AS 101 - 2026-09-30 - Lecture 06
AS 101 - Lecture 06 - 2026-09-30
Week 4 · 17:38-18:31 · 53 min · Full transcript · Flashcards
Overview
This lecture started the history of astronomy, beginning with ancient astronomy; modern astronomy comes next lecture. It opened with Stephen Hawking's idea that time itself began at the Big Bang. It then showed that people in every culture watched the sky for farming and navigation, and left evidence in paintings, monuments and records. Most of the lecture covered the ancient Greeks: the geocentric model, parallax, Eratosthenes measuring the Earth, Hipparchus, and Plato's "perfect" uniform circular motion, which later turned out to be wrong.
Why time has a history
This builds on the Big Bang and spacetime from Lectures 2 and 3.
Time began at the Big Bang
Stephen Hawking (once a visiting professor at the Perimeter Institute) wrote A Brief History of Time. Its title means that time has a history: it started 13.8 billion years ago, when spacetime suddenly began to expand at the Big Bang. Before that there was no time, so science says nothing about "before".
Why: Hawking's analogy is that asking what came before the Big Bang is like standing at the North Pole and asking "Where is north?" The lecturer compared it to asking for a grade higher than A+ or lower than F. The history is "brief" because 13.8 billion years is short on astronomical scales.
Why ancient people watched the sky
What we know today came from many people's work, collected over thousands of years.
Recognising patterns
Ancient people grouped stars into shapes, the way we saw with constellations, because a shape is easy to remember. Cultures all over the world did this, including in Africa, South America, China and Japan, and Indigenous peoples here in Canada.
Why: Astronomy started with curiosity about how things happen. Science depends on evidence, so the archaeological sites and records below show what these cultures knew.
Farming and navigation
- Farming: knowing the seasons told people when to plant and when to harvest. In southern Ontario the growing window is only about six months, so timing matters.
- Navigation: people used the North Star as a fixed point to work out where they were. It worked like a GPS.
Archaeoastronomy
Archaeoastronomy terms
- Archaeoastronomy: archaeology and astronomy combined. It studies old buildings and objects that had an astronomical meaning.
- Observatory: a place that holds instruments for watching the sky. Today that means a building full of telescopes.
- BCE and CE: "Before the Common Era" and "Common Era" replace BC and AD. The numbers are the same; the names are just more neutral.
Ancient sky monuments
- A painting from about 15,000 BCE, in what is now France, shows a star map, or the zodiac.
- A structure in Ireland from about 3000 BCE has unknown builders. The lecturer said structures like it mark the four special days of the year: the solstices and equinoxes. (He said "the longest day, September the 21st". Per the slides, the longest day is the summer solstice, June 21, and September 22 is the fall equinox.)
- Stonehenge (builders unknown) served as an observatory. It lines up with sunrise and sunset, moonrise and moonset, and the summer and winter solstices.
Why: Curious people built these to track the cycles of the Sun and Moon that we studied in Chapter 2.
The first female astronomer
In Babylon (today's Iraq), about 4,000 years ago, a female librarian kept records of the sky. She observed and recorded a solar eclipse, and we still have that record. She is the first female astronomer in recorded history. The lecturer said the Babylonians also defined and identified our constellations. (Many constellations do trace back to Babylon, but the official 88 and their borders were set by the International Astronomical Union, as in Lecture 3.) (Her name was shown in class but is not in the recording or the slides, so check the posted slides. Most references name Enheduanna, a high priestess in Ur around 2300 BCE, as the first named female astronomer. If the slide shows her, note that references call her a priestess, not a librarian.)
"I might ask the name of this female librarian, first female astronomer in the recorded history." Get her name from the posted slides.
Ancient supernova records
A supernova is the huge explosion of a dying star; it is covered in detail with the life cycle of stars. The lecturer said China recorded the earliest known supernova, in 1400 BCE. (Most references give 185 CE, also from Chinese records, as the earliest confirmed supernova record. Know his 1400 BCE for his tests, but check the textbook.) The lecturer said a South American painting also shows a supernova. It includes a hand, which he said is there because people saw the event as holy or powerful, and a crescent Moon that marks the supernova's position. (The best-known painting like this is at Chaco Canyon in New Mexico, USA, so it is North American. It is thought to show the supernova of 1054 CE.)
Why: The Chinese observers thought the explosion was happening as they watched. They knew nothing about light travel time, but the light had left the star long before (see light travel time, Lecture 2).
Polaris as a landmark
Polaris, the North Star, stays fixed in the sky while other stars move. Indigenous peoples in Canada had their own name for it, meaning "the one that never moves". People used it as a landmark to work out where they were. (The Indigenous name he showed is not recoverable from the recording.)
Why: Polaris sits almost exactly above Earth's north pole. The lecturer said that because Canada is so close to the North Pole, it is always there. (In fact Polaris never sets anywhere north of the equator. Its height above the horizon equals your latitude, so from Canada it sits fairly high. See circumpolar stars, Lecture 4.)
On Polaris being fixed and used as a landmark: "That's another question you might expect to be on."
How GPS finds you
GPS uses the same landmark idea as Polaris. Your phone works out where it is relative to satellites. The lecturer said three references are enough to fix your position using circles. (In practice a phone needs at least four satellites: three for the position and one more to correct its own clock.) The satellites carry atomic clocks (cesium clocks), which have to allow for Einstein's result that time runs slower closer to a massive object.
Why: Time is not absolute: it is not the same for everyone in space. This extends relativity from earlier lectures.
Ancient Greek astronomy
Names to know
The lecture showed a timeline of astronomers. You don't need the dates, but you should know some of the names.
"I don't expect that you should know all this timing and all, but some of the names, you should know that. I will keep on emphasizing those names again and again so that will give you a hint."
What the Greeks added
The Greeks used only their naked eyes, since there were no telescopes. They were the first to combine models with observations, and they did systematic, sustained research. The lecturer said their documents are the first preserved written records of astronomy. (Older Babylonian sky records survive, like the librarian's eclipse record above. The Greek records are the oldest that explain the sky with models.) Science was then called philosophy, which is why a PhD is a "Doctor of Philosophy". It later branched into chemistry, biology and the other sciences.
Why: The method of investigating is as important as the discovery itself.
Thales of Miletus
Thales correctly predicted a solar eclipse.
Pythagoras
Pythagoras gave the formula linking the three sides of a right-angled triangle.
Why: It lets you find a missing side of a right triangle, which is the basis of a lot of ancient geometry.
where a and b are the two shorter sides and c is the longest side (the hypotenuse).
A right triangle has short sides of 3 and 4. Find the long side.
-- put the two short sides into the formula -- square each side -- add -- take the square root
Answer:
First principles
A first principle is the obvious starting point, based on what you see. (This is the lecturer's meaning. In most science writing, "first principles" means the basic laws that everything else is worked out from. Use his meaning for his tests.) For example, "the Earth looks flat" or "the sky looks like a sphere". Science starts there, then adds observations until it finds out, for example, that the Earth is really spherical.
Why: You have to start somewhere, and there is nothing wrong with starting from the obvious.
The geocentric model
In the geocentric model, Earth sits fixed at the centre and everything goes around it. The celestial sphere from Lecture 3 is a geocentric model.
Why: It came from the religious belief of the time that there were only two things, earth and heaven. Heaven had to be perfect, so the Moon, Sun and stars had to be perfect, highly polished spheres moving in circles. First principles agreed: I see no one else at the centre, so I must be the centre.
Aristotle and a round Earth
The lecturer said Aristotle was the first to work out that the Earth is not flat but spherical. (Most references say Pythagoras and his followers first proposed a round Earth. Aristotle gave the first evidence for it, such as Earth's curved shadow on the Moon during a lunar eclipse. The ship example is a later argument that shows the same curve.) One piece of evidence is a ship sailing away: its bottom disappears first.
Why: On a curved Earth, the curve hides the lower part of the ship first. On a flat Earth, the whole ship would just shrink.
Aristarchus
Aristarchus estimated the size of the Sun and its distance from us (the real distance is one astronomical unit, almost 150 million km). He also proposed that the Earth rotates on its axis, and he used parallax. His numbers had low accuracy, so his ideas went nowhere.
Parallax
Parallax is the apparent shift of an object when you look at it from two different positions. You can test it by holding your thumb out at arm's length and closing one eye, then the other: your thumb seems to jump.
Why: If you see parallax, you have proven that you are moving. Ancient astronomers saw no shift in the stars, so they assumed Earth is fixed, which supported the geocentric model. They saw no shift because even the nearest stars are very far away (about 4.2 light-years), and without telescopes they could not detect such tiny shifts.
"Keep in mind, once I observe parallax, then I can prove that I am moving." And: "The ancient astronomers assumed the earth did not move because they didn't observe any parallax."
He stressed this with "keep in mind", but he did not say it will be on a test.
Eratosthenes measures the Earth
Eratosthenes measured the size of the Earth using two sticks (or pipes), two cities, and simple proportion. He had no calculator, only geometry.
Why: The Sun is so far away (150 million km) that its rays arrive parallel. On a flat Earth, two upright sticks would cast the same shadow. Because the Earth is curved, a stick in one city cast no shadow while a stick in the other city cast one at the same moment. The shadow angle equals the angle between the cities measured from Earth's centre. The lecturer compared the proportion to apples: if one apple costs $1.50, what do 10 cost?
where θ is the shadow angle, d is the distance between the two cities, C is Earth's circumference and r is Earth's radius.
Alexandria and Syene are 5,000 stadia apart (a stadion is an old unit, about the length of a stadium). At the same time on the same day, the stick in one city casts no shadow, and the other casts a shadow at 7.2°.
-- the angle's share of a full circle equals the distance's share of the circumference -- solve for C -- 7.2° is one fiftieth of a circle stadia -- the full circumference km -- the lecturer's figure in kilometres -- rearrange to get the radius km -- divide
Answer: About 40,000 km around and about 6,369 km in radius -- very close to the 6,371 km radius on the slides.
The lecturer said he and a friend in the other city agreed on a day and a time, probably using water clocks. (Most accounts say he needed no helper. He knew the Sun shone straight down a well in Syene at noon on the summer solstice, so he measured the shadow in Alexandria at noon that day.) One of them checked when the light went straight down a stick, and the other measured the shadow at that same moment.
Asked whether students would have to calculate this: "No. But you should remember that name. That's all. I'm not going to ask you to use mathematics." Also: "I want you to remember the name Eratosthenes. He selected two cities, two pipes, two sticks."
Hipparchus
Around 150 BCE, Hipparchus built a star catalogue with about 850 entries. He developed trigonometry (sine, cosine and tangent; a tangent touches a circle at only one point). He also created the scale for comparing star brightness: the magnitude scale from Lecture 3, which he said a quiz was on. He discovered precession, and the lecturer said he also found that Earth's axis is tilted. (Precession is his real discovery. The tilt was known before him; Eratosthenes, for one, had already measured it.) The lecturer called him "the greatest astronomer".
Precession is not tilt
Precession is the slow wobble of Earth's spinning axis, which comes back to the same position after 26,000 years (see Lecture 4). Tilt is the fixed lean of the axis. They are different things, and only tilt causes the seasons.
Why: The tilt changes how directly sunlight hits each hemisphere over the year. Precession is far too slow to cause a yearly cycle.
"That is not the tilt, keep in mind." And: "So, don't ever answer the question like, 'What is the reason for season is?' ... not the precession, it is the tilt." In other words, never give precession as the reason for the seasons.
Other names
- Alexander the Great was the next name the lecturer mentioned after Hipparchus. (Alexander was a king, not an astronomer. He lived 356–323 BCE, about two centuries before Hipparchus, so he did not come after him.)
- Hypatia was a female astronomer.
- Aryabhata was credited by the lecturer with inventing zero. (Most references credit the Indian mathematician Brahmagupta, around 628 CE, with first treating zero as a number. Aryabhata, around 500 CE, used a place-value system. Know the lecturer's version for his tests.)
Plato and the perfect heavens
Plato, a philosopher and Aristotle's teacher, taught that the heavens are perfect. The perfect shape is a sphere, and the perfect motion is uniform circular motion.
Uniform circular motion
Uniform circular motion has two parts. "Circular" means the object moves in a circle. "Uniform" means it moves at a constant speed, never speeding up or slowing down. The lecturer said the ancients assumed every planet moved in a circle, all at the same speed (his example was 50 km/h for every planet). (Most references say each planet had its own constant speed, since outer planets like Saturn clearly take longer to go around. The key idea is that a planet's speed never changes.) Both parts are wrong:
- Orbits are ellipses, not circles. That is why Earth is sometimes closer to the Sun and sometimes farther (see perihelion and aphelion, Lecture 4). On a circle, the distance would never change.
- Planets do not keep the same speed. They move faster closer to the centre and slower farther away.
Why: Fixing this mistake is how we came to the correct picture of the universe, which leads into modern astronomy next lecture.
He closed the lecture on this and called it "the biggest mystery of all the time" and "the biggest mistake they made. Both are totally wrong today."
He did not say it will be on a test.
Exam checklist
- #Names to know: know the astronomers' names, not the dates.
- #The first female astronomer: he may ask the Babylonian librarian's name.
- #Polaris as a landmark: the fixed star, used as a landmark.
- #Parallax: no parallax seen, so the ancients assumed Earth was fixed.
- #Eratosthenes measures the Earth: remember the name and the method; no calculation.
- #Precession is not tilt: tilt causes the seasons, not precession.
- #Uniform circular motion: both wrong: orbits are ellipses, and speed changes.
Admin & deadlines
- Quizzes: today's in-class quiz is closed. Quizzes are session-restricted, so no one else can log in for you. The same kinds of questions will come up on the midterm (Monday, October 19, 5:30–6:50 pm, LH 3094) and on the final.
- Assignment 1: opens today (September 30) and is due next Wednesday, October 7, which matches the syllabus. It has 70 multiple-choice and true-or-false questions. Once you start, you have 80 minutes and must finish in one sitting; you cannot split it across days. It is session-restricted: only you, under your own login. If two people log in it blocks you, and the mark is "gone forever". He said it is worth 10%, which matches the syllabus (two assignments, 20% total).
- Academic integrity: he will report anyone who has someone else do a quiz or assignment, and "will not hesitate even a nanosecond".
- Next lecture: modern astronomy (Copernicus, Galileo, Newton and Einstein). The syllabus schedules this topic, "The Origin of Modern Astronomy", as Chapter 3 of ASTRO.
- Optional reading: Stephen Hawking's A Brief History of Time. It costs about $20 at Indigo in Conestoga Mall. The library copy can only be read by one person at a time.
Transcribed automatically from the lecture recording. Slides used: AS 101 - Ch. 02 - The Sky - Patterns, Cycles and Seasons (slides).pdf. Course info used: AS 101 - Syllabus - Fall 2026.pdf. Audio archived at /mnt/porsche/configs/lectures/archive/2026-09/AS 101 - 2026-09-30 - Lecture 06.opus.