EC 223 - 2026-09-29 - Lecture 06

EC 223 - Lecture 06 - 2026-09-29

Economics of the Canadian Banking and Financial System · Igor Antonio Araujo Carreira · LH 1009

Week 4 · 17:30-18:44 · 74 min · Full transcript · Flashcards

Overview

This lecture finished Chapter 5 by redoing how a bigger money supply shows up in the bond market, then explained why the first drop in interest rates may not last. It then started Chapter 6, which asks why interest rates differ across bonds. The first part is the risk structure: bonds with the same maturity have different yields because of default risk, liquidity and taxes. The second part is the term structure: the same kind of bond has different yields at different maturities, and three theories (expectations, segmented markets and liquidity premium) try to explain the shape of the yield curve.

Money supply and interest rates

This finishes the liquidity preference framework from last lecture, which found that a bigger money supply lowers interest rates in the market for money.

Money supply in the bond market

When the Bank of Canada wants to add money to the economy, it uses cash to buy bonds. It keeps the bonds and hands out money, so the money supply rises. In the bond market you can read this two ways, and both give the same result. You can see it as bond demand shifting right, because the Bank of Canada is a new buyer. Or you can see it as bond supply shifting left, because fewer bonds are left for sale. Either way the bond price rises and the interest rate falls, which matches the money market result.

Why: Bond prices and yields move in opposite directions (from Lecture 04), so anything that pushes bond prices up pushes interest rates down.

Note that the bond market graph has price and quantity on its axes, so nothing on it shows the interest rate directly. The lecturer said you can write the interest rate change beside the graph. On the money market graph, the vertical axis is the interest rate itself.

Exam

The quizzes don't ask for graphs, "but in the exam, you need to draw some graphs." Mark the initial point and the new point, number them, and label the axes and curves: "if you don't put anything, I don't know if this is interest rate or prices. So, it's always good to label everything, so it helps you to get full credit."

Liquidity effect

The liquidity effect is the drop in interest rates caused by a rise in the money supply. More money is being supplied for a given money demand, so interest rates fall.

Why: The lecturer stressed that this is usually a short-run effect. Raising the money supply lowers nominal interest rates in the short run, but that does not have to hold later.

Effects that push rates back up

Faster money growth also sets off three effects that push interest rates up, the opposite way from the liquidity effect.

Why: The first two effects work through the money market (more money demand), and the third works through the bond market. All three undo part or all of the liquidity effect.

r≈i−πe

where r is the real interest rate, i is the nominal interest rate and πe is expected inflation.

Made-up example: expected inflation lowers the real return

A bond pays a nominal rate of 5%, and expected inflation rises from 2% to 4%.

  1. r≈5%−2%=3% -- real return before the change
  2. r≈5%−4%=1% -- real return after the change

Answer: The real return falls from about 3% to about 1% -- lenders want fewer bonds and borrowers want to issue more, so bond prices fall and interest rates rise.

Short run versus long run

What we usually see in reality is that the liquidity effect is stronger at first, so interest rates fall right after the money supply rises. Then the income, price level and expected inflation effects kick in, and rates start to rise. Usually the nominal interest rate ends up higher than where it started, but that is a long-run effect.

Why: The liquidity effect happens as soon as the money arrives. Income, prices and inflation expectations take time to adjust.

Exam

Asked whether short run versus long run could be tested: "I could ask, I don't know if I will… it's more unlikely that I will ask something like this." More likely: "what is the impact of increasing liquidity on both markets, and then you shift the curves, or of expected inflation on the bond market." He said "more important than this is understanding exactly how you shift curves."

Open market operations

Open market operations mean the central bank buys and sells bonds. The lecturer called this the main tool a central bank uses to move interest rates, answering a question about the US Federal Reserve. (The Bank of Canada mainly steers rates by setting a target for the overnight rate, backed by its standing facilities. Its tools come in a later chapter.) Usually it acts only on short-term bonds by setting its policy rate. With quantitative easing, it instead bought long-term bonds to push long-term interest rates down. Other tools come in later chapters.

Risk structure of interest rates

This starts Chapter 6. The risk structure compares bonds with the same maturity that pay different yields.

Yields move together but differ

Figure 6-1 shows long-term yields on Government of Canada bonds, provincial bonds and corporate bonds from 1978 on. Yields were very high around the early 1980s and have mostly fallen since, though they are picking up a little now. Corporate bonds usually yield the most and federal bonds the least. The gap between them changes over time, sometimes wide and sometimes narrow, but all three move together.

Why: Three things explain the gaps between bonds with similar maturities: default risk, liquidity and tax considerations. The lecturer spent most time on the first two.

Default risk

Default risk is the chance that the bond issuer will be unable or unwilling to pay the interest or repay the face value at maturity. For example, you buy an Ontario bond that pays $1,000 in 3 years, and Ontario pays you nothing or only part of it. In practice, issuers usually renegotiate rather than just stop paying. They may ask for more time (4 years instead of 3), repay only the principal, or cut the interest rate.

Government of Canada bonds are treated as default-free, because the federal government can raise taxes and the Bank of Canada can create Canadian dollars. Their rate is often called the risk-free rate, and it is the reference rate. Other bonds of the same maturity are expected to yield the same or more, though taxes and other factors mean this is not always true.

Why: Buyers want to be paid for the chance of losing money, so a riskier bond has to offer a higher yield.

Risk premium

The risk premium is the gap between the yield on a risky bond and the yield on a Government of Canada bond with the same maturity. It measures how risky that bond is. A large gap means a higher chance of default. The premium can also include things other than default risk, such as liquidity.

Why: The Government of Canada rate is the default-free benchmark, so anything a bond pays above it is the reward for its extra risk.

risk premium=ic−iT

where ic is the yield on the risky (corporate) bond and iT is the yield on the Government of Canada bond with the same maturity.

Made-up example: finding a risk premium

A 5-year corporate bond yields 5.25%, and a 5-year Government of Canada bond yields 3.00%.

  1. 5.25%−3.00% -- subtract the risk-free yield from the risky yield
  2. =2.25% -- the gap

Answer: The risk premium is 2.25 percentage points -- that is the extra yield buyers need to hold the corporate bond.

Liquidity

Liquidity is how easily an asset can be turned into cash. A liquid bond has low transaction costs and many buyers and sellers, so you can sell it quickly and cheaply. For stocks, Apple is very liquid, but a small engineering company on the stock exchange may trade rarely, so it is hard to find a buyer. In the same way, one company's bonds are much less liquid than Government of Canada bonds.

Why: Holding everything else constant, people want less of a bond that is hard to sell. Its demand curve shifts left, its price falls and its yield rises. That extra yield acts like part of the risk premium.

Income tax considerations

A tax-exempt bond can offer a lower yield before tax than a taxable bond. In the United States, interest on municipal bonds is exempt from federal income tax. The lecturer said he doesn't think tax-exempt bonds are really a thing in Canada.

Why: If two bonds both yield 10% but only one is tax-exempt, everyone prefers the tax-exempt one. Its demand shifts right, its price rises and its yield falls, so tax-exempt bonds end up with lower yields.

Rising default risk on corporate bonds

The slides show two bond markets side by side: corporate bonds (a) and Government of Canada bonds (b). When default risk on the corporate bond rises, its expected return falls and it looks riskier. Demand for corporate bonds shifts left, so their price falls from P1c to P2c and their rate rises from i1c to i2c. People move that money into Canada bonds, so that demand shifts right. Their price rises from P1T to P2T and their rate falls from i1T to i2T. The gap between i2c and i2T is the new, wider risk premium.

Why: The lecturer used RBC. Its bonds are almost risk-free, because "if RBC fails, probably Canada doesn't exist anymore," and the government would likely bail it out. If something like a US sanction suddenly made RBC riskier, people would sell RBC bonds and buy Canada bonds. That opens the gap in prices and in interest rates.

Credit ratings

Credit-rating agencies assess how likely each issuer is to repay and give it a letter grade. The slides list DBRS, Moody's, S&P and Fitch. AAA (Moody's: Aaa) is the top grade, meaning the lowest default risk. Lower grades mean a higher chance of default, and the bottom (C and D grades) means default is very likely or has already happened.

The most important line is between investment grade and non-investment grade. Investment grade runs down to BBB low at DBRS (Baa3 at Moody's, BBB2 at S&P). (The slide's table writes S&P and Fitch grades with 1 and 2, but those agencies actually use + and -. So S&P's lowest investment grade is BBB-, and its highest speculative grade is BB+.) From BB high (Ba1) down, bonds are non-investment grade, or speculative. Some mutual funds may only hold investment-grade bonds, so a downgrade below that line forces them to sell. That is why companies and governments try hard to stay above it. Asked where "junk bonds" start, the lecturer pointed near that same line but said he was not completely sure. (Standard references, including Mishkin, define junk bonds as all non-investment-grade bonds: BB high at DBRS, Ba1 at Moody's, BB+ at S&P, and anything lower. Use that line on a test.) Rating agencies come back in the financial crises chapter, because they were central to the crisis.

Why: Most buyers can't study every issuer themselves, so a rating is a quick signal of default risk.

Exam

About the ratings table: "Of course, I will never ask you to memorize this."

Complex pooled securities

A student asked about The Big Short, where banks mixed low-rated and high-rated pieces into a middle-rated product. The lecturer said something like that could happen, along with plain mispricing, such as rating mortgage pools AAA when the real quality was much lower. When you pool many assets, it gets hard to judge the real risk. Some investment banks built very complex products on purpose, and some were built on top of other pooled products. It became "simply impossible to assess" what the underlying asset was. He'll cover how mortgage-backed securities were built in the financial crises chapter.

Term structure of interest rates

The risk structure held maturity fixed and varied risk. The term structure does the opposite.

Term structure versus risk structure

The risk structure compares bonds with the same maturity but different risk, liquidity or taxes. The term structure compares the same type of bond at different maturities. For example, the Government of Canada issues bonds maturing in a few weeks, a month, a year or 20 years, and they all have different interest rates.

Yield curve

The yield curve plots the yields on bonds with different terms to maturity but the same risk, liquidity and tax treatment, such as Government of Canada bonds. It is a picture of the term structure, and it changes over time as bond prices change.

A real curve does not have to be smooth. It can dip a little and then rise, but it is roughly upward or downward overall. The lecturer pulled up Government of Canada data from 1986, where 3-month bonds yielded 9.5% and 6-month bonds 9.2%, yet the curve still sloped upward overall. Then he plotted today's Canadian curve: it slopes upward, from about 2% to 2.25% at the short end to close to 4.5% at the long end.

Why: Different points on the curve serve different purposes. Short rates matter for banks lending to each other. Mortgages follow longer rates: a 5-year mortgage uses the 5-year Government of Canada rate as its reference, and US mortgages often run 20 or 30 years.

Three facts to explain

A theory of the term structure should explain three facts:

  1. Interest rates on bonds of different maturities move together over time. If the Bank of Canada raises short-term rates, rates at all maturities usually rise too, though not always.
  2. When short-term rates are low, yield curves are more likely to slope up. When short-term rates are high, they are more likely to be inverted. The lecturer said that if the Bank of Canada kept raising rates, Canada's curve could invert at some point.
  3. Yield curves usually slope upward.

Why: Fact 2 makes sense if rates tend to drift back toward a long-run average. A low rate today is expected to rise, and a high rate today is expected to fall.

Expectations theory explains facts 1 and 2 but not 3. Segmented markets theory explains fact 3 but not 1 and 2. Liquidity premium theory combines the two and explains all three.

Expectations theory

Expectations theory says the interest rate on a long-term bond is about the average of today's short-term rate and the short-term rates expected over the bond's life. It assumes buyers see bonds of different maturities as perfect substitutes. They have no preferred maturity, and they won't hold a bond whose expected return is lower than a bond of another maturity.

Why: Over two years you can buy a two-year bond and hold it, or buy a one-year bond and then another one-year bond next year. If both are perfect substitutes, both plans must give the same expected return. The two-year bond returns (1+i2t)(1+i2t)−1=2i2t+(i2t)2≈2i2t. The two one-year bonds return (1+it)(1+it+1e)−1=it+it+1e+itit+1e≈it+it+1e. The small squared and product terms are dropped, which is why everything is approximate. Setting 2i2t≈it+it+1e gives the formula.

i2t≈it+it+1e2

where i2t is today's interest rate on a two-period bond, it is today's rate on a one-period bond, and it+1e is the rate expected next period on a one-period bond.

Example: two one-year bonds versus one two-year bond

The one-year rate today is 9%, and you expect the one-year rate next year to be 11%.

  1. $100×1.09=$109 -- invest $100 for the first year, then reinvest the $109 at next year's rate
  2. i2t≈(9%+11%)/2 -- average the two one-year rates
  3. =20%/2=10% -- do the arithmetic

Answer: The two-year bond must yield about 10% -- any less and you would rather roll over one-year bonds.

Made-up example: checking the approximation

Use the same numbers: the two-year rate is 10%, and the one-year rates are 9% then 11%. Invest $1.

  1. (1.10)(1.10)−1=1.21−1=0.21 -- exact two-year bond return
  2. 2(0.10)=0.20 -- approximate return, dropping the (0.10)2=0.01 term
  3. (1.09)(1.11)−1=1.2099−1=0.2099 -- exact return from two one-year bonds
  4. 0.09+0.11=0.20 -- approximate return, dropping the 0.09×0.11=0.0099 term

Answer: Both plans return about 21% exactly and 20% by the approximation -- the dropped terms are tiny, so the averaging rule works.

Longer maturities under expectations theory

The same logic works for any length. The n-period rate is about the average of the one-period rates expected over the bond's n-period life. For three years, you add a third term, it+2e, and divide by 3.

int≈it+it+1e+it+2e+⋯+it+(n−1)en

where int is today's rate on an n-period bond, it is today's one-period rate, it+ke is the one-period rate expected k periods from now, and n is the number of periods to maturity.

Made-up example: a three-year bond

The one-year rate is 2% today, and you expect 3% next year and 4% the year after.

  1. i3t≈(2%+3%+4%)/3 -- average the three expected one-year rates
  2. =9%/3=3% -- do the arithmetic

Answer: The three-year bond yields about 3% -- above today's 2% one-year rate, so the curve slopes up.

What expectations theory explains

Fact 1: a change in today's short rate it changes long rates too, because it is one of the terms in every long-term average. Also, rate changes tend to persist. If the Bank of Canada raises rates today, nobody expects it to reverse them next period, so expected future short rates rise as well, and long rates move with them.

Fact 2: when the short rate changes, it moves every maturity, but it moves the short end the most. So a low short rate tilts the curve up, and a high short rate tilts it down.

Why: The rate you changed carries full weight at its own maturity, but it is only one term in the average at longer maturities.

Example: a drop in the short rate tilts the curve up

Today's one-year rate and next year's expected one-year rate are both 5%. Then today's rate drops to 1%, and the expected rate stays at 5%.

  1. i2t≈(5%+5%)/2=5% -- before: the one-year and two-year rates are both 5%, so the curve is flat
  2. i2t≈(1%+5%)/2=6%/2=3% -- after: the two-year rate falls only to 3%

Answer: The curve goes from 5% and 5% to 1% and 3% -- it now slopes upward because the short end fell the most.

Fact 3 is not explained: nothing in the theory says expected short rates should usually rise, so it cannot say why curves usually slope up.

Segmented markets theory

Segmented markets theory says bonds of different maturities are not substitutes at all. Each maturity is its own market. Its rate is set only by the supply and demand for bonds of that maturity, with nothing spilling over from other maturities.

Why: Investors have a holding period in mind. If you want your money back in one year, a three-year bond is risky. If rates rise in the meantime, its price falls and you could lose money when you sell (the interest-rate risk from Lecture 04). A one-year bond gives you a sure return.

It explains fact 3. If investors generally prefer short bonds because they carry less interest-rate risk, demand for short bonds is higher. Their prices are higher and their yields lower, so the curve slopes up. It cannot explain facts 1 and 2, because it treats the markets as completely separate.

Betting on the yield curve

The lecturer showed how hedge funds bet on one maturity, say the two-year bond. The current yield curve is what the market is pricing in. If a fund thinks the central bank will raise rates faster than the market expects, it expects yields to rise and prices to fall. So it sells the bond now and buys it back after the hikes. If it thinks rates will rise more slowly than the market expects, it buys. As news arrives, yields fall and prices rise, so the fund sells before maturity and earns more than the yield to maturity it bought at.

Why: Short-term yields respond most to central bank decisions, and prices move opposite to yields. A correct view about rates becomes a gain on the price.

A student asked about buying at the curve's yield. The lecturer clarified that you don't buy "at" one yield. Each bond you buy today carries the yield for its own maturity on today's curve. A 3-month bond and a 10-year bond bought on the same day have different yields.

Liquidity premium theory

Liquidity premium theory says a long-term bond's rate is the average of expected short-term rates, as in expectations theory, plus a liquidity premium. The premium reflects supply and demand for bonds of that maturity, which is the segmented markets idea. Bonds of different maturities are partial (imperfect) substitutes. The liquidity premium is generally positive and grows with the term to maturity, n. One reason is interest-rate risk. The slide's graph also calls this the preferred habitat theory.

Why: Investors will hold longer bonds, but only if they are paid extra to take on more risk. That extra payment grows the longer the bond runs.

int≈it+it+1e+it+2e+⋯+it+(n−1)en+lnt

where int is today's rate on an n-period bond, it and it+ke are today's and expected one-period rates, and lnt is the liquidity premium for the n-period bond at time t.

The slide's graph assumes future one-year rates are expected to stay the same. Then expectations theory gives a flat yield curve. The liquidity premium curve starts at the same point but rises with maturity, and the gap between the two is lnt. So this curve always sits above the expectations theory curve and is steeper.

Made-up example: adding the liquidity premium

The one-year rate is 3% and is expected to stay at 3% for the next two years. The liquidity premium on a three-year bond is 0.5%.

  1. (3%+3%+3%)/3=9%/3=3% -- expectations part: the average of expected short rates
  2. i3t≈3%+0.5% -- add the liquidity premium
  3. =3.5% -- do the arithmetic

Answer: The three-year bond yields about 3.5% -- above the 3% one-year rate even though no rate change is expected, so the curve slopes up.

How the liquidity premium theory fits the facts

Why: It keeps the expectations part, which explains facts 1 and 2, and adds the segmented markets idea as a premium, which explains fact 3.

Made-up example: an inverted curve despite the premium

The one-year rate is 5%, and the expected one-year rates are 3% next year and 1% the year after. The three-year liquidity premium is 0.5%.

  1. (5%+3%+1%)/3=9%/3=3% -- average of expected short rates
  2. i3t≈3%+0.5%=3.5% -- add the premium
  3. 3.5%<5% -- compare with the one-year rate

Answer: The three-year rate (3.5%) is below the one-year rate (5%), so the curve is inverted -- expected short rates fall enough to outweigh the premium.

The lecturer closed by saying this is a very simplified summary. Real yields depend on many more factors than expected rates and liquidity.

Exam checklist

Admin & deadlines


Transcribed automatically from the lecture recording. Slides used: EC 223 - 2026-09-29 - Lecture 06 - The Risk and Term Structure of Interest Rates (slides).pdf. Course info used: EC 223 - Syllabus - Fall 2026.pdf. Audio archived at /mnt/porsche/configs/lectures/archive/2026-09/EC 223 - 2026-09-29 - Lecture 06.opus.