EC 270 - 2026-09-24 - Lecture 05

EC 270 - Lecture 05 - 2026-09-24

Intermediate Microeconomics I · Logan McLeod · LH 1011

Week 3 · 11:30-12:44 · 74 min · Full transcript · Flashcards

Overview

This lecture finished Chapter 4 with two practice questions, one Cobb-Douglas and one perfect complements, then started Chapter 5: Choice. Chapter 5 joins the budget constraint from Chapter 2 with the preferences and utility from Chapters 3 and 4. It asks how a consumer picks the best bundle they can afford. McLeod set up the consumer's problem and defined ordinary demand. He then gave the two conditions for an interior solution: the budget is spent, and the indifference curve is tangent to the budget line. He finished by solving for Cobb-Douglas demands by direct substitution, and left the Lagrange method for Tuesday.

Chapter 4 practice questions

These two questions close out Chapter 4. They use the utility functions and the MRS from the last lecture.

Bundles on one indifference curve

Every bundle on the same indifference curve gives the same level of utility, called u¯ ("U bar"). So if two bundles share a curve, you can set their utilities equal and solve for a missing quantity.
Why: An indifference curve is, by definition, the set of bundles the consumer likes equally. In utility terms, that means they all give the same number.

u(x1A,x2A)=u(x1B,x2B)=u¯

where A and B are two bundles on the same curve, and u¯ is that curve's utility level.

Example: Finding a missing quantity with u=x1x2

The utility function is u(x1,x2)=x1x2, which is Cobb-Douglas with both powers equal to 1. The bundles (6,16) and (2,x2) lie on the same indifference curve. Find x2.

  1. u(6,16)=6×16=96 -- the utility of the bundle we fully know
  2. u¯=96 -- so this curve is the one where utility equals 96
  3. u(2,x2)=2x2=96 -- the second bundle must give the same utility
  4. x2=96/2=48 -- solve for x2

Answer: x2=48 -- the bundle (2,48) is on the same curve as (6,16). With less good 1, the consumer needs much more good 2 to stay equally happy.

left=0; right=20; bottom=0; top=60
---
y=96/x|x>0
(6,16)|label:(6, 16)
(2,48)|label:(2, 48)

Here x is the quantity of good 1 and y is the quantity of good 2. The curve is the indifference curve where x1x2=96.

MRS at a bundle

The marginal rate of substitution (MRS) is the slope of the indifference curve. It is the amount of good 2 the consumer is willing to give up for one more unit of good 1. You find it from the two marginal utilities, and then plug in the bundle to get the slope at that point.
Why: Marginal utility is how much extra utility one more unit of a good gives you. The ratio of the two marginal utilities tells you how many units of good 2 are worth one unit of good 1 to this consumer.

MRS=−MU1MU2

where MU1=∂u∂x1 and MU2=∂u∂x2 are the partial derivatives of the utility function with respect to each good.

Example: MRS of u=x1x2 at (6,16)

Same utility function as above. Find the MRS at the bundle (6,16).

  1. MU1=∂(x1x2)∂x1=x2 -- treat x2 as a constant; the derivative of x1 is 1
  2. MU2=∂(x1x2)∂x2=x1 -- same idea, with x1 held constant
  3. MRS=−MU1MU2=−x2x1 -- the general MRS for this function
  4. MRS(6,16)=−166=−83 -- plug in the bundle and simplify

Answer: MRS=−83 -- at (6,16) the consumer is willing to give up 83 (about 2.67) units of good 2 for one more unit of good 1.

Exam

A student first answered "partial derivative of X1 divided by the partial derivative..." and McLeod said "So close." The MRS is −MU1/MU2, the ratio of the marginal utilities. It is not a ratio of derivatives of the goods themselves. Also, always simplify: "like any good economist, we always simplify wherever we can."

When bundles cannot share a curve

With perfect complements, u=min{x1,x2}, utility is set by whichever good you have less of. Two bundles can only be on the same indifference curve if their smaller quantities match.
Why: The consumer wants the goods in a fixed 1 to 1 ratio. Any extra of one good beyond that ratio adds nothing, so only the smaller amount counts.

Example: (6,16) and (2,x2) with u=min{x1,x2}

Same two bundles as before, but now with perfect complements. Can they be on the same indifference curve?

  1. u(6,16)=min{6,16}=6 -- the first bundle is on the curve where utility equals 6
  2. u(2,x2)=min{2,x2}≤2 -- whatever x2 is, utility can be at most 2
  3. 2<6 -- the second bundle can never reach utility 6

Answer: There is no answer. The question cannot be solved, because under these preferences the two bundles can never be on the same indifference curve.

The three slopes of an L-shaped curve

A perfect complements indifference curve is L-shaped, with its corner on the ray x2=x1. It has three different slopes, depending on where you are on it:

Why: A vertical line has an infinite slope and a horizontal line has zero slope. A corner has no single slope, so it is undefined.

Example: MRS of u=min{x1,x2} at (6,16)

Find the slope of the indifference curve through (6,16).

  1. min{6,16}=6 -- the curve's corner is at (6,6)
  2. 16>6, so x2>x1 -- the bundle is above the corner, on the vertical part

Answer: MRS=−∞ -- at (6,16) the consumer already has more good 2 than they can use, so a little less good 2 would not lower their utility at all, and the curve is vertical there.

Exam

A student answered "undefined or infinity". McLeod called that only "partially correct" because it gave two answers. You have to say which part of the L the bundle is on. He picked these two examples on purpose: "we don't just want to blindly plow through math... you need to sometimes think a little bit logically about what is the model telling us." He said this is "a theme that will come up as we go through the term." Cobb-Douglas lets you "just plow ahead with the math", but with other preferences, like perfect complements, blind math gives nonsense.

Choice

Chapter 5 pulls everything together. The budget constraint (Chapter 2) says what the consumer "can afford", and preferences and utility (Chapters 3 and 4) say what is "most preferred".

Economic rationality

Economists assume consumers choose the most preferred bundle of goods they can afford. That means the bundle on the highest indifference curve that is still in the budget set.
Why: On the budget line, every bundle costs the same. If one of those bundles is on a higher indifference curve, the consumer gets more utility for the same money, so they should pick it.

In class, the slide showed the budget line from (0,4) to (4,0) with indifference curves on top, plus two bundles on the line. The blue bundle was at (2,2) and the orange bundle was at (3,1). The orange bundle is on a lower indifference curve. Both cost the same, so the consumer picks the blue one. The blue one is where an indifference curve just touches the budget line, which is a tangency. Every bundle the consumer likes more than the blue one lies above that curve, and so it is outside the budget.

left=0; right=5; bottom=0; top=5
---
y=4-x|x>0
(2,2)|label:Blue (optimal)
(3,1)|label:Orange

Here x is the quantity of good 1 and y is the quantity of good 2. The line is the budget line from the slide. The slide's indifference curves are not drawn here, because the slide gave no equations for them.

The consumer's problem

The consumer solves a constrained optimization problem. They choose x1 and x2 to reach the highest utility they can, subject to the budget constraint.
Why: Without a budget, they would always want more. The budget is what stops them, so the best they can do is the highest curve that still touches the budget set.

maxx1,x2u(x1,x2)s.t.p1x1+p2x2≤m

where u is the utility function, p1 and p2 are the prices, m is income, and "s.t." means "subject to".

The slide compares three bundles:

The star marks the optimal value, the one that makes the consumer as well off as possible.

Ordinary demand

The ordinary demand, also called Marshallian demand after the economist Marshall, is the most preferred affordable bundle at given prices and income. It is usually not a single number but a function of prices and income.
Why: If you change a price or income, the best bundle changes. A demand function tells you the optimal amount for any prices and income.

x1(p1,p2,m)andx2(p1,p2,m)

where each is the optimal quantity of that good, written as a function of both prices and income.

Interior and corner solutions

The basic idea is the same for every utility function. The consumer always wants the highest indifference curve they can reach within their budget, whatever the curves look like and whether the answer is interior or a corner. So far the pictures have used Cobb-Douglas-shaped curves, which "bow towards the origin and not touching the axis", but the idea is not limited to them.

Interior solutions

This covers the case where the consumer buys some of both goods. Here the slopes from Chapter 2 and Chapter 3 finally meet.

Two conditions for the optimum

At an interior optimum, two things are true:

Why: Any bundle below the line leaves money unspent, so you could afford a better one. On the line, the best point is where the highest curve just touches it without crossing.

p1x1∗+p2x2∗=mMRS(x1∗,x2∗)=−p1p2

where (x1∗,x2∗) is the optimal bundle and −p1/p2 is the slope of the budget line.

Exam

McLeod reminded the class that he told them to "put a little star" next to the slope of the budget constraint in Chapter 2 and the slope of the indifference curve in Chapter 3. "This is a point where those stars matter." He said "this condition's going to come up," and that they would come back to these slopes "again and again."

Willingness versus ability to trade

The tangency condition has an economic meaning. The MRS is the consumer's willingness to trade: how much good 2 they would give up for one more unit of good 1, based on their preferences. The budget line slope, −p1/p2, is their ability to trade at market prices. It is the opportunity cost of good 1 in terms of good 2. At the optimum, the willingness to trade equals the ability to trade.
Why: McLeod's explanation was that giving up good 2 means selling it at p2 and buying good 1 at p1. That market rate is what the consumer is able to do. When what they want to do matches what they can do, there is no trade left that makes them better off, so they are "in equilibrium."

Bundles away from the tangency

A bundle on the budget line but away from the tangency costs the same as the optimum. However, it is on a lower indifference curve. The consumer can trade along the budget line to get better off, until they reach the tangency.
Why: If the curve's slope and the line's slope differ, the market is offering a trade the consumer likes better than their own trade-off. They keep taking it until the two rates match.

Example: Bundle a, where the indifference curve is flatter

At bundle a, the slope of the indifference curve is −0.5 and the slope of the budget line is −1.

  1. |MRS|=0.5 -- the consumer is willing to give up 1 unit of good 1 to get only 0.5 units of good 2
  2. p1p2=1 -- the market lets them trade 1 unit of good 1 for 1 unit of good 2
  3. 0.5<1 -- they would accept 0.5 units of good 2, but the market gives them 1, which is a good deal

Answer: Buy less good 1 and more good 2 -- they keep trading along the budget line toward bundle c. They stop at c, where the willingness to trade equals the ability to trade.

The opposite happens at a bundle like b, which has a lot of good 2 and little good 1. (This b is a different bundle from the unaffordable b above. On this slide, b is on the budget line, up and to the left of c.) There the indifference curve is steeper than the budget line. So the consumer is willing to give up a lot of good 2 for one more unit of good 1. They buy more good 1 and less good 2, again moving toward c.

Bang for the buck

This is a second way to read the tangency condition. At the optimum, the last dollar spent on each good gives the same extra utility.
Why: MUi is the extra utility from one more unit of good i. So MUi/pi is the extra utility from one more dollar spent on good i. If a dollar does more good in one place, you move money there, until the two are equal. As McLeod put it, you want "the biggest bang for your buck."

−MU1MU2=−p1p2⟹MU1p1=MU2p2

where MU1 and MU2 are the marginal utilities and p1 and p2 are the prices. To get the right side, move everything with subscript 1 to the left and everything with subscript 2 to the right.

Made-up example: Where the next dollar should go

At some bundle, MU1=10 with p1=$2, and MU2=6 with p2=$3.

  1. MU1p1=102=5 -- extra utility per dollar spent on good 1
  2. MU2p2=63=2 -- extra utility per dollar spent on good 2
  3. 5>2 -- a dollar does more good on good 1

Answer: Shift spending toward good 1 and away from good 2 -- this bundle is not optimal yet. The consumer keeps shifting until the two ratios are equal.

Solving Cobb-Douglas demands

This section applies the two conditions to a general Cobb-Douglas utility function to get its ordinary demands.

Two solution methods

A constrained optimization problem like this can be solved by direct substitution or by the Lagrange method, which students may have seen in MA 129. Both give the same answer. Only direct substitution was done today. The Lagrange method starts on Tuesday.
Why: They are just two routes to the same optimum, so the answer cannot depend on the route.

Exam

"At no point in this term am I going to require you to answer this question using Lagrange or direct substitution. You'll have the option of doing one method or the other." Also: "It's not going to be a detriment if you do direct substitution versus Lagrange, say, on a midterm test." He will teach both, but you only need to master one.

Direct substitution

First, use the tangency condition to write x2∗ in terms of x1∗. Next, substitute that into the budget constraint and solve for x1∗. Finally, plug x1∗ back in to get x2∗.
Why: Tangency gives one equation and the budget gives a second. Two equations with two unknowns can be solved by substituting one into the other.

Example: Cobb-Douglas demands by direct substitution

The problem is to maximize u=x1αx2β subject to p1x1+p2x2=m. Here α and β are parameters greater than 0. The two conditions are (1) p1x1∗+p2x2∗=m and (2) MRS=−p1p2.

  1. MU1=αx1α−1x2β -- treat x2β as a constant and use the power rule on x1α
  2. MU2=βx1αx2β−1 -- same idea, with x1α held constant
  3. MRS=−αx1α−1x2ββx1αx2β−1 -- put the marginal utilities into −MU1/MU2
  4. MRS=−αβx1−1x21=−αx2βx1 -- cancel the powers and rewrite without negative exponents
  5. −αx2∗βx1∗=−p1p2 -- apply condition (2)
  6. αx2∗βx1∗=p1p2 -- both slopes are negative, so the minus signs cancel
  7. x2∗=βαp1p2x1∗ -- multiply both sides by βα and by x1∗; call this equation (3)
  8. p1x1∗+p2(βαp1p2x1∗)=m -- substitute (3) into the budget, equation (1)
  9. p1x1∗+βαp1x1∗=m -- the p2 terms cancel
  10. p1x1∗(1+βα)=m -- factor out p1x1∗
  11. p1x1∗(α+βα)=m -- write 1 as αα to get a common denominator
  12. x1∗=αα+βmp1 -- divide by p1 and multiply by αα+β; call this equation (4)
  13. x2∗=βαp1p2⋅αα+βmp1 -- substitute (4) into (3)
  14. x2∗=βα+βmp2 -- p1 cancels, and α cancels

Answer: x1∗=αα+βmp1 and x2∗=βα+βmp2 -- these are the ordinary demand functions. Each depends on prices, income, and the parameters of the utility function.

Cobb-Douglas ordinary demands

With Cobb-Douglas utility, the consumer spends a fixed share of income on each good. The share for good 1 is αα+β, and the share for good 2 is βα+β.
Why: Multiply x1∗ by p1 and you get αα+βm. That is spending on good 1, and it does not depend on either price. McLeod said Cobb-Douglas has "some really nice properties" that make it easy to work with. The fixed spending share is one of them, but he did not state it in this lecture.

x1∗(p1,p2,m)=αα+βmp1x2∗(p1,p2,m)=βα+βmp2

where α and β are the exponents in u=x1αx2β, m is income, and p1 and p2 are the prices.

When α=β=1, the formula gives x2∗=12mp2, as McLeod noted in class.

Made-up example: Demands for u=x1x2

Let u=x1x2, with p1=$2, p2=$4 and m=$40.

  1. MRS=−x2x1 -- from the practice question above
  2. x2∗x1∗=24 -- the tangency condition, with the minus signs cancelled
  3. x2∗=12x1∗ -- solve for x2∗ in terms of x1∗
  4. 2x1∗+4(12x1∗)=40 -- substitute into the budget constraint
  5. 2x1∗+2x1∗=40 -- simplify
  6. 4x1∗=40, so x1∗=10 -- solve for x1∗
  7. x2∗=12(10)=5 -- plug back into step 3
  8. 2(10)+4(5)=20+20=40 -- check: the budget is exactly spent

Answer: (x1∗,x2∗)=(10,5) -- this matches the formula, since 12⋅402=10 and 12⋅404=5. Half of income goes to each good.

Exam

A student asked whether you can just plug numbers into these general formulas. McLeod said you would get the right answer but "lose out on all of the marks related to the mechanics." Short-answer questions "are there to show your understanding of the mechanics of the model." He said, "I would advise against that, 'cause you get most of your marks for the mechanics, not from the one correct answer." Always show the full derivation.

Exam checklist

Admin & deadlines


Transcribed automatically from the lecture recording. Slides used: EC 270 - Ch. 05 - Choice (slides).pdf. Course info used: EC 270 - Math Appendix (slides).pdf, EC 270 - Rules of Derivatives.pdf, EC 270 - Syllabus - Fall 2026.pdf. Audio archived at /mnt/porsche/configs/lectures/archive/2026-09/EC 270 - 2026-09-24 - Lecture 05.opus.