equation for the yield, or you are given the yield and find the price.

Consols and current yield

A consol (perpetuity) is a coupon bond with no maturity date. It never repays the principal and pays a fixed coupon forever. Carreira said he thinks some still exist, especially in the UK. (In fact, the UK government redeemed its last consols in 2015, so do not rely on UK consols still existing.) The current yield is C/P, and for a consol it equals the yield to maturity.

Why: For a long-term coupon bond, the current yield is a good approximation of the yield to maturity. Cash flows far in the future are divided by a huge discount factor. For example, 10(1.03)1000 is almost zero. So a long coupon bond's far-off payments barely count, and it prices almost like a consol.

P=Ci⟹i=CP

where P is the consol's price, C is the yearly coupon, and i is its yield to maturity (equal to its current yield).

Made-up example: Pricing a consol and finding its yield

A consol pays $100 a year forever.

  1. At i=5%: P=1000.05=2000 -- the price when the yield is 5%
  2. If the price is instead $2,500: i=1002500=0.04 -- solve for the yield

Answer: At a 5% yield it costs $2,000. At a $2,500 price it yields 4%. The higher price comes with the lower yield.

Exam

A student asked whether a question could involve a consol with a call option (a clause letting the issuer buy it back). Carreira said: "No, no." That belongs in an options and futures course. This course is about "learning the basic instruments and how interest rates will affect them."

Using present value and yield to maturity

Choosing a lottery payout

The Daily Grand lottery pays $1,000 a day for life, or you can take $7 million today instead. Present value is the right way to compare the two options.

Why: The class listed what should drive the choice. First is the interest rate you could earn on the lump sum: at 0% you gain little by taking it, while at 10% you have more reason to take the $7 million now. Second is how long you expect to live. Third is risk: the $7 million is certain, but the stream depends on how long you live. Carreira left inflation out to keep the reasoning simple.

Example: Setting up the Daily Grand comparison

Treat the payments as yearly: 1000×365=365,000 per year. Assume you live another 50 years.

  1. Option A: 7,000,000 today -- no discounting needed
  2. Option B: 365,0001+i+365,000(1+i)2+⋯+365,000(1+i)50 -- discount each year's payments
  3. Compare the two values at the interest rate you could actually earn -- take whichever is larger

Answer: No number was worked out in class. The choice depends on i and on how long you expect to live.

Made-up example: The lottery stream as a perpetuity

To get numbers without a computer, pretend the $365,000 a year really lasts forever, and use the consol formula.

  1. At i=5%: 365,0000.05=7,300,000 -- worth more than $7 million
  2. At i=10%: 365,0000.10=3,650,000 -- worth much less than $7 million

Answer: Higher interest rates favour the lump sum. A limited lifespan makes the stream worth even less than these figures.

Price and yield move oppositely

A bond's price and its yield to maturity are negatively related. Saying "interest rates went up" usually means "bond prices went down." If you hold a bond and rates rise, you lose if you sell.

Why: The price is the discounted value of fixed cash flows. A higher discount rate shrinks every term, so the price falls. Table 4-1 shows this: as the price drops from $1,200 to $800, the yield climbs from 7.13% to 13.81%.

Exam

Carreira called this "one thing that I will reinforce later," and it came back in the rate-of-return and risk sections.

Coupon bond price facts

Three facts about coupon bonds that follow directly from the formula:

  1. When the price equals the face value, the yield to maturity equals the coupon rate.
  2. A higher price means a lower yield to maturity.
  3. When the price is below the face value, the yield is above the coupon rate. When the price is above the face value, the yield is below the coupon rate.

Why: At par, the coupon payments are exactly the interest payments. So the yield must equal the coupon rate. Moving the price away from par pushes the yield the opposite way. Carreira said: "You don't need to memorize this. If you know the formula... these are implications that you can see directly."

Made-up example: A two-year bond at two different yields

The bond has a face value of $1,000 and a 10% coupon (C=100), and matures in two years.

  1. At i=10%: P=1001.1+11001.21 -- the last payment is the coupon plus the face value
  2. 90.91+909.09=1000.00 -- priced at par, so the yield equals the coupon rate
  3. At i=5%: P=1001.05+11001.1025 -- lower the yield
  4. 95.24+997.73=1092.97 -- the price rises above par

Answer: At a 10% yield the price is $1,000. At a 5% yield it is $1,092.97. The price is above par exactly when the yield is below the coupon rate.

Facts for all bonds

These hold for every debt instrument, not just coupon bonds, and even for zero-coupon bonds:

Rate of return

Return versus yield to maturity

The yield to maturity is what you earn if you buy a bond and hold it until it matures. The rate of return is what you actually gain or lose from holding it for a given period. The two can differ if you sell before maturity. You then sell at whatever the market price is, and the market yield may have changed since you bought. A stock has no maturity, so for a stock you can only talk about its return.

Why: The return equals the yield to maturity only if you hold until maturity, or if interest rates do not change. If rates fall while you hold the bond, its price rises and you earn more than the yield. If rates rise, you earn less.

Exam

Carreira's warning: if you buy a 30-year government bond yielding 1% and an interest-rate spike forces you to sell, "maybe you have a very negative return... You will only earn 1% if you hold until maturity. So, bottom line, bonds can also be very risky."

Rate of return

The return over one period is the coupon plus the change in price, divided by the price you paid. It has two parts: the current yield (income) and the capital-gain rate.

Why: It counts everything you actually received: the coupon, and the profit or loss on resale.

R=CPt+Pt+1−PtPt

where C is the coupon received, Pt is the purchase price, Pt+1 is the price you sell at one period later, CPt is the current yield ic, and Pt+1−PtPt is the capital-gain rate. If the bond matures at t+1, then Pt+1 is the face value.

Example: Selling a 2-year bond after one year at $1,100

You buy a 2-year bond with a $1,000 face value and a 10% coupon for $1,000. You sell it after one year at the market price of $1,100.

  1. C=0.10×1000=100 -- coupon received
  2. Pt+1−Pt=1100−1000=100 -- capital gain
  3. R=100+1001000 -- total gain over the price paid
  4. R=2001000=0.20 -- divide

Answer: A 20% return, double the 10% yield, because the price rose.

Example: Selling the same bond at $900

Same bond, but you can only sell at $900 after one year.

  1. C=100 -- coupon received
  2. Pt+1−Pt=900−1000=−100 -- capital loss
  3. R=100+(−100)1000=01000 -- the coupon and the loss cancel

Answer: A 0% return. You earned the coupon but lost it all on the sale.

Example: Selling the same bond at $800

Same bond bought for $1,000, but you need the money and must sell after one year at $800.

  1. R=1001000+800−10001000 -- put the numbers into the formula
  2. R=0.10+−2001000=0.10−0.20 -- current yield plus capital-gain rate
  3. R=−0.10 -- add

Answer: A return of -10%, even though the bond's yield to maturity was 10%.

Example: A 1-year bond held to maturity

A bond with a $1,000 face value and a 10% coupon matures in one year. You buy it at par ($1,000) and hold it to maturity, so Pt+1 is the face value.

  1. R=1001000+1000−10001000 -- you receive the coupon plus the face value
  2. R=0.10+0=0.10 -- no capital gain

Answer: A 10% return, equal to the yield to maturity. You bought at par and held to maturity. "Bought at par" means you paid the face value. Carreira also noted that holding the 2-year version to maturity earns $200 over two years, 10% a year, again equal to the yield to maturity.

Interest-rate risk

Longer maturities are more sensitive

When interest rates rise, long-term bonds lose far more value than short-term bonds. Holding other characteristics constant, the longer the maturity, the bigger the percentage price change and the lower the return after a rate rise. Even a bond with a high initial yield can have a negative return if rates rise.

Why: A long bond has many more cash flows in the future, and a rate rise shrinks every one of them. Carreira put it this way: "There are a bunch of cash flows. So any movement in your interest rate will affect all these cash flows."

Table 4-2 (slides): bonds all bought at $1,000 with a 10% current yield, after interest rates rise. Carreira did not remember the size of the rise, but believed it was the same for every maturity.

Years to maturity Price next year ($) Capital gain (%) Return (%)
30 503 -49.7 -39.7
20 516 -48.4 -38.4
10 597 -40.3 -30.3
5 741 -25.9 -15.9
2 917 -8.3 +1.7
1 1000 0.0 +10.0
Example: Returns on the 2-year and 30-year rows

Each bond pays a coupon of $100 and was bought for $1,000. Use the next-year prices from the table.

  1. 2-year: R=1001000+917−10001000 -- put the numbers into the formula
  2. R=0.10−0.083=0.017 -- a small capital loss
  3. 30-year: R=1001000+503−10001000 -- the same rate rise
  4. R=0.10−0.497=−0.397 -- a huge capital loss

Answer: The 2-year bond returns +1.7% and the 30-year bond returns -39.7%. The 1-year bond matures at $1,000 and still earns its full 10%.

Made-up example: Where the 2-year price of $917 comes from

Carreira did not say how far rates rose. Suppose the market rate rose from 10% to 20%. After one year, the 2-year bond has one payment left: $1,100 (the last coupon plus the face value), due in one year.

  1. Pt+1=11001+0.20 -- discount the last payment at the new rate
  2. Pt+1=11001.2≈916.67 -- divide

Answer: About $917, which is the slide's figure. Every other row of the table also fits a rise from 10% to 20%, but Carreira did not state the size of the rise in class.

Interest-rate risk

Interest-rate risk is the uncertainty about an asset's holding-period return caused by changes in market interest rates. Prices and returns on long-term bonds are more volatile than on otherwise similar short-term bonds. There is no interest-rate price risk if the bond's maturity matches your holding period.

Why: If you hold to maturity, you get exactly the promised cash flows no matter what happens to rates. The risk only bites when you have to sell early at the market price.

Exam checklist

Admin & deadlines


Transcribed automatically from the lecture recording. Slides used: EC 223 - 2026-09-22 - Lecture 04 - The Meaning of Interest Rates (slides).pdf. Course info used: EC 223 - Syllabus - Fall 2026.pdf. Audio archived at /mnt/porsche/configs/lectures/archive/2026-09/EC 223 - 2026-09-22 - Lecture 04.opus.