EC 223 - 2026-09-24 - Lecture 05

EC 223 - Lecture 05 - 2026-09-24

Economics of the Canadian Banking and Financial System · Igor Antonio Araujo Carreira · LH 1009

Week 3 · 17:30-18:52 · 81 min · Full transcript · Flashcards

Overview

This lecture finished Chapter 4 by redoing one bond-price calculation from last class, then covering real versus nominal interest rates. It then started Chapter 5, which asks what sets bond prices and interest rates. The first tool is supply and demand in the bond market, including what shifts each curve and what happens when both shift at once. The class ended by starting a second tool, the liquidity preference framework, which gets the same interest rate from the market for money. That part continues next lecture.

Finishing interest-rate risk

This picks up the table from Lecture 04 showing that longer maturities are more sensitive to rate changes. The slides were updated to state that the interest rate rises from 10% to 20%.

Recomputing the table prices

The "price next year" in the table is the bond's remaining payments discounted at the new 20% rate. Every bond has a 10% coupon, a $1,000 face value, and starts at a price of $1,000.

Why: A longer bond has more future payments left to discount. When the rate jumps from 1.1 to 1.2 in every denominator, more terms get hit, so the price falls more. That is why longer maturities are more sensitive.

Example: the 2-year bond falls to $917

A 2-year bond pays a $100 coupon each year and $1,000 at maturity. Rates are 10% when you buy and 20% a year later.

  1. Pt=1001.1+11001.12=90.91+909.09=1000 -- the price today at 10%.
  2. Pt+1=11001.2=916.67≈917 -- one year later the first coupon is paid and only the last payment remains, now discounted at 20%.
  3. 917−10001000=−0.083 -- the capital-gain rate is −8.3%.
  4. R=10%+(−8.3%)=1.7% -- the current yield plus the capital-gain rate.

Answer: a price of about $917 and a return of +1.7% -- the 2-year bond still earns a small positive return, because only its one remaining payment is hit by the higher rate.

Example: the 5-year bond falls to $741

Same bond, but with 5 years to maturity. After one year, 4 years of coupons and the face value remain, all discounted at 20%.

  1. Pt+1=1001.2+1001.22+1001.23+11001.24 -- the four remaining payments at the new rate.
  2. =83.33+69.44+57.87+530.48 -- each term worked out.
  3. =741.13≈741 -- added up.
  4. 741−10001000=−0.259 -- the capital-gain rate is −25.9%.
  5. R=10%−25.9%=−15.9% -- the total return.

Answer: a price of about $741 and a return of −15.9% -- more remaining terms means a much bigger loss than the 2-year bond.

Real and nominal interest rates

So far the course has only used nominal rates. This section adjusts them for inflation.

Nominal versus real

A nominal interest rate is the plain money return and ignores inflation. A real interest rate adjusts for inflation, so it measures the return in goods you can actually buy. "Real" in economics means measured relative to some good rather than in dollars. The lecturer compared it to the numeraire good from intro micro: a chair priced at "half a table" is a real price, while $100 is a nominal price.

Why: A rate alone does not tell you if borrowing is cheap. The lecturer's example: 5% is "actually amazing" to a borrower in a country with 10% inflation. Some car dealerships now offer 1% financing. That is below inflation and below what a GIC pays. So it can be better to keep your money in a GIC at about 3% and take the financing instead of making a down payment. The real rate better reflects the real cost of borrowing and the purchasing-power return to lending. It is a better guide to the incentives to borrow or lend. A low real rate gives more reason to borrow and less reason to lend.

Example: the chair

You put $100 in a bond paying 5%. Before, $100 bought one chair. Then all prices double (100% inflation), so the chair costs $200.

  1. 100×1.05=105 -- the nominal payoff after a year.
  2. 105200=0.525 -- the number of chairs the payoff now buys.
  3. 0.525−11=−0.475 -- the change measured in chairs.

Answer: about −47.5% in real terms -- the 5% nominal return hides a real loss, since you can buy less than before.

Example: borrowing right after COVID

Right after COVID, loans cost about 1% while inflation ran about 5% to 6%.

  1. r≈i−π=1%−5% -- nominal rate minus inflation.
  2. r≈−4% -- the result.

Answer: a real rate of about −4% or lower -- borrowing was very cheap in real terms, which the lecturer tied to the housing-market boom.

Ex post and ex ante real rates

The ex post real rate subtracts the inflation that actually happened, so it looks back at a past period. The ex ante real rate subtracts expected inflation, so it is the one that matters for decisions made today. The Fisher equation links them.

Why: When you lend or borrow, you do not yet know what inflation will be. So your decision rests on expected inflation. Expectations can turn out wrong. The lecturer's example was people expecting 3% inflation, then a war in Iran pushes oil prices up and actual inflation comes in at 6%.

i≈r+πeorr≈i−πe

where i is the nominal interest rate, r is the real interest rate and πe is expected inflation. For the ex post rate, use actual inflation π in place of πe. The lecturer said you can treat the ≈ as an equals sign. (Strictly it is an approximation: the exact version is (1+i)=(1+r)(1+πe). Subtracting works for small rates like the ones in class, but not for big inflation. In the chair example above, 5%−100%=−95%, while the true real return is 1.052−1=−47.5%.)

Example: an oil shock

People expect 3% inflation, but actual inflation turns out to be 6%. (No nominal rate was stated. The lecturer called the 3% and the 0% "ex-ante inflation" and "ex-post inflation", but they only make sense as the ex ante and ex post real rates, and a 6% nominal rate gives both.)

  1. rexante≈6%−3%=3% -- nominal rate minus expected inflation.
  2. rexpost≈6%−6%=0% -- nominal rate minus actual inflation.

Answer: the lender expected a 3% real return and got 0% -- surprise inflation moves wealth from lenders to borrowers.

Measuring expected inflation

The CPI only measures past inflation, so expected inflation has to be estimated. There is no single measure. There are two common ways:

Why: If the gap did not match what the market expects, investors could profit by buying one bond and selling the other. That trading moves prices until the gap matches expectations.

Example: reading inflation from two bonds

A one-year government bond pays 10%. An inflation-linked bond pays 7% plus inflation.

  1. πe≈10%−7%=3% -- the market's implied expected inflation.
  2. Expectations rise to 4%: the linked bond now promises about 7%+4%=11% -- that beats the 10% normal bond.
  3. Everyone buys the linked bond and sells the normal one -- the linked bond's price rises so its rate falls, and the normal bond's price falls so its rate rises.
  4. Say the linked rate moves to 6.5% and the normal rate to 10.5%: 10.5%−6.5%=4% -- the gap now matches the new expectation.

Answer: the gap between the two rates tracks expected inflation -- here it moves from 3% to 4%.

Real rates in the 1970s

Nominal and real rates often do not move together. In the US in the 1970s nominal rates were high, but real rates were very low and often negative.

Why: The US kept raising nominal rates, but expected inflation rose even faster because of the oil price shocks, so real rates kept falling. Then Paul Volcker (US Federal Reserve chair) pushed nominal rates up very sharply so that real rates would finally rise. A higher real rate makes people consume and invest less, which lowers demand and brings inflation down. This comes back later in the course.

Determinants of asset demand

Chapter 5 starts here. The question is what decides how many bonds people want to hold.

What drives asset demand

Four things decide whether someone buys one asset rather than another:

Why: Every asset is judged against the alternatives. If the expected return on stocks goes up, demand for bonds goes down, even though nothing about bonds changed.

Everything else held constant

Each of those effects assumes that only one factor changes and everything else stays the same.

Why: In real life, a higher return often comes with more risk. Then people will not necessarily buy more. The analysis only works one factor at a time.

Exam

"This is important: holding everything else constant, okay? Cuz sometimes returns increase, but then risk also increases." Every "more of X means more demand" statement in this chapter carries that condition.

Supply and demand in the bond market

The four determinants above now feed into a demand curve for bonds. Borrowers supply the other side.

Bond demand

Bond demand comes from investors who want to hold bonds as assets. Holding everything else constant, a lower bond price (a higher interest rate) raises the quantity of bonds demanded. So the demand curve slopes down when drawn against price.

Why: As with any good, when the price falls you want to buy more. For an investor, paying $800 for a $1,000 payoff is better than paying $900.

Bond supply

Bond supply comes mainly from borrowers such as corporations and governments. It also includes investors selling bonds they already own in the secondary market. Holding everything else constant, a lower bond price (a higher interest rate) raises the cost of borrowing, so fewer bonds are supplied. The supply curve slopes up when drawn against price.

Why: A borrower who owes $1,000 at maturity either way would rather raise more money today. A higher price means more cash raised for the same repayment, which is the same as a lower interest rate.

Example: which bond would a borrower rather issue?

A one-year discount bond with a $1,000 face value. The borrower can sell it for $900 or for $800.

  1. i=1000900−1=0.111 -- the rate is 11.1% at a price of $900.
  2. i=1000800−1=0.25 -- the rate is 25% at a price of $800.
  3. At $900 the borrower raises $100 more today for the same $1,000 repayment -- a cheaper loan.

Answer: the borrower prefers the $900 price -- a higher price is a lower cost of borrowing. (The lecturer rounded these to about 10% and 20%. The exact rates are 11.1% and 25%, so use those in calculations.) An investor wants the opposite: the $800 price. In class a student first picked $800 because "it's cheaper", which is the investor's view, not the borrower's.

Bond market equilibrium

Equilibrium is the price where the quantity demanded equals the quantity supplied, Bd=Bs. That price, and its interest rate, is the market-clearing price and rate.

Why: If demand exceeds supply (excess demand), buyers compete for the few bonds and accept lower rates, so the price rises and the rate falls. If supply exceeds demand (excess supply), issuers must offer better rates, so the price falls and the rate rises. This can happen quickly or slowly, but it keeps going until there is no excess on either side.

Bd=Bs

where Bd is the quantity of bonds demanded and Bs is the quantity supplied.

Example: the slide's one-year discount bond

Face value $1,000. At a price of $750, the government wants to supply $100 billion of bonds, but investors want $500 billion.

  1. i=1000750−1=0.333 -- the rate at $750 is 33.3%.
  2. 500−100=400 -- an excess demand of $400 billion.
  3. Issuers ask for lower rates and buyers accept them -- the price is bid up.
  4. The market settles where the curves cross: P∗=850, with i∗=1000850−1=0.176 -- a rate of 17.6%.

Answer: P∗=$850, i∗=17.6%, quantity $300 billion -- at this price nobody wants more or fewer bonds than are on offer. Starting from a very high price (0% rate), the same process runs the other way.

The prices on the slide map to these rates: $1,000 is 0%, $950 is 5.3%, $900 is 11.1%, $850 is 17.6%, $800 is 25.0% and $750 is 33.3%. Each one is i=F−PP, where F is the $1,000 face value and P is the price.

left=0; right=600; bottom=700; top=1000
---
y=1000-0.5x|x>0
y=700+0.5x|x>0
(300,850)|label:C
(100,750)|label:F
(500,750)|label:E

x is the quantity of bonds in $ billions and y is the bond price in dollars. The falling line is demand, the rising line is supply, and F to E is the excess demand at $750.

Movements versus shifts

A change in the bond's own price (or interest rate) moves you along the curve. A shift of the whole curve happens only when something other than the price changes, so more or fewer bonds are wanted at every price.

Why: The curve already shows how quantity responds to price. So a price change cannot also move the curve. A shift means that at the same price, say a 10% rate, people now want more or fewer bonds than before. Either kind of shift gives a new equilibrium price and rate.

Exam

"There is an important distinction and that many people mess up. It's really frequent, really really really frequent." And: "We do not shift the curve because the price changed. We don't shift the demand. When we say, hear me out, this is important..." If a higher rate makes people buy 300 bonds instead of 100, that is a movement along the demand curve. Drawing it as a shift is wrong.

What shifts bond demand

These are the factors other than price that move the whole demand curve.

Wealth

More wealth or saving shifts bond demand to the right.

Why: Wealthier people put some of the extra into bonds, so they want more at every price.

Example: people get wealthier

Start at the $850 equilibrium with $300 billion of bonds. Wealth rises, and at $850 people now want $500 billion.

  1. Supply did not shift, so at $850 it is still $300 billion -- only demand moved.
  2. 500−300=200 -- an excess demand of $200 billion.
  3. Excess demand bids the price up -- so the rate falls.

Answer: a new equilibrium with more bonds and a lower interest rate. (The lecturer briefly said rates go up, then said they end up lower. Lower is right, since excess demand raises the price.)

Expected future interest rates

If people expect interest rates to rise in the future, they want fewer bonds today. The demand curve shifts left. This is the opposite of a rise in the current rate, which makes people want more.

Why: When rates rise, bond prices fall. If you buy now and rates then jump, you lose money if you have to sell. So you wait. This is going on now: the market has already priced in some Bank of Canada rate moves. If you think the Bank will raise rates faster than expected, you hold off. After a surprise hike, when you think no more are coming, it may be a good time to buy. Once you own a bond, you want rates to fall.

Example: a one-day bond windfall

You buy a one-year discount bond with a $1,000 face value at a 10% rate. The next day something like COVID hits and rates go to 0%.

  1. P=10001.1=909.09 -- what you paid.
  2. P=10001.0=1000 -- the new price at a 0% rate.
  3. 1000−909.09=90.91 -- your gain in one day.
  4. 90.91909.09=0.10 -- a 10% return.

Answer: a full year's 10% return in one day -- holding to maturity would add nothing more, so bond markets can also give "really strong returns" when rates fall.

Exam

The lecturer called this "tricky" twice ("that's another tricky. It's tough") after the class answered it wrong: "I hope it's very clear the distinction between current interest rate that... you want like the highest possible, from the expectation of interest rate, which, ideally, after you buy some bond, you would want rates to fall." A higher current rate raises the quantity demanded. A higher expected future rate shifts demand left.

Expected inflation and bond demand

A rise in expected inflation shifts bond demand to the left.

Why: From the Fisher equation, r≈i−πe. If expected inflation rises and the nominal rate stays put, the expected real return falls, so people want fewer bonds at each price. Money leaving bonds may go to stocks, though that is less clear. It often goes to real assets such as houses, which tend to keep pace with inflation. In high-inflation countries people rush to buy US dollars or apartments to keep their savings "frozen in real terms."

Risk and liquidity

Bonds that become riskier than other assets see demand shift left. Bonds that become more liquid than other assets see demand shift right.

Why: Most people are risk averse and everyone likes liquidity. The general rule is simple. At a given price, if people want more, the curve shifts right. If they want less, it shifts left.

What shifts bond supply

New bonds are issued by corporations and governments. These factors shift the supply curve.

Investment opportunities

When investment projects become more profitable, firms want to borrow more, so bond supply shifts right.

Why: The lecturer's example: Canada signs a trade deal with Asia, so building a pipeline to export oil or gas becomes very profitable. At any given rate, the pipeline company issues more bonds to pay for the build.

Expected inflation and bond supply

A rise in expected inflation, with the nominal rate fixed, lowers the real cost of borrowing, so bond supply shifts right.

Why: Borrowers repay in dollars that are worth less. Taken to the extreme, a government can print money and create inflation so the real cost of its debt goes deeply negative. The lecturer said this is discussed especially for some Latin American countries. $1,000 that once bought a car might end up buying a candy, which is a kind of default.

Example: the real cost of borrowing falls

The nominal rate is fixed at 10%. Expected inflation rises from 5% to 10%.

  1. r≈10%−5%=5% -- the real cost before.
  2. r≈10%−10%=0% -- the real cost after.

Answer: the real cost of borrowing falls from 5% to 0% -- so firms and governments issue more bonds at the same nominal rate.

Government deficits

A larger government budget deficit shifts bond supply to the right.

Why: Governments mainly finance deficits by issuing bonds. A government with a surplus will likely repay bonds and shrink its debt instead.

Combining shifts

Some events move both curves at once. The result can be clear for one variable and unclear for the other.

Higher expected inflation

When expected inflation rises, bond demand shifts left and bond supply shifts right. The bond price falls and the interest rate rises. What happens to the quantity of bonds is unclear.

Why: Both shifts push the price down, so the rate must rise. For quantity, the demand shift lowers it and the supply shift raises it, so the answer depends on which shift is bigger. For example, if supply grows a lot and demand shrinks only a little, quantity rises.

Exam

In class, students mixed up expected inflation with expected interest rates. The lecturer's correction: "Note that it's not the expectation of interest rate, or the expectation of real or nominal interest rate. It's the expectation of inflation." With the nominal rate fixed, higher πe lowers the real return, so demand falls. When the class guessed "stays the same" for quantity, the answer was "We don't know."

Ambiguous outcomes

When demand and supply shift in the same direction, you know which way quantity goes, but not the rate. When they shift in opposite directions, you know the rate, but not quantity.

Why: If both curves shift right, quantity surely rises. The price, and so the rate, depends on which curve moved more. If demand barely moves and supply moves a lot, the price falls and the rate rises.

Exam

"This is another non-obvious thing that sometimes you can have ambiguous impacts on interest rates or... quantity demanded." When both curves shift, only commit to the variable both shifts agree on.

The Fisher effect

Nominal interest rates tend to move with expected inflation. The slides show that US three-month Treasury bill rates and expected inflation tracked each other from 1953 to 2020.

Why: If the real rate is set by other forces, a rise in πe must show up in i. This happens partly because the central bank raises rates. It also happens because markets move early when they expect the central bank to raise rates to fight inflation. The lecturer noted that US 5- and 10-year bond rates are rising now without the Federal Reserve acting.

The liquidity preference framework

This is a second way to find the equilibrium interest rate. It looks at the market for money instead of the bond market. The lecturer started it today and will finish it next class. The slides on Friedman's effects of money growth were not reached.

Money and bonds as the only stores of value

The framework assumes there are only two ways to store wealth: money and bonds. So the total supplied of the two must equal the total demanded.

Why: Wealth has to sit in one or the other. If the bond market has excess supply, the money market must have excess demand of the same size. When one market is in equilibrium, both sides equal zero and the other market is too. So you can study either one. The standard approach uses money.

Bs+Ms=Bd+Md⇒Bs−Bd=Md−Ms

where Bs and Bd are bonds supplied and demanded, and Ms and Md are money supplied and demanded.

Made-up example: two markets, one imbalance

At today's interest rate, people want $20 billion more money than exists.

  1. Md−Ms=20 -- the excess demand for money.
  2. Bs−Bd=20 -- by the identity, the bond market has the same-sized excess supply.
  3. Excess bond supply lowers bond prices -- so the interest rate rises.

Answer: a $20 billion excess supply of bonds -- fixing one market fixes the other.

Money demand

People hold money to make transactions and as a store of value. In this model money earns zero interest. The quantity of money demanded falls as the bond interest rate rises.

Why: The bond rate is the opportunity cost of holding money. If bonds pay 0%, there is no reason to give up cash for them. At 10%, holding cash costs you more. When bond rates fall, liquid money becomes more attractive.

Money supply

In this simplified model the central bank fully controls the money supply. So the supply curve is a vertical line: the amount is the same at every interest rate. It only shifts when the central bank decides to shift it.

Money market equilibrium

Equilibrium is where the downward-sloping money demand curve crosses the vertical money supply line. On the slide this is at i∗=15%, with a money supply of $300 billion. Above 15% there is excess supply of money, and the rate falls. Below 15% there is excess demand, and the rate rises.

What shifts money demand

Two factors shift money demand to the right:

Example: prices double

The average price of what you buy goes from $100 to $200.

  1. Before, your usual basket cost $100 -- that is the money you held for it.
  2. 200100=2 -- now the same basket costs twice as much.

Answer: you want twice as much money -- to keep buying the same things, so money demand shifts right.

Exam

The lecturer called the price-level effect "tricky like how you think about it". Higher prices mean each dollar buys less, so people want more money at every interest rate, and money demand shifts right.

Higher income or prices raise rates

When income or the price level rises, money demand shifts right while money supply stays fixed. The quantity of money does not change, but the interest rate rises.

Why: People want more money, but there is no more of it. They try to sell bonds to get money, which pushes bond prices down. The rate rises until people are willing to keep holding the bonds they wanted to sell.

More money lowers rates

When the central bank raises the money supply, the vertical line shifts right and the interest rate falls.

Why: With more money around, people want more bonds, which raises bond prices and lowers rates. Exactly how depends on how the central bank adds the money. In class the lecturer began to describe one way, the central bank buying bonds to add money, then stopped: that mechanism comes after the midterm.

Exam checklist

Admin & deadlines


Transcribed automatically from the lecture recording. Slides used: EC 223 - 2026-09-22 - Lecture 04 - The Meaning of Interest Rates (slides).pdf, EC 223 - 2026-09-24 - Lecture 05 - The Behaviour of Interest Rates (slides).pdf. Course info used: EC 223 - Syllabus - Fall 2026.pdf. Audio archived at /mnt/porsche/configs/lectures/archive/2026-09/EC 223 - 2026-09-24 - Lecture 05.opus.