EC 270 - 2026-09-22 - Lecture 04

EC 270 - Lecture 04 - 2026-09-22

Intermediate Microeconomics I · Logan McLeod · LH 1011

Week 3 · 11:30-12:50 · recording lost, slides + your hand notes · Flashcards

Written from the slides and your hand notes

The recording of this lecture was lost (the file saved empty). Your six pages of hand notes from class were merged in on 2026-09-24. Anything marked "from class" comes from those notes. It was checked against the slides where the slides cover it, and the math was redone where they do not. Examples marked "Made-up" and the practice-question working were written for these notes, and the admin dates come from the syllabus. Everything else comes from the slides.

Overview

The recording of this lecture was lost, so these notes come from the slides and your hand notes from class. Chapter 4 turns the preference relations from Chapter 3 into numbers, using a utility function that gives higher numbers to preferred bundles. The deck shows that utility only ranks bundles, so any order-preserving (monotonic) transformation of a utility function describes the same preferences. It then walks through four standard utility functions, and uses partial derivatives to define marginal utility and the marginal rate of substitution (MRS), which is the slope of an indifference curve.

Utility functions

This picks up straight from Lecture 03. The deck opens by recapping strict preference, indifference, weak preference and the three axioms (completeness, reflexivity, transitivity) before building on them.

Utility function

A utility function U(x1,x2) gives each bundle a number, so that a strictly preferred bundle gets a higher number and indifferent bundles get the same number. A preference relation can be represented by a continuous utility function if it is complete, reflexive, transitive, and continuous. The last condition, continuity, is new compared with the three axioms from Lecture 03. (Your hand notes say the three axioms are enough; the slides list continuity as a fourth condition.)

Why: Numbers are much easier to work with than preference symbols. Once preferences are a function, calculus can be used to find the best bundle, which is where Chapter 5 is heading.

(x1,x2)≻(y1,y2)⟺U(x1,x2)>U(y1,y2)(x1,x2)≺(y1,y2)⟺U(x1,x2)<U(y1,y2)(x1,x2)∼(y1,y2)⟺U(x1,x2)=U(y1,y2)

where (x1,x2) and (y1,y2) are two bundles, ≻ is strict preference, ≺ is "less preferred than", ∼ is indifference, and ⟺ means "if and only if".

Utility is ordinal

Utility is an ordinal concept, which means it only tells you the order of bundles. The size of the gap between two utility numbers means nothing.

Why: Preferences only say which bundle is better, not by how much. So a utility function cannot carry more information than the preferences it comes from.

Example: what a utility of 6 versus 2 tells you

Suppose U(x1,x2)=6 and U(y1,y2)=2.

  1. 6>2 -- the first bundle has the higher utility number.
  2. U(x1,x2)>U(y1,y2)⇒(x1,x2)≻(y1,y2) -- a higher number means strictly preferred.

Answer: (x1,x2)≻(y1,y2) -- but (x1,x2) is not preferred three times as much, because utility only ranks.

Exam

From class, per your hand notes, which star it: "This is an ordinal concept, so you cannot say (x1,x2) is 3 times as preferred as (y1,y2)." The slides also put "Utility is an ordinal (i.e. ordering) concept" in bold and warn against the mistake of reading the numbers as amounts: "(x1,x2) is not preferred three times as much as is (y1,y2)."

Utility levels and indifference curves

Example: assigning utility levels to three bundles

The bundles are (4,1), (2,3) and (2,2), with preferences (2,3)≻(4,1)∼(2,2). Your hand notes show this one was also done in class.

  1. (2,3) is the best bundle, so give it the highest number: U(2,3)=6 -- any number works if the order holds.
  2. (4,1)∼(2,2), so they need the same, lower number: U(4,1)=U(2,2)=4 -- indifferent bundles share a level.
  3. Check: 6>4=4 -- the order matches the preferences.

Answer: U(2,3)=6>U(4,1)=U(2,2)=4 -- so (4,1) and (2,2) sit on the U=4 indifference curve, and (2,3) sits on the higher U=6 curve.

Indifference map in 3D

The slides tilt the indifference map flat and add a vertical axis for utility. The utility function then becomes a surface rising above the x1-x2 plane, and each indifference curve is the set of points at one height on that surface. The bundles (2,2) and (4,1) sit at height 4, and (2,3) sits at height 6.

Why: It shows where indifference curves come from. They are like contour lines on a hiking map, where every point on one line is at the same height (the same utility).

Monotonic transformations

There is no unique utility function for a given set of preferences. If U represents the preferences and f is strictly increasing, then f(U) represents the same preferences. A monotonic transformation turns one set of numbers into another set while keeping their order. Technically it is a positive monotonic transformation.

Why: Utility only ranks bundles, so any change that keeps the ranking, such as squaring positive numbers or doubling and adding 10, leaves the preferences exactly as they were.

From class, per your hand notes: positive monotonic transformations give "the set of all utility functions for a preference set". So any two utility functions for the same preferences are positive monotonic transformations of each other.

V=f(U) represents ⪰ whenever df(U)dU>0

where U is the original utility function, f is the transformation, and df(U)dU>0 means f is strictly increasing.

Example: squaring the utility function

Start with U(x1,x2)=x1x2 and define V(x1,x2)=(U(x1,x2))2=x12x22. Use the bundles (2,3), (4,1) and (2,2).

  1. U(2,3)=2×3=6, U(4,1)=4×1=4, U(2,2)=2×2=4 -- original levels.
  2. V(2,3)=22×32=4×9=36 -- square each part.
  3. V(4,1)=42×12=16×1=16
  4. V(2,2)=22×22=4×4=16
  5. 36>16=16 -- the same order as 6>4=4.

Answer: V ranks the bundles exactly as U does -- so V represents the same preferences.

Example: doubling and adding 10

Define W(x1,x2)=2U(x1,x2)+10=2x1x2+10, using the same three bundles.

  1. W(2,3)=(2×2×3)+10=12+10=22
  2. W(4,1)=(2×4×1)+10=8+10=18
  3. W(2,2)=(2×2×2)+10=8+10=18
  4. 22>18=18 -- the same order as U and V.

Answer: W also represents the same preferences -- U, V and W are three different utility functions for one preference relation.

Example: a transformation that does not work (from class)

In class the question was "Can you just use any values?" Any numbers work, as long as the ordering is kept. Your hand notes then try G(x1,x2)=−U(x1,x2)=−x1x2 on the same three bundles, where (2,3)≻(4,1)∼(2,2). Your notes stop at the three numbers, so step 4 and the answer were worked out here.

  1. G(2,3)=−(2×3)=−6
  2. G(4,1)=−(4×1)=−4
  3. G(2,2)=−(2×2)=−4
  4. −6<−4 -- G gives the best bundle the lowest number.

Answer: G does not represent these preferences -- it keeps (4,1)∼(2,2), but it ranks (2,3) worst instead of best. Multiplying by −1 reverses the order, which is why only a positive (strictly increasing) monotonic transformation works.

Exam

The flag comes from the slides. Your hand notes record "No unique utility function" from class but do not star it. The slides put "There is no unique utility function representation of a preference relation" in bold, and they end the section on the question "What do we conclude?", with the answer that any strictly increasing f(U) represents the same preferences.

Examples of utility functions

With utility defined, the slides give four standard utility functions, each with its own indifference curve shape.

Perfect substitutes

The consumer regards x1 and x2 as equivalent, so one unit of either is equally good. The indifference curves are straight, parallel lines, and here they have a slope of −1.

Why: If the goods are interchangeable one for one, you will always give up exactly one unit of one good for one more unit of the other. That constant trade is a straight line.

U(x1,x2)=x1+x2

where x1 and x2 are the quantities of the two goods.

left=0; right=16; bottom=0; top=16
---
y=8-x|x>0
y=12-x|x>0
y=15-x|x>0

x is x1 and y is x2. The lines are the indifference curves for U=8, U=12 and U=15.

Made-up example: comparing two bundles

With U(x1,x2)=x1+x2, compare (3,5) and (6,1).

  1. U(3,5)=3+5=8 -- add the quantities.
  2. U(6,1)=6+1=7
  3. 8>7 -- compare the levels.

Answer: (3,5)≻(6,1) -- only the total number of units matters, not how it is split between the goods.

Perfect complements

The two goods are always consumed together in fixed proportions, for example 1 to 1. All the indifference curves are right-angled (L-shaped), with their corners on a ray from the origin. For 1-to-1 goods, that ray is the 45-degree line.

Why: Extra units of only one good are useless without more of the other, so utility depends only on whichever good you have less of.

U(x1,x2)=min{x1,x2}

where min{x1,x2} is the smaller of the two quantities.

Example: utility levels for perfect complements

The slides list bundles for U(x1,x2)=min{x1,x2}.

  1. min{1,1}=1 -- the corner of the U=1 curve.
  2. min{1,2}=1 and min{1,3}=1 -- more x2 alone adds nothing.
  3. min{2,1}=1 and min{3,1}=1 -- more x1 alone adds nothing.
  4. min{2,2}=2 -- more of both reaches the next curve.
  5. min{2,3}=2 -- still on the U=2 curve.

Answer: (1,1), (1,2), (1,3), (2,1) and (3,1) all give U=1, and (2,2) and (2,3) give U=2 -- this traces out L-shaped curves with corners at (1,1) and (2,2).

Quasilinear preferences

The utility function is linear in one good and non-linear in the other. Each indifference curve is a vertically shifted copy of the others.

Why: Because x2 just adds on, raising utility by some amount just means adding that much x2 at every value of x1. That moves the whole curve straight up.

U(x1,x2)=f(x1)+x2

where f(x1) is some non-linear function of x1. The slides use U(x1,x2)=2x1+x2.

Made-up example: the vertical shift

With U(x1,x2)=2x1+x2, compare (4,1) and (4,3).

  1. U(4,1)=24+1=2×2+1=5
  2. U(4,3)=24+3=4+3=7
  3. 7−5=2 -- the utility gap equals the extra x2.

Answer: At the same x1, two more units of x2 raise utility by exactly 2 -- so the higher curve is the lower one shifted straight up.

Cobb-Douglas preferences

A utility function where each good is raised to a positive power and the results are multiplied. The powers c and d are read as preference weights. All Cobb-Douglas indifference curves are hyperbolic, which means they get closer and closer to both axes but never touch them.

Why: If either good is zero, the product is zero. So staying at a positive utility level means always having some of both goods, and the curve can never reach an axis.

U(x1,x2)=x1cx2d,c>0,d>0

where c is the weight on x1 and d is the weight on x2. The slides' examples are x112x212, x1x23 and x114x234.

Made-up example: a Cobb-Douglas utility level

With U(x1,x2)=x112x212, find the utility of (4,9).

  1. U(4,9)=412×912 -- put in the numbers.
  2. =4×9=2×3 -- a power of one half is a square root.
  3. =6

Answer: U(4,9)=6 -- every bundle on the same indifference curve as (4,9) also gives 6.

Marginal utility and the MRS

This section uses the partial derivatives and total differentiation from the Mathematical Appendix to measure how utility changes along each good and along an indifference curve.

Marginal utility

Marginal means incremental. The marginal utility of good i is the rate of change of total utility as the amount of good i changes, holding the other good fixed. It is the slope of the utility function in the direction of that good.

Why: It answers the slides' question: "how much extra utility do you get if you consume one more unit of xi?" The answer is MUi. Your hand notes from class put it as "How does level of utility change as quantity changes".

MUi=∂U(x1,x2)∂xi

where MUi is the marginal utility of good i, and ∂ means a partial derivative (differentiate in xi, treating the other good as a constant).

Example: marginal utilities of a Cobb-Douglas function

Take U(x1,x2)=x112x212.

  1. MU1=∂U∂x1=(12x1−12)×(x212) -- power rule on x1, with x212 treated as a constant.
  2. MU2=∂U∂x2=(x112)×(12x2−12) -- power rule on x2, with x112 treated as a constant.

Answer: MU1=12x1−12x212 and MU2=12x112x2−12 -- each marginal utility depends on how much of both goods you have.

Example: marginal utilities of U=x112x22 (from class)

Your hand notes work this one in class. Take U(x1,x2)=x112x22. The slides' example just above uses x212, so this is either a second example from class or a copying slip. The working is right either way. When you take the partial derivative with respect to x1, treat x2 as a constant, and the other way round.

  1. MU1=∂U∂x1=(12x1−12)×(x22) -- power rule on x112, with x22 held constant.
  2. MU2=∂U∂x2=(x112)×(2x2)=2x112x2 -- power rule on x22, with x112 held constant.
  3. MRS=−MU1MU2=−12x1−12x222x112x2 -- one step past your notes, using the MRS rule below.
  4. =−14x1−1x2=−x24x1 -- divide the numbers (12÷2=14), then subtract the powers: −12−12=−1 for x1 and 2−1=1 for x2.

Answer: MU1=12x1−12x22 and MU2=2x112x2, so MRS=−x24x1 -- at any bundle this is a quarter of the x1x2 slope, because x2 carries a much heavier weight than x1 (2 against 12), so the curves are flatter.

Made-up example: evaluating those marginal utilities

Use the same U(x1,x2)=x112x212 at the bundle (4,9).

  1. MU1=12×4−12×912=12×12×3 -- a power of minus one half is one over the square root.
  2. =34
  3. MU2=12×412×9−12=12×2×13
  4. =13

Answer: MU1=34 and MU2=13 -- at (4,9), one more unit of x1 adds about 0.75 utility, and one more unit of x2 adds about 0.33.

Marginal rate of substitution

An indifference curve is all the bundles with a given utility level, U(x1,x2)=U~. The MRS is the rate at which the consumer will substitute one good for the other while staying on that curve, and it measures the slope of the indifference curve. In words: for one extra unit of x1, how many units of x2 are you willing to give up to keep utility at U~?

Why: Along the curve, the utility gained from the extra x1 must exactly cancel the utility lost from giving up x2. That balance is what sets the slope.

Exam

From class, per your hand notes, which open the MRS examples with a starred line: "Slope of indifference curves really important." The MRS is that slope, found with MRS=−MU1MU2.

Deriving the MRS

Totally differentiate U(x1,x2)=U~. Because utility is held constant, the total change in utility is zero. Then solve for dx2dx1.

Why: Total differentiation asks how x1 and x2 can change together (the changes dx1 and dx2) while utility stays at U~. That describes a move along the indifference curve.

∂U(x1,x2)∂x1dx1+∂U(x1,x2)∂x2dx2=0MRS=dx2dx1=−MU1MU2

where dx1 and dx2 are small changes in each good, and MU1 and MU2 are the marginal utilities.

Made-up example: MRS from marginal utilities

Using the marginal utilities found above at (4,9) for U=x112x212: MU1=34 and MU2=13.

  1. MRS=−MU1MU2=−3/41/3 -- put in the numbers.
  2. =−34×3=−94 -- dividing by 13 means multiplying by 3.

Answer: MRS=−94=−2.25 -- at (4,9), the consumer is willing to give up x2 at a rate of 2.25 units per extra unit of x1 (this is the slope at that point, so it is exact only for small changes).

MRS for Cobb-Douglas

For Cobb-Douglas utility, the MRS is not constant. It depends on the bundle (x1,x2). Your hand notes from class write this in capitals: "MRS is NOT constant for Cobb-Douglas utility".

Why: The curves bend. They are steep where you have little x1 and lots of x2, and flat where it is the other way round.

Example: MRS of U=x1x2

Take U(x1,x2)=x1x2. Your hand notes show this one was also worked in class.

  1. MU1=∂U∂x1=(1)(x2)=x2 -- treat x2 as a constant.
  2. MU2=∂U∂x2=(x1)(1)=x1 -- treat x1 as a constant.
  3. MRS=−MU1MU2=−x2x1
  4. At (1,8): MRS=−81=−8 -- on the U=8 curve.
  5. At (6,6): MRS=−66=−1 -- on the U=36 curve.

Answer: MRS=−x2x1 -- the curve is very steep at (1,8) and has a slope of −1 at (6,6).

left=0; right=14; bottom=0; top=16
---
y=8/x|x>0
y=36/x|x>0
y=16-8x|x>0
y=12-x|x>0
(1,8)|label:MRS = -8
(6,6)|label:MRS = -1

x is x1 and y is x2. The curves are U=8 and U=36, and the straight lines are the tangents at (1,8) and (6,6).

MRS for quasilinear utility

For quasilinear utility, the MRS does not depend on x2. So the MRS is the same along any vertical line where x1 is fixed, on every indifference curve.

Why: The curves are vertical shifts of each other, so at a given x1 they all have the same slope.

Example: MRS of U=2x1+x2

Take U(x1,x2)=2x1+x2. Your hand notes show this one was also worked in class.

  1. MU1=∂U∂x1=2×12x1−12=x1−12 -- power rule on 2x112; the x2 term gives 0, because it does not change when x1 changes (your red note).
  2. MU2=∂U∂x2=1 -- x2 enters linearly; the 2x1 term gives 0, because it does not change when x2 changes (your red note).
  3. MRS=−MU1MU2=−x1−121=−x1−12

Answer: MRS=−x1−12=−1x1 (the form in your hand notes) -- there is no x2 in it.

Made-up example: same MRS on two curves

With MRS=−x1−12, compare the bundles (4,1) and (4,10).

  1. At (4,1): MRS=−14=−12
  2. At (4,10): MRS=−14=−12 -- the value of x2 never enters.

Answer: Both bundles have MRS=−12 -- they are on different indifference curves, but the slope is the same at x1=4.

MRS for perfect substitutes

For perfect substitutes, the MRS is a constant. It is the same at every bundle, on every indifference curve.

Why: The indifference curves are straight lines, and a straight line has the same slope everywhere.

Example: MRS of U=x1+x2 (from class)

Your hand notes work this one in class. Take U(x1,x2)=x1+x2.

  1. MU1=∂U∂x1=1 -- x1 enters linearly, and x2 is held constant.
  2. MU2=∂U∂x2=1 -- the same for x2.
  3. MRS=−MU1MU2=−11=−1

Answer: MRS=−1 at every bundle -- the consumer always trades the goods one for one, which is the slope of −1 on the slides.

Made-up example: substitutes with different weights

Your hand notes say perfect substitutes "all have slope −1", which matches the slides: they define perfect substitutes as goods the consumer regards as equivalent, like x1+x2. The textbook uses a wider definition, where the goods can trade at any constant rate, such as U(x1,x2)=2x1+x2, where one unit of x1 is worth two units of x2.

  1. MU1=∂U∂x1=2 and MU2=∂U∂x2=1
  2. MRS=−MU1MU2=−21=−2

Answer: MRS=−2 -- the indifference curves are still straight, parallel lines, but they are steeper than −1.

MRS and monotonic transformations

A positive monotonic transformation does not change the MRS. That fits with the earlier result: a transformed utility function represents the same preferences, so it must give the same indifference curves and the same slopes.

Why: By the chain rule, both marginal utilities get multiplied by the same factor ∂f∂U. That factor cancels when you divide one by the other.

MRS=−∂V/∂x1∂V/∂x2=−∂f∂U∂U∂x1∂f∂U∂U∂x2=−MU1MU2

where V=f(U(x1,x2)), f is strictly increasing, and ∂f∂U is how fast f rises with U. (The slide drops the minus sign in the middle steps but has it in the final result.)

Example: MRS of the squared utility function

Take U(x1,x2)=x1x2 and f(U)=U2, so V(x1,x2)=x12x22. The MRS of U is already known to be −x2x1. Your hand notes show this one was also worked in class.

  1. ∂V∂x1=2x1x22 -- power rule on x12.
  2. ∂V∂x2=2x12x2 -- power rule on x22.
  3. MRS=−2x1x222x12x2 -- divide the two.
  4. =−x2x1 -- cancel the 2, one x1 and one x2.

Answer: The MRS of V is −x2x1, the same as for U -- the transformation changed the utility numbers but not the indifference curves.

Exam

From class, per your hand notes, which mark the two answers "equal!" and conclude: "any utility function that is a positive monotonic transformation of the other, MRS is the same." The slides also end this example with the bold line "The MRS for V(x1,x2) is the same as the MRS for U(x1,x2)" and the rule "The MRS is unchanged by a positive monotonic transformation."

Practice questions

The last content slide poses four questions but does not answer them. The working below is from these notes, not from the slides.

Made-up example: Cobb-Douglas curve through (6, 16)

For U(x1,x2)=x1x2, an indifference curve passes through (6,16) and (2,x2). Find x2, and find the MRS at (6,16).

  1. U(6,16)=6×16=96 -- the utility level of this curve.
  2. 2×x2=96 -- the second bundle must give the same utility.
  3. x2=962=48
  4. MRS=−x2x1=−166=−83 -- the Cobb-Douglas MRS from above, at (6,16).

Answer: x2=48, and the MRS at (6,16) is −83≈−2.67 -- at that bundle, the consumer gives up about 2.67 units of x2 for one more unit of x1.

Made-up example: perfect complements curve through (6, 16)

For U(x1,x2)=min{x1,x2}, an indifference curve passes through (6,16) and (2,x2). Find x2, and find the MRS at (6,16).

  1. U(6,16)=min{6,16}=6 -- the utility level of this curve.
  2. min{2,x2}≤2 for any x2 -- with only 2 units of x1, utility can never be above 2.
  3. 2<6 -- so no bundle with x1=2 reaches this curve.
  4. At (6,16), x2>x1, so the bundle is on the vertical arm of the L -- extra x2 adds nothing, so MU2=0 and MU1=1.
  5. MRS=−MU1MU2=−10 -- dividing by zero.

Answer: No value of x2 works, because the curve through (6,16) never reaches x1=2. The MRS at (6,16) is undefined, because the indifference curve is vertical (infinitely steep) there.

Exam checklist

Flagged by the slides, and in class where it says so (from your hand notes).

Admin & deadlines

From class, per your hand notes: tutorial questions, and a reminder that the assignment is due Sunday ("so do that!!"). That is Assignment 1, due Sunday, September 27. The rest comes from the syllabus.


Written from the slides, because the recording was lost; your hand notes from class (six photographed pages) were merged in on 2026-09-24. Slides used: EC 270 - Ch. 04 - Utility (slides).pdf. Course info used: EC 270 - Math Appendix (slides).pdf, EC 270 - Rules of Derivatives.pdf, EC 270 - Syllabus - Fall 2026.pdf.