EC 223 - 2026-09-17 - Lecture 03
EC 223 - Lecture 03 - 2026-09-17
Week 2 · 17:36-18:21 · 45 min · Full transcript · Flashcards
Overview
This lecture covered Chapter 3 of Mishkin & Serletis: what money is and how it is measured. It started with the definition of money, how it differs from wealth and income, and its three functions: medium of exchange, unit of account and store of value. It then asked whether money needs a government, using historical cases and hyperinflations. It also traced how payment systems evolved from commodity money to fiat money and electronic payments. It ended with the Bank of Canada's measures of the money supply (M1+, M1++, M2, M2+, M2++, M3) and why the choice of measure matters.
Meaning of money
Carreira opened with the question: "What exactly is money?"
What money is
Money is anything that is generally accepted as payment for goods and services or in the repayment of debts. Currency (banknotes and coins) is the clearest example. There is debate over which other instruments count as money, and the answer can change over time.
Why: The definition rests on acceptance, not on what the object is made of. Carreira said understanding the functions of money is "the first step" in the debate over what counts as money.
Money, wealth and income
- Wealth is the total collection of assets that store value. It includes money, and also bonds, common stock, art, land, furniture, cars and houses.
- Income is a flow of earnings per unit of time.
- Money is only one kind of asset. A rich person may hold most of their wealth as land, stocks or buildings rather than as money.
Why: In everyday speech "money" means being rich or earning a lot. In economics it means only the thing used to pay, so mixing the words up leads to wrong answers.
Carreira flagged this as "one important thing": money is different from wealth. Land, stocks and buildings "are assets, but they are not money."
The three functions of money
To decide whether something is money, Carreira said to test it against these three functions.
Medium of exchange
Money is used to pay for goods and services. For this to work, it must be accepted. People take Canadian dollars because they trust that everyone else will, which Carreira called "kind of like a faith thing." In the modern world, this acceptance has largely been set up by the government.
Why: Money promotes economic efficiency in two ways. First, it removes the need for a double coincidence of wants. In a barter economy (where goods and services are traded directly for other goods and services), you must find someone who has what you want and wants what you have. Carreira's example: to get shoes, water and a phone, he would have to find a phone seller who wants economics lessons, then a shoe seller who does too. With money, he sells his teaching to the university once and buys everything else with the pay. This lowers transaction costs because less time is spent on exchanges. Second, it allows specialization and the division of labour. Without money, a farmer would grow oats, beans and rice for themselves instead of trading. With money, they can focus on what they are most productive at, sell it, and buy the rest.
What makes a good medium of exchange
An effective medium of exchange must be:
- Easily standardized. Every $10 note is the same. Rocks or tables come in different shapes and qualities.
- Widely accepted. A piece of paper you write "$100" on will be refused at the grocery store, even if it looks official.
- Divisible. If only $100 notes existed, buying one pen would mean buying 100 pens.
- Easy to carry. Nobody wants to bring 1 kg of silver to a restaurant.
- Resistant to deterioration. It should still be there a year later, not rot like food.
Carreira's example was the stone money of the Pacific island of Yap. Some stones were centimetres across and some were up to 4 metres tall, Carreira said. (Most references put the largest at about 3.6 metres across. The 4 metres is his rounded figure.) The big ones never moved. They usually stayed in front of the first owner's house, and people tracked who owned each stone by talking to each other. It was accepted, probably standardized in some way, and very durable (Carreira said the stone pictured is now at the Bank of Canada). But it was terrible to carry. It was still money, just "not good money."
Unit of account
Money provides the units in which value is measured throughout the economy.
Why: Without money, each good's value would have to be quoted against every other good. Carreira's example: a table is half a laptop, a watch is a third of a laptop, a TV is two laptops. With nearly unlimited products, that means nearly unlimited comparisons. With money, everything is priced in dollars, which cuts the number of prices and lowers transaction costs.
Take four goods: a table, a laptop, a watch and a TV. Compare quoting prices with and without money.
- Without money, list every pair: table–laptop, table–watch, table–TV, laptop–watch, laptop–TV, watch–TV -- each pair needs its own price.
- Count them:
prices -- six exchange rates to remember. - With money, each good gets one dollar price:
prices -- one per good. - With
goods, barter needs prices but money needs only . For 100 goods: prices against -- the gap widens fast as goods are added.
Answer: 6 prices without money, 4 with money -- the gap grows very fast as goods are added, which is why barter pricing becomes "simply impossible."
Store of value
Money serves as a repository of purchasing power over time. It lets you earn today and spend in the future.
Why: Without a store of value, you would have to spend your pay the moment you got it. Money is not the only store of value, and houses, land, stocks, bonds, art or jewellery may store value better. What sets money apart is that it is the most liquid asset. Money is also a worse store of value over long periods because of inflation. Carreira said that if you leave cash uninvested for 100 years, "probably you won't be able to buy anything." So it stores value only within a time horizon, and how well it does depends on the country.
Liquidity
Liquidity is the relative ease and speed with which an asset can be converted into a medium of exchange. Money is the most liquid asset by definition, because it is itself the medium of exchange.
Why: A house may hold its value well, but turning it into something you can spend is slow and costly. You need to sell it and pay a realtor. That is why it is a poor medium of exchange even when it is a good store of value.
How the functions are linked
The three functions depend on each other. During hyperinflation (commonly defined as inflation above 50% per month), currency becomes a poor store of value. It can then also become a poor medium of exchange. A seller who is paid in that currency would also have to rush to spend it before it lost more value, so sellers stop wanting to accept it.
A basket of groceries costs
- Each month prices are multiplied by
, so after 12 months the factor is -- compounding month on month. -- two months. -- four months. -- eight months. -- twelve months. -- the basket's new price.
Answer: about
Carreira: "This is like three functions of money is, I would say, the main takeaway from today's lecture." Know all three (medium of exchange, unit of account, store of value), why each matters, and how hyperinflation breaks the store-of-value function and then the medium-of-exchange function.
Can money exist without government?
Carreira said this section is "not in the book," just reflection. It builds on the idea that money works because people accept it.
Money can emerge without government
Money can emerge through decentralized exchange. The key idea is that people accept money partly because they expect others to accept it.
- Zimbabwe: when the Zimbabwean dollar collapsed in hyperinflation, people started accepting U.S. dollars and South African rand. The government was not issuing them, but people used them anyway.
- Somalia: the government collapsed in 1991, but Somali shillings kept circulating because network effects kept everyone accepting them. The problem was that nobody could verify authenticity, so people printed their own copies. They kept printing until making a fake note cost more than the note was worth.
Carreira said gold and Bitcoin are not money today, since you cannot pay with "two grams of gold" in most places. But if people lost trust in the government and agreed on gold as money, it could become money.
Unusual historical forms of money
- Wampum beads were used in trade and as stores of value by some Indigenous nations and European colonists.
- Tobacco was used as commodity money in colonial Virginia.
- Playing-card money was issued by authorities in New France in 1685 to pay troops. While waiting for coins from France, officials gave soldiers signed playing cards redeemable for coins later. The soldiers began trading the cards among themselves, so the cards circulated as money. (Carreira presented this as money arising among the soldiers themselves. Note that the cards were issued by the colonial authorities, as the slide says, and Intendant Jacques de Meulles ordered that they be accepted as payment. Do not say no authority was involved.)
- Cigarettes were used in prisoner-of-war camps during World War II.
- Vodka was briefly used as a medium of exchange during Russia's 1998 crisis.
Carreira mentioned stories of people who did not smoke or drink but still accepted cigarettes or vodka, because they could use them to buy things. People may accept an object not because they want to consume it, but because they expect others to accept it.
When money loses its value
- Germany after World War I: Carreira said one explanation is war reparations, which led to printing money to pay them. At the peak in 1923, prices roughly doubled every four days. People spent their Papiermarks the moment they were paid, since even one day's wait meant buying less. The currency became an extremely poor store of value. Sellers then stopped wanting to accept it, so it also failed as a medium of exchange.
- Zimbabwe: hyperinflation led to a $100 trillion banknote. Cash was used as wallpaper, and people carried buckets of it to shop. That made it hard to transport, people stopped accepting it, and it was replaced.
- Argentina: almost everyone tries to hold U.S. dollars because they do not trust the peso.
Is Bitcoin money
Carreira's view is that Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies are not money today.
- It is not widely used as a medium of exchange.
- It is not a unit of account, since nobody knows what a shirt costs in Bitcoin.
- Whether it is a store of value is debatable, because it can fall about 10% in a day. Prices measured in it would change "minute by minute almost." Many people would say it cannot be a store of value.
He added that this could change in the future.
Evolution of the payments system
Payments system
The payments system is the methods used to conduct transactions in the economy. The form of money has changed over history.
Commodity money
Commodity money is money that has value as a commodity in addition to its value as a medium of exchange. Examples are gold, silver and other commodities. Precious metals were the most common because they are durable, standardized and divisible.
Why it faded: Precious metals are costly and inconvenient to transport. Carreira noted gold has risen so much in value that small amounts buy more now. Even a few years ago, though, buying a car or a house took a lot of metal, especially silver.
Paper currency
Paper currency is pieces of paper that function as a medium of exchange. It often started as representative money, meaning it could be converted into coins or a fixed quantity of precious metal. In 19th-century Canada, banks issued banknotes redeemable for gold or silver. Carreira described it this way: you deposited gold, got a certificate for, say, 10 grams, and people began trading the certificates instead of redeeming them. The paper itself became money.
Problem: counterfeiting and the cost of verifying authenticity. Carreira's example was a fake note from a bank with a name slightly different from a real bank, which people could not easily spot.
Fiat money
Fiat money is money that is not redeemable for a fixed quantity of a commodity. It is typically issued by a government or central bank and recognized as legal tender. It has little or no intrinsic value.
Why: People accept it because they trust the issuer and expect others to accept it. Nobody takes Canadian dollars expecting to swap them for gold at a bank.
Cheques and electronic payments
- Cheques are written instructions to a bank to move money from one account to another. They lower some transaction costs but take time to clear. They are payment instruments, not money.
- Electronic payments are instructions to transfer bank deposits electronically, for example an e-transfer. Debit cards are also payment instruments, not money.
- Stored-value balances and e-cash, such as stored-value cards or PayPal, may count as forms of electronic money, because they work somewhat like an account.
Measuring money
This section applies the definition of money to the real economy.
Why measuring money is hard
Since money is whatever is generally accepted as payment, whether an asset is money depends on people's behaviour. Many assets are close to money. Carreira gave two examples:
- Savings accounts. Today most debit cards can draw directly from savings. In the past, you had to move funds to your chequing account first, and that extra step made savings less than fully liquid.
- Bonds. A fairly safe bond can be sold quickly and the money spent, but no store will take the bond itself.
Whether these count as money depends on which definition you use.
Monetary aggregates
The Bank of Canada measures money with several monetary aggregates. They run from the narrowest (most liquid) to broader measures. Carreira said the broader measures build on the narrower ones, and the instruments added at each level tend to be less liquid, though "it's not necessarily strict."
- M1+ is currency outside banks plus chequable deposits at chartered banks, trust and mortgage loan companies (TMLs), and credit unions and caisses populaires (CUCPs). Carreira described it as "your current account and any cash you have," the narrowest definition of money.
- M1++ is M1+ plus all nonchequable deposits at chartered banks, TMLs and CUCPs, such as a nonchequable savings account.
- M2 is currency outside banks plus personal deposits at chartered banks, non-personal demand and notice deposits at chartered banks, and fixed-term deposits.
- M2+ is M2 plus deposits at TMLs and CUCPs, life insurance company individual annuities, personal deposits at government-owned savings institutions, and money market mutual funds.
- M2++ is M2+ plus other retail instruments and non-money market mutual funds.
- M3 is M2 plus non-personal term deposits at chartered banks and foreign currency deposits of residents at chartered banks.
One catch from the slide diagrams: M2 does not contain all of M1+. Carreira said "M2 includes M1, and M3 includes uh M2 and M1," but by the slide definitions that is only roughly true. Chequable deposits at TMLs and CUCPs are in M1+, but they only come in at M2+ (as part of all deposits at TMLs and CUCPs). M3 is built on M2, not M2+, so M3 does not include TML and CUCP deposits either. Go by the slide definitions if a question asks what each aggregate contains.
Carreira admitted he does not know every line item himself, such as what a government-owned savings institution is. The full list is in Table 3-1 of the textbook.
Carreira: "The most like important thing is for you is like understanding that there are different measures, and what are the most liquid ones and less liquid ones." You do not need to memorize every obscure line item, but know that M1+ is the narrowest and most liquid and that the broader measures add less liquid instruments.
Why the choice of aggregate matters
Different aggregates can move in different directions in the short run. Figure 3-2 in the slides (growth rates of M2, M1++ and M2++, 1969 to 2020) shows they mostly rise and fall together. But in some periods, such as around 1998 to 2003, M2 growth fell below zero while M1++ and M2++ kept growing.
Why: If policymakers want to know whether a monetary expansion is happening, one measure can say yes while another says no. Those conflicting signals can point to different policy choices, so the choice of aggregate matters.
Weighted monetary aggregates
The Bank of Canada's measures are simple-sum indices: each component is just added up. A weighted aggregate instead gives each component a weight. Research suggests weighted aggregates predict inflation and the business cycle somewhat better than the usual measures.
Why: Carreira suggested the reason is probably liquidity. More liquid instruments could get a higher weight, since they are quickly spent, and spending raises demand and inflation.
where
Suppose (made-up numbers, not real data) currency outside banks is
-- M1+ has four components here. -- put in the amounts, in billions. , then , then -- add them up.
Answer:
Carreira called this part "less important" and said he included it "just because it's in the book." He said later chapters return to money supply, and that quantitative easing makes these measures harder to interpret today.
Exam checklist
- #Money, wealth and income: money is not wealth. Land, stocks and buildings are assets, not money.
- #How the functions are linked: the three functions are "the main takeaway" of the lecture. Hyperinflation breaks store of value, then medium of exchange.
- #Monetary aggregates: know that there are different measures and which are more or less liquid.
Admin & deadlines
- Textbook access: Carreira emailed Pearson about access problems and was meeting a representative on Friday, September 18. He will post an announcement once it is fixed.
- Other editions: a student asked about using the 12th edition. Carreira said it is probably the American version. The concepts are about the same, but Canadian material (the Bank of Canada, GICs) will differ, so it is "at your own risk." He referred to the "Canadian 11th edition," but the syllabus lists the required text as the 8th Canadian edition of Mishkin & Serletis (2023). Go by the syllabus. The syllabus also says the Digital Textbook Access opt-out deadline is September 24, 2026. If you do not opt out, $71.99 is charged to LORIS on your October invoice (code DBK).
- Quiz: to be posted by the end of Friday, September 18, and due at the end of the day on Wednesday, September 23. Two attempts, with a long time limit. Per the syllabus, the higher attempt counts, and the best 7 quizzes are averaged for 14% of the grade. Notes and the textbook are allowed, but generative AI and help from others are not. Carreira plans to repeat this pattern each week: posted by the end of Friday, due the following Wednesday.
- Reading: Table 3-1 in the textbook, which lists everything in each monetary aggregate.
- Next lecture: probably Chapter 4.
- Midterm: October 8, 2026, in person during class, closed book, worth 37%. It covers everything taught up to then, with multiple-choice and short-answer questions. This is from the syllabus; it was not mentioned in this lecture.
Transcribed automatically from the lecture recording. Slides used: EC 223 - 2026-09-17 - Lecture 03 - What Is Money (slides).pdf. Course info used: EC 223 - Syllabus - Fall 2026.pdf. Audio archived at /mnt/porsche/configs/lectures/archive/2026-09/EC 223 - 2026-09-17 - Lecture 03.opus.