EC 270 - 2026-09-15 - Lecture 02

EC 270 - Lecture 02 - 2026-09-15

Intermediate Microeconomics I · Logan McLeod · LH 1011

Week 2 · 11:30-12:48 · 77 min · Full transcript · Flashcards

Overview

This lecture started consumer theory, which fills the first six weeks of the course and is what the midterm covers. That theory assumes people pick the best bundle of goods they can afford, and today covered the "can afford" part: the budget constraint (Chapter 2). McLeod set up the budget constraint and budget set in math and on a graph, then read the slope as a price ratio and an opportunity cost. He then used the model to show what happens when income changes, when one price changes, when you rescale with a numeraire, when a tax or subsidy is added, and when prices are nonlinear.

Consumer theory

What consumer theory assumes

Economists assume consumers choose the best bundle of goods that they value and that they can afford.
Why: McLeod used the example of T-bone steak. You might love it, but you don't buy it for every meal because it's expensive. Your choices depend on both what you like and what you can afford. The model builds those two pieces one at a time: "best" is preferences (Chapter 3, starting Thursday) and "can afford" is the budget constraint (Chapter 2, today).

The budget constraint

Bundles and prices

What limits consumption

Your choices are limited by your budget, by time (you shop less in a week with four or five midterms), and by other resources (you may be able to afford a steak but have no grill to cook it on). The model simplifies by looking only at the money limit, which comes from prices and income.
Why: Keeping just one kind of limit makes the model workable. Money is the limit that prices act on directly.

Affordability

A bundle is affordable when what you spend on it is less than or equal to your income. Income here means disposable income, meaning the money you have to spend. The model ignores saving and borrowing.
Why: pixi is what you spend on good i. Adding it up across all the goods gives the total cost of the bundle, and you can buy the bundle only if the total fits within your income.

p1x1+p2x2+⋯+pnxn≤m

where pi is the price of good i, xi is the quantity of good i, and m is income.

Budget constraint and budget set

The budget constraint is the set of bundles that are just affordable, meaning they cost exactly your income. The budget set is every affordable bundle: the ones that cost exactly your income plus the ones that cost less. The budget constraint is the upper boundary of the budget set.
Why: "Just affordable" means you spend all of your income. Every quantity must be zero or positive, because a negative quantity would mean returning or selling the good, and this model is only about buying.

{(x1,…,xn)∣x1≥0,…,xn≥0, and p1x1+⋯+pnxn=m}

where this is the budget constraint (spending equals m exactly).

B(p1,…,pn,m)={(x1,…,xn)∣x1≥0,…,xn≥0, and p1x1+⋯+pnxn≤m}

where this is the budget set (spending at most m).

Exam

McLeod stressed that the budget constraint and the budget set are not the same thing ("there is a distinction") and told the class to flag it. The constraint is the bundles that cost exactly m. The set is every bundle that costs m or less.

Two goods and the composite good

The two-good model

For most of the term the model uses just two goods, x1 and x2. What holds in the n-good case holds with two goods, and most two-good results carry back to n goods.
Why: It's a simplifying assumption that gets you to the same predictions without pages of set theory ("for the interests of both of our sanities").

p1x1+p2x2≤m

where p1,p2 are the prices and m is income.

The composite good

One way to read the two-good model: x1 is the good you care about (for example, T-bone steak) and x2 is a composite good that stands for everything else. It's handy to think of x2 as the dollars left to spend on other goods. Then p2=1. This is just a special case of the budget constraint.
Why: It lets you study the trade-off between one good and "everything else" with only two goods.

p1x1+x2≤m

where x2 is dollars spent on all other goods.

Made-up example: Steak versus everything else

Steak costs 5 dollars a unit (p1=5) and income is 100 dollars (m=100). You buy 8 steaks.

  1. 5(8)+x2=100 -- put the numbers into the budget constraint, spending all income
  2. 40+x2=100 -- steak spending is 40 dollars
  3. x2=60 -- subtract 40 from both sides

Answer: x2=60 -- you have 60 dollars left for everything else.

Three ways to describe the model

All term, each model gets described three ways: in English (what can I afford at these prices and income?), in math (an equation such as p1x1+p2x2=m), and in a graph.

The budget line on a graph

This section uses the linear-function facts from the Mathematical Appendix, which McLeod told everyone to review on their own last lecture.

Intercepts

The graph puts x1 on the horizontal axis and x2 on the vertical axis. It uses only the first quadrant, because quantities can't be negative. The budget constraint is a straight line.

Why: p1x1+p2x2=m already has the shape of the appendix line ax+cy=d (vertical intercept d/c, horizontal intercept d/a, slope −a/c), with a=p1, c=p2 and d=m. Solving it for x2 gives the standard form below.

x2=mp2−p1p2x1

where m/p2 is the vertical intercept and −p1/p2 is the slope.

Made-up example: Intercepts and slope

p1=2, p2=3, m=12, so the line is 2x1+3x2=12.

  1. m/p1=12/2=6 -- horizontal intercept, all income on good 1
  2. m/p2=12/3=4 -- vertical intercept, all income on good 2
  3. −p1/p2=−2/3 -- slope

Answer: The line runs from (0,4) to (6,0) with slope −2/3 -- you can buy 6 of good 1, or 4 of good 2, or any mix on the line between them.

Where a bundle sits

Why: More of both goods means more spending on both goods. This is the set-theory definition drawn for n=2.

The slope of the budget line

Slope

The slope of the budget line is −p1/p2. The minus sign says the line slopes down. The price ratio p1/p2 sets how steep or flat the line is.
Why: The slope depends only on prices. That's the key to every shift later on: if prices don't change, the slope doesn't change.

slope=−p1p2

where p1 and p2 are the prices of goods 1 and 2.

Exam

"You might want to put a little star beside this concept of slope. We are going to revisit this quite a lot." Understanding the slope of the budget constraint "is going to be very helpful as we move through the rest of the term."

Trading one good for the other

The slope is the rate at which the market lets you swap good 2 for good 1. To get 1 more unit of x1, you must give up p1/p2 units of x2.
Why: You could sell some good 2 at price p2 and use that money to buy good 1 at price p1. One more unit of good 1 costs p1 dollars, and that is p1/p2 units' worth of good 2.

Opportunity cost

Opportunity cost is the cost of consuming good 1 measured by the value of the next best thing you give up. With only two goods, the next best thing is simply good 2. The slope of the budget line measures the opportunity cost of good 1.
Why: The slope tells you how much good 2 you must give up for one more unit of good 1. That is exactly what one more unit of good 1 costs you.

OC of 1 more x1=p1p2 units of x2,OC of 1 more x2=p2p1 units of x1

where p1,p2 are the two prices.

Made-up example: Opportunity cost

p1=6 and p2=2.

  1. p1/p2=6/2=3 -- opportunity cost of one more unit of good 1
  2. p2/p1=2/6=1/3 -- opportunity cost of one more unit of good 2

Answer: One more unit of good 1 costs 3 units of good 2, and one more unit of good 2 costs 1/3 of a unit of good 1.

Shifting the budget line

The model has three parameters (p1, p2, m). The real power of the model comes from changing one of them and seeing how the budget set changes.

Change in income

When income rises from m1 to m2 with prices held constant, the budget line shifts out, parallel to the old one. The budget set gets bigger, no original choice is lost, and new choices are added, so it cannot make the consumer worse off. When income falls, the line shifts in, parallel to the old one. The budget set shrinks, some choices are lost, and the consumer is typically worse off.
Why: The shift is parallel because the slope −p1/p2 depends only on prices, and prices didn't change. McLeod asked the class exactly this: why he could say the shift is "absolutely" parallel.

Made-up example: Income doubles

p1=2, p2=3, and income rises from m=12 to m=24.

  1. 24/2=12 -- the new horizontal intercept (it was 6)
  2. 24/3=8 -- the new vertical intercept (it was 4)
  3. −2/3 -- the slope is unchanged, because prices are unchanged

Answer: Both intercepts double and the slope stays at −2/3 -- the line moves out parallel to the old one.

Change in the price of good 1

When p1 rises to p1′, the horizontal intercept m/p1′ moves toward the origin. The vertical intercept m/p2 stays put. So the line pivots inward around the vertical intercept and gets steeper: the slope goes from −p1/p2 to −p1′/p2. The budget set shrinks, some choices are lost, and the consumer is typically worse off. A fall in p1 does the opposite. The line pivots outward and gets flatter, no choice is lost, and the consumer can't be worse off.
Why: At the vertical intercept you buy zero of good 1, so its price doesn't matter there. Only m and p2 set that point, and neither one changed. A student said it's because p1 is zero. McLeod corrected that: it's x1 that is zero at the vertical intercept.

Made-up example: The price of good 1 doubles

m=12, p2=3, and p1 rises from 2 to 4.

  1. 12/4=3 -- the new horizontal intercept (it was 6)
  2. 12/3=4 -- the vertical intercept is unchanged
  3. −4/3 -- the new slope (it was −2/3), so the line is steeper

Answer: The line pivots inward around (0,4) -- bundles with a lot of good 1 are no longer affordable.

Change in the price of good 2

This isn't on the slides, but McLeod walked through it in class. When p2 rises, the vertical intercept falls and the horizontal intercept stays put. So the line pivots around the horizontal intercept and gets flatter. The conclusions match the good 1 case, just on the other axis.

Made-up example: The price of good 2 doubles

m=12, p1=2, and p2 rises from 3 to 6.

  1. 12/6=2 -- the new vertical intercept (it was 4)
  2. 12/2=6 -- the horizontal intercept is unchanged
  3. −2/6=−1/3 -- the new slope (it was −2/3), so the line is flatter

Answer: The line pivots down around (6,0) and choices are lost.

The numeraire

Numeraire

Numeraire means "unit of account." You can fix one price, or income, to a set value by dividing the whole budget constraint by it. The numeraire price is the price you measure the other price and income against. The numeraire good is the good you use to measure the value of the other goods. Changing the numeraire changes neither the budget constraint nor the budget set.
Why: Dividing both sides of an equation by the same number leaves its solutions unchanged. The same bundles are affordable and the trade-off (the slope) is identical.

p1x1+p2x2=m⇔p1p2x1+x2=mp2⇔p1mx1+p2mx2=1

where dividing by p2 makes good 2 the numeraire and dividing by m pegs everything to income.

Example: Dollars versus cents

p1=2 dollars, p2=3 dollars, m=12 dollars. Rewrite the same budget in cents.

  1. 2x1+3x2=12 -- the budget in dollars
  2. 200x1+300x2=1200 -- the budget in cents (everything times 100)
  3. −2/3 -- the slope in dollars
  4. −200/300=−2/3 -- the slope in cents

Answer: The slopes match -- it's the same budget line and the same budget set, just written in different units.

Example: Making good 1 the numeraire

Start from 2x1+3x2=12 and set p1=1.

  1. 22x1+32x2=122 -- divide everything by p1=2
  2. x1+32x2=6 -- simplify
  3. −13/2=−23 -- the slope is −p1/p2 with p1=1 and p2=3/2

Answer: The slope is still −2/3 -- good 1 is now the numeraire and every price is measured relative to p1.

Exam

"This is going to be a theme that kind of comes up throughout the term... There's not a unique equation that describes that. There's sort of a set of equations that all describe the same thing." Many equations can describe the same economic behaviour.

Taxes and subsidies

The budget constraint model can also be used to analyse tax policy.

Ad valorem sales tax

An ad valorem (value) tax is a tax on the value (the price) of a good. HST is a 13% ad valorem tax, which turns a price p into (1+0.13)p=1.13p. In general, a tax at rate t turns p into (1+t)p. A uniform tax hits both goods at the same rate. That shifts the budget line in, parallel to the old one, just like losing income. A uniform ad valorem tax at rate t is equivalent to an income tax at rate t/(1+t).
Why: Divide both sides by (1+t). The left side is the original spending, so relative prices and the slope are unchanged. The right side is smaller than m, because 1+t>1. A student explained the shift by prices going up. McLeod said that "might be overthinking": the slope doesn't change, so look at the income side, which shrinks.

(1+t)p1x1+(1+t)p2x2=m⇔p1x1+p2x2=m1+t

where t is the tax rate.

equivalent income loss=m−m1+t=t1+tm

where m is the income before the tax.

Made-up example: HST as an income tax

m=113 dollars and t=0.13.

  1. 1131.13=100 -- the income this budget acts like after the tax
  2. 113−100=13 -- the equivalent income loss
  3. 0.131.13×113=0.13×100=13 -- the same loss from the formula
  4. 0.131.13≈0.115 -- the equivalent income tax rate

Answer: A 13% HST on everything acts like an income tax of about 11.5% -- here it's the same as losing 13 dollars of income.

Quantity tax

With a quantity tax, the consumer pays a fixed amount to the government for each unit they buy. In the US, for example, the federal gasoline tax was about 15 cents a gallon (McLeod thinks it's higher now). (The actual US federal gasoline tax has been 18.4 cents a gallon since 1993. The 15 cents is the slide's rounded example, so treat it only as an illustration.) It changes the price from p to p+t. A quantity tax on good 1 changes the slope, and the budget line gets steeper.

p→p+t

where t is the tax per unit.

Made-up example: Quantity tax on good 1

p1=2, p2=1, m=20, and there's a tax of 0.50 dollars per unit of good 1.

  1. p1+t=2+0.5=2.5 -- the new price of good 1
  2. −2.5/1=−2.5 -- the new slope (it was −2), so the line is steeper
  3. 20/2.5=8 -- the new horizontal intercept (it was 10)

Answer: The line pivots inward around (0,20), the same as a rise in p1.

Lump-sum tax

With a lump-sum tax, the consumer pays a fixed amount no matter what or how much they buy. It works like taking away income, so the budget line shifts in, parallel to the old one. A lump-sum subsidy means the budget line shifts outward.

Subsidies

A subsidy is a "negative" (Opposite of) tax: the government gives you money instead of taking it. Taxes and subsidies change prices the same way, except for the sign. McLeod's example was the federal subsidy on electric vehicle purchases, which is a per-unit (quantity) subsidy.

tax: p+tsubsidy: p−t

where t is the amount per unit.

Made-up example: Subsidy on good 1

p1=2, p2=1, m=20, and there's a subsidy of 1 dollar per unit of good 1.

  1. p1−t=2−1=1 -- the new price of good 1
  2. −1/1=−1 -- the new slope (it was −2), so the line is flatter
  3. 20/1=20 -- the new horizontal intercept (it was 10)

Answer: The line pivots outward around (0,20) and the budget set grows.

Rationing constraints

The level of consumption of some good is fixed so that you can not purchase more than a certain amount. (Example: during world wars, governments often ration certain foods). Graphically, this means part of the graph is just cut off.

Nonlinear prices

Until now, the price was the same however much you bought. Real stores have bulk discounts (a bag of chips for 4.99 dollars, or two for 7.50 dollars) and penalties for buying too much (a toilet paper sale at 2 dollars a 24-pack that only applies to the first four packs, where the fifth pack jumps to 25 dollars).

Quantity discount budget line

When the price of a good changes with the quantity you buy, the slope changes at that quantity. The budget line then has a kink, meaning a corner. The reading is the same as before: bundles on the line cost exactly m, and bundles on or under it make up the budget set.
Why: The slope is −p1/p2. When p1 changes partway along the line, the slope changes there too.

Pasted image 20260916224928.png

p1=2 if 0≤x1≤20,p1=1 if x1>20

where p2=1 and m=100.

Example: Bulk discount on good 1

m=100 and p2=1. Good 1 costs 2 dollars each for the first 20 units and 1 dollar each after that.

  1. 100/1=100 -- the vertical intercept, all income on good 2
  2. −2/1=−2 -- the slope for x1 from 0 to 20
  3. −1/1=−1 -- the slope for x1 above 20
  4. 2×20=40 -- spending on the first 20 units of good 1
  5. 100−40=60 -- income left over
  6. 60/1=60 -- the extra units of good 1 at 1 dollar each
  7. 20+60=80 -- the total good 1 if you spend everything on it
  8. 100−2(20)=60 -- the amount of good 2 at the kink, so the kink is at (20,60)

Answer: The horizontal intercept is 80 -- not 50 (the answer at 2 dollars a unit) and not 100 (the answer at 1 dollar a unit).

left=0; right=110; bottom=0; top=110
---
y=100-2x|x>0|x<20
y=80-x|x>20|x<80
(20,60)|label:Kink

Here x is the quantity of good 1 (x1) and y is the quantity of good 2 (x2).

Exam

"So this is the tricky part." Finding the horizontal intercept means adding up spending piece by piece. Dividing all of m by one price gives the wrong answer: "that 80 looks less than 100. So how did I get to 80?"

Exam checklist

Admin & deadlines


Transcribed automatically from the lecture recording. Slides used: EC 270 - Ch. 02 - Budget Constraint (slides).pdf. Course info used: EC 270 - Math Appendix (slides).pdf, EC 270 - Rules of Derivatives.pdf, EC 270 - Syllabus - Fall 2026.pdf. Audio archived at /mnt/porsche/configs/lectures/archive/2026-09/EC 270 - 2026-09-15 - Lecture 02.opus.