EC 223 - 2026-09-15 - Lecture 02
EC 223 - Lecture 02 - 2026-09-15
Week 2 · 17:31-18:45 · 74 min · Full transcript · Flashcards
Overview
This lecture gave an overview of the financial system (Chapter 2 of Mishkin and Serletis). It started with what financial markets do: they move funds from savers to borrowers, either directly through markets or indirectly through intermediaries. It then sorted financial markets several ways: debt versus equity, primary versus secondary, exchanges versus over-the-counter, and money versus capital markets, with the main instruments in each. The second half covered financial intermediaries: their three roles, their types and their size in Canada. It ended partway through why the sector is so heavily regulated.
Function of financial markets
This picks up the "purpose of the financial system" from Lecture 01. Carreira said many of today's topics come back later in the term, and he repeats them on purpose so they sink in.
Lender-savers and borrower-spenders
Financial markets channel funds from agents with surplus funds to agents with a shortage of funds.
- Lender-savers spend less than their income, so they have funds to lend.
- Borrower-spenders spend more than their income, so they must borrow to finance their spending.
- Both groups include households, business firms, governments and foreigners. Every category has some lenders and some borrowers. For example, Norway lends out its oil surpluses, while most governments carry debt and borrow.
Why: The same kind of agent can sit on either side. What matters is whether it has spare funds or needs funds.
Allocating capital efficiently
Financial markets let funds move from people who lack productive investment opportunities to people who have them. This improves economic welfare.
Why: Money sitting idle earns nothing. If it goes to someone with a good project, the extra output can be split so that both sides end up better off.
You have $1,000 in the bank with nothing to do with it. A classmate has a business idea (buy a laptop and equipment) that turns $1,000 into $2,000 in one year. You lend the $1,000 and they pay you back $1,500.
-- the surplus created by the project -- your gain as the lender -- the borrower's gain after repaying you
Answer: Each of you gains $500. The market created value just by moving the funds to where they were more productive.
Timing purchases
Financial markets let consumers buy things before they have saved the full price. Buying a house is the classic case.
Why: You get the house now and repay out of future income. The lender is paid for waiting through interest, so both sides are better off.
You want a $1,000,000 house but don't have $1,000,000. You have a steady job and borrow the money. Over 20 years you repay $1,500,000 in total. (In class Carreira also said you might put about $30k a year of a $100k salary toward it. That part doesn't add up, since 20 years at $30k is only $600,000, so step 2 works out the yearly figure from the total.)
-- total interest paid to the lender -- average payment per year
Answer: You pay $500,000 in interest, but you live in the house for the whole 20 years. The lender earns the interest, so both sides gain.
Direct and indirect finance
Two routes for funds
- Direct finance: borrowers get funds directly from lenders in financial markets, by selling them securities. Examples given in class: buying government bonds on your trading platform, or buying stock in an IPO.
- Indirect finance: a financial intermediary borrows from lender-savers and then lends to borrower-spenders. The most common example is a bank. You deposit money, the bank lends it to a business (or gives out a mortgage), so you are lending to that firm indirectly.
Why: The line is a bit blurry. Bonds can go either way, and even "direct" deals usually have some intermediary involved. The test is whether you hold a claim on the borrower itself or on an intermediary.
Carreira asked the class for an example of each route. Know the Figure 2-1 flowchart: lender-savers on the left, borrower-spenders on the right, with financial markets (direct) on the bottom and financial intermediaries (indirect) on top.
Securities
Securities are tradable financial instruments that are claims on the borrower's future income or assets. They are assets for the buyer. Debt securities (for example bonds) are liabilities for the issuer, while equity securities (for example shares) are ownership claims.
Why: The same piece of paper sits on two balance sheets. If a firm issues $100 in bonds and raises $100 in cash, the bonds are a $100 liability for the firm and a $100 asset for whoever bought them. It works just like a house or stocks sit on your side as assets.
Brokers and dealers
Even direct finance needs financial institutions. You can't just email Tesla and ask to become a shareholder.
- Brokers match buyers and sellers.
- Dealers buy and sell securities at stated prices.
Why: A dealer actually takes the security onto its own books. If it buys and then can't sell, it is stuck holding that risk. A broker only matches the two sides.
Debt and equity
These are the "two ways firms raise funds" from Lecture 01, now in detail.
Debt instruments
A debt instrument is a contract between a borrower, who issues it, and a lender, who owns it. Examples are bonds and mortgages. The borrower pays the holder fixed dollar amounts at regular intervals until the maturity date, which is when it expires.
- Short-term: maturity under 1 year.
- Intermediate-term: 1 to 10 years.
- Long-term: over 10 years.
Why: Look at a mortgage from both sides. For you, the house is an asset and the mortgage (what you owe) is a liability. For the bank, the mortgage is an asset, because it is money owed to it.
Equity
Equity is a share of ownership in a corporation. It gives the owner a claim on the corporation's net income and assets. The example is common stock. Stocks have no maturity date. Some pay dividends (some every six months, some none for years), and some give voting rights while others don't.
Why: The upside is the whole point. If the firm grows and becomes more profitable, equity holders benefit directly.
Residual claimants
Equity holders are residual claimants. The corporation must pay all its debt holders before it pays its equity holders. The exact order also depends on local bankruptcy law.
Why: When a firm fails and sells off its assets, the equity has usually already been wiped out. Debt is usually the less risky investment, because you normally get back the amount you expected. With shares you can lose 50%, or 100% if the firm fails. That is the risk-return trade-off.
A firm shuts down and sells all its assets for $150,000. It owes bondholders $100,000.
-- debt holders are paid in full first, and what is left goes to equity holders - If the assets had sold for only $80,000:
-- debt holders get all $80,000 -- nothing is left for equity holders
Answer: Shareholders get $50,000 in the first case and $0 in the second. They are paid only from whatever is left over after the debt.
Carreira called this "one very important thing about being an equity holder". Know the term "residual claimant" and what it means for risk.
Primary and secondary markets
Primary market
The primary market is where new securities, such as bonds or stocks, are issued (sold) to their first investors. For stocks, the main primary-market event is an IPO. Investment banks help with the issue and often underwrite it, meaning they guarantee the issuer a minimum price. Individuals usually don't take part in the primary market for government bonds. It is usually just banks.
Why: The underwriter earns a spread, but it carries the risk that the issue doesn't sell.
An investment bank sets the IPO price at $100 per share and promises to pay the firm $99 per share.
-- the bank's spread per share if everything sells - If some shares don't sell at $100, the bank still pays the firm $99 each -- the bank keeps those shares and owns part of the firm
Answer: If the IPO goes well, the bank earns $1 per share. If it mispriced the issue, it is stuck holding shares it paid $99 for.
Secondary market
The secondary market is where previously issued securities are resold. Examples are stock, bond, foreign exchange, futures and options markets. Buying RBC shares on a trading platform today is a secondary-market trade: you are buying from someone who bought from someone else, going back to RBC's original issue.
Why: The issuing firm gets no money from these trades. The money goes from buyer to seller.
Why secondary markets matter
Firms still care about secondary markets for two reasons.
- The secondary-market price sets the price the firm can get when it sells new shares in the primary market to raise more money.
- More importantly, secondary markets make securities liquid, meaning easier and quicker to sell. Investors pay more for liquid securities.
Why: Without a secondary market, a share bought at the IPO is hard to get rid of. You would have to find a buyer yourself, which is costly. If a shock hits (say you lose your job) and you need cash fast, you end up in a fire sale, selling at a loss. People value being able to turn an asset into cash quickly, so they pay more for it.
Carreira asked the class twice: "Does the firm earn anything just by this operation, this trade itself?" (No.) Then: "Why is it valuable for the firm?" (Price discovery for future issues, and above all liquidity.) Expect a "why do secondary markets matter" question.
Exchanges and over-the-counter markets
There are two ways to organize a secondary market.
- Exchanges: buyers and sellers meet in one central place to trade. Examples are the Toronto Stock Exchange (stocks) and ICE Futures Canada (commodities like wheat and oats).
- Over-the-counter (OTC) markets: dealers in many locations trade bilaterally, meaning one-on-one. The Canadian government bond market is an OTC market.
Why: OTC markets used to be costlier, but today there are many OTC dealers competing, so in practice the difference from exchanges is small.
Money and capital markets
Splitting markets by maturity
- Money markets: short-term debt instruments, with maturity under 1 year. If you buy one, you are repaid within a year.
- Capital markets: longer-term debt (maturity over 1 year) and equity. Equity is long-term almost by definition, since it never matures.
Why: This split is about time to maturity, not about whether something is debt or equity.
Why money market prices barely move
Money market instruments have the smallest price swings, so they are the least risky investments.
Why: When maturity is close, the future is easy to see. Something extraordinary, like a default, is unlikely to happen within a month. Also, a big price drop would imply an absurd return, so bad news only moves the price a little.
Payoff is what the bond pays at maturity, Price is what you pay for it today, and Return is what you earn as a share of the price over the time you hold it.
A bond pays $100 in one month and costs $99 today. Bad news arrives (government debt rises). Could its price fall to $50?
-- the return over one month at the normal price -- the one-month return if the price fell to $50
Answer: A 100% return in one month makes no sense for a near-certain payment, so the price only moves slightly. That is why money market instruments are low-risk.
Carreira put this to the class as a "why" question. Be ready to explain why short maturity means small price swings. Bond pricing itself comes later in the course.
Treasury bills
Government of Canada Treasury bills pay a set amount at maturity. They are the most liquid and safest money market instrument.
Why: They are the safest, so they have the lowest return. A low return means a high price: you pay more for them.
Certificates of deposit
A certificate of deposit (CD), also called a fixed or term deposit, is a debt instrument a bank sells to depositors. It pays interest and returns the original amount (the principal) at maturity. The main Canadian example is the Guaranteed Investment Certificate (GIC).
Why: It is a deposit with a fixed term. You give up access to the money for a while in exchange for a set interest rate.
You put $1,000 into a one-year GIC at 4% interest.
-- interest for the year -- principal plus interest at maturity
Answer: You get $1,040 back after one year.
Deposit insurance
Bank deposits are insured up to a limit, so a depositor gets their money back if the bank fails. The fund is built from the banks' own contributions. Carreira called it the "FDIC". He first said he thought the limit was $100,000, then used $250,000 after a student suggested it. The slides say the Canadian agency is the CDIC (Canada Deposit Insurance Corporation) and that the limit is $100,000 per depositor. Go with the slides. (The FDIC and its $250,000 limit are the US version.)
Why: It prevents bank runs. Carreira's example: suppose a rumour spreads that the US will sanction Canadian banks. Everyone rushes to withdraw, and that creates a financial panic. If people know they will get their money back up to the limit, most of them have no reason to run.
In class Carreira used a $250,000 limit: with $250,000 in a failed bank you lose nothing, but with $500,000 you would lose the part above the limit. Here it is redone with the slides' CDIC limit of $100,000. You have $250,000 in one bank and the bank fails.
-- the insured part, which is paid back -- the uninsured part, which is at risk
Answer: You are sure to get $100,000 back. The $150,000 above the limit could be lost.
Commercial paper
Commercial paper is a short-term, unsecured debt instrument issued by banks and large corporations.
Why: It is similar to a CD, with two differences. It is usually even shorter-term, and it is unsecured, meaning no insurance or collateral stands behind it.
Repurchase agreements
A repurchase agreement (repo) is effectively a short-term loan, usually for less than two weeks, with Treasury bills as collateral. Collateral is an asset the lender keeps if the borrower doesn't repay.
Why: You get cash without fully selling your bonds. In Carreira's words: "I borrow money from you and I leave this bond as a collateral." If he doesn't repay within, say, a day or a week, you keep the bond. If he does, he pays you back with interest and gets the bond back.
Overnight funds
Overnight funds are typically overnight loans between banks of their deposits at the Bank of Canada. At the end of each day, some banks have surplus settlement balances there and others are short. The banks with a surplus lend to the ones that are short at a set rate, and the loan is repaid the next day. This comes back later in the course.
Why: The bank with spare balances earns interest by lending them out for one night, and the bank that is short covers its gap until the next day.
Capital market instruments
Capital market instruments tend to be riskier and less liquid than short-term securities. Carreira stressed "tend": some stocks are more liquid than some short-term bonds. The main ones:
- Stocks.
- Government of Canada, provincial and municipal bonds, issued to finance deficits.
- Corporate bonds, long-term bonds that usually pay interest twice a year and repay the face value at maturity.
- Consumer and bank commercial loans, where access depends on things like your credit score.
Why: Longer maturity leaves more time for things to go wrong, so prices move more.
Mortgages
Mortgages are loans to households or firms to buy land, housing or other structures. The property itself is the collateral.
Why: Collateral makes lending safer, but not completely safe. As in 2008, the house can end up worth much less than the loan. That is why refinancing involves a new appraisal. If the house is now worth much less, you may not be able to renew on the same terms and could end up giving the house back to the bank.
Mortgage-backed securities
Mortgage-backed securities (MBS) are bond-like debt instruments backed by a bundle of individual mortgages. Banks make mortgage loans, pool them and sell the bundle. The buyer then gets paid as households pay their mortgages.
Why: Selling the bundle moves the default risk from the bank to whoever buys the MBS. These come back in depth in the financial crisis chapter.
Internationalization of financial markets
Foreign bonds and Eurobonds
- Foreign bond: sold in a foreign country and denominated in that country's currency. Example: a Canadian company sells a bond in the UK in British pounds.
- Eurobond: sold in a foreign country but denominated in a different currency. Example: a Canadian company sells a bond in the UK in Canadian dollars, or a US company sells a bond in Canada in US dollars.
Why: Ask two questions: where is the bond sold, and in what currency? If the currency matches the country where it is sold, it is a foreign bond. If not, it is a Eurobond.
Carreira warned that a Eurobond "doesn't mean that it's denominated in euros". It just means the currency differs from the country where it is sold. This is an easy trap on multiple choice.
Eurocurrencies
Eurocurrencies are foreign currencies deposited in banks outside their home country. Carreira's example is a Canadian bank accepting deposits in US dollars. Eurodollars are US dollars deposited in foreign banks outside the US, or in foreign branches of US banks.
Why: Once again "Euro" means "outside the home country", not "euros".
Financial intermediaries
The notes now move from direct finance to indirect finance. Carreira said he maybe should have covered this first, because it matters more for raising funds. This expands "Financial institutions (FIs)" and "Credit allocation and risk management by banks" from Lecture 01.
Financial intermediation
Financial intermediation is indirect finance, where an intermediary stands between lender-savers and borrower-spenders and helps move funds from one to the other. Example: you deposit money in a bank, and the bank either lends to a firm (so the firm is the borrower) or buys Canadian government bonds (so the government is the borrower).
Why: Financial intermediaries are a more important source of financing for corporations than securities markets are.
Lower transaction costs
Transaction costs are the time and money spent carrying out financial transactions. Intermediaries lower them in three ways:
- Economies of scale: transaction costs per deal fall as volume grows. A bank builds its compliance, screening and monitoring setup once and reuses it for every transaction. It doesn't hire a new lawyer for each loan.
- Liquidity services: services that make transactions easier, such as Interac transfers, automatic debits and credit cards. Without a bank, you would have to carry $2,000 in cash to your landlord for rent.
- Economies of scope: one information resource is applied to many services. A bank that learned the risks of lending to young people can reuse much of that knowledge to start lending to seniors.
Why: All three spread a fixed cost (a setup, a network, or knowledge) over many uses.
Risk sharing and asset transformation
Intermediaries reduce investors' exposure to risk, meaning uncertainty about the returns they will earn. The main way is asset transformation: the intermediary sells safe assets to savers and uses the funds to buy riskier assets. Your deposit is a low-risk asset for you (insured, and with little or no return) and a liability for the bank. The bank uses it to make loans (mortgages, car loans, business loans) and to buy bonds, which are riskier.
Why: On your own, you would lend your $1,000 to one person, maybe a relative, and all your risk would sit in that one loan. A bank makes many loans. Some default, most don't, and on average the return beats the losses. That is how the bank earns a spread while paying you a safe return.
Carreira called risk sharing "the most interesting" role, since "there's nothing else that could do this" at that scale. Be able to explain asset transformation: a safe deposit for you, a risky loan portfolio for the bank.
Diversification
Diversification means investing in a portfolio of assets whose returns don't always move together, so overall risk is lower than for any single asset. A bank deposit indirectly gives you a stake in many kinds of loans and securities.
Why: You couldn't do this yourself. You can't lend $1 to each of hundreds of home buyers, local shops and large firms, but the bank does this for you.
Asymmetric information
Asymmetric information means one party to a transaction knows more than the other. It comes in two main types, adverse selection and moral hazard. Intermediaries help solve both by screening borrowers (for example with credit scores) and monitoring them. More on monitoring later if there is time.
Why: Lenders can't see everything about borrowers. A specialist who screens and monitors many borrowers does this much better than an individual saver.
Adverse selection
Adverse selection is asymmetric information before the transaction. One party knows about a hidden characteristic, so bad-quality (risky) borrowers are the ones most likely to seek loans and be selected. One of the main ways lenders fight it is the credit score, which looks at the borrower's history.
Why: Risk-lovers with gamble-like projects are the most eager to borrow at a high rate, while safe borrowers drop out. In financial stress this can get so bad that banks assume everyone asking for a loan is low quality and stop lending altogether.
Loans cost 10% interest. Borrower A's project returns 30% with probability 0.5 and 0% with probability 0.5. Borrower B's project returns a sure 5%.
-- A's expected return -- simplify -- A expects to beat the loan rate, so A borrows -- B's safe project can't cover the interest, so B doesn't borrow
Answer: Only the risky borrower applies. The bank's pool of applicants ends up riskier than the population, and that is adverse selection.
Moral hazard
Moral hazard is asymmetric information after the transaction. The borrower may do things the lender can't see and wouldn't want, which lowers the chance the loan is repaid. Example: someone with a great credit score gets a cheap loan and then spends it on random stuff instead of investing it, so they can't repay. Insurance example: once you have car insurance with a low premium, you start driving recklessly.
Why: A credit score can't catch this, because it only looks at the past. Lenders need monitoring after the deal.
The key split is before the transaction (adverse selection, fought with screening and credit scores) versus after it (moral hazard, fought with monitoring). Carreira asked the class how lenders detect adverse selection; the answer he wanted was the credit score.
Types of financial intermediaries
There are three main groups:
- Depository institutions (banks): accept deposits and make loans. They are chartered banks, trust and mortgage loan companies, and credit unions and caisses populaires.
- Contractual savings institutions: take in funds at regular intervals under a contract. They are life insurance companies, property and casualty insurance companies, and pension and retirement funds.
- Investment intermediaries: finance companies, mutual funds, money market mutual funds, hedge funds and investment banks. Investing in a mutual fund is not a deposit. The fund invests for you, and withdrawal rules depend on the fund. Deposits, by contrast, can be withdrawn at any time.
Table 2-3 shows each type's main liabilities (sources of funds) and main assets (uses of funds). For chartered banks, the liabilities are deposits and the assets are loans, mortgages and government bonds. For mutual funds, the liabilities are shares and the assets are stocks and bonds, depending on whether it is a fixed-income or a stock fund.
Why: Liabilities are where an intermediary gets its money, and assets are where it puts that money. Reading the table this way tells you what each intermediary actually does.
Relative size of intermediaries
Among institutions and pension plans regulated by OSFI (as of December 31, 2020), domestic chartered banks hold $6,909,661 million of the $11,450,677 million total, or 60.34%. Pension plans (17.20%) and Canadian life insurers (14.71%) come next.
Why: Domestic banks are by far the main financial intermediary in Canada, holding more than half of the assets in Table 2-4. (The table only covers institutions and pension plans regulated by OSFI. It leaves out things like mutual funds and provincially regulated credit unions.)
Regulation of financial markets
This extends "Why financial markets are regulated so heavily" from Lecture 01. The lecture ended partway through this part, and the slide listing the regulatory agencies was not reached.
Why regulate
Financial markets and intermediaries are central to the economy. If intermediaries fail, lenders lose their money, and the intermediaries also stop lending to firms. Those firms can then fail too, and so on. That spreading chain is called systemic risk. There are two main reasons to regulate:
- Increase the information available to investors. Public balance sheets and financial statements show a firm's earnings and debt. This reduces adverse selection and moral hazard, and markets become more efficient because people are less afraid to lend.
- Ensure the soundness of financial intermediaries, so that financial panics are avoided.
The types of regulation are restrictions on entry (not just anyone can open a bank), restrictions on assets and activities, reporting requirements, and deposit insurance. Carreira's example of an asset restriction: banks can't buy stocks. If stock prices crashed and depositors ran, the bank might lack the liquidity to pay them back, and a panic would follow. (That is a simplification. Canadian banks can hold some shares, within limits set by the Bank Act. The textbook's point is that regulation restricts risky assets such as common stocks. On a test, "restrictions on holding risky assets like stocks" is the safe way to put it.)
Why: Both reasons tie back to earlier ideas. More information fights asymmetric information, and soundness rules (plus deposit insurance) stop bank runs.
Exam checklist
- #Two routes for funds: direct means through markets, indirect means through an intermediary. Know the examples and the flowchart.
- #Residual claimants: equity holders are paid only after all debt holders.
- #Why secondary markets matter: the firm gets no money from these trades, but they set future issue prices and give liquidity.
- #Why money market prices barely move: close to maturity, a big price drop would imply an absurd return.
- #Foreign bonds and Eurobonds: "Euro" does not mean euros.
- #Risk sharing and asset transformation: a safe deposit becomes a risky, pooled loan portfolio.
- #Moral hazard: before the deal is adverse selection (credit score), after the deal is moral hazard (monitoring).
Admin & deadlines
- Slides for this lecture are posted. Lecture notes (a fuller text version of the slides) will be posted by Friday, September 18.
- Quizzes are on MyLearningSpace. Carreira's plan is to post each quiz by Friday (sometimes Thursday), due at the end of Wednesday, before Thursday's class. The first quiz was to go up by September 18 and be due Wednesday, September 23. Check MyLS for the exact times, since the syllabus says quiz dates are posted there.
- Textbook: the slides and lectures are meant to be enough on their own. The book (Mishkin and Serletis, 8th Canadian ed.) adds detail for anything unclear. A practice midterm and a practice final will also be provided.
- Reading: Section 2.6 of the textbook, for details on each type of financial intermediary. Carreira won't go through them in class.
Transcribed automatically from the lecture recording. Slides used: EC 223 - 2026-09-15 - Lecture 02 - An Overview of the Financial System (slides).pdf. Course info used: EC 223 - Syllabus - Fall 2026.pdf. Audio archived at /mnt/porsche/configs/lectures/archive/2026-09/EC 223 - 2026-09-15 - Lecture 02.opus.