EC 223 - 2026-10-01 - Lecture 07

EC 223 - Lecture 07 - 2026-10-01

Economics of the Canadian Banking and Financial System · Igor Antonio Araujo Carreira · LH 1009

Week 4 · 18:13-18:34 · 21 min · Full transcript · Flashcards

Overview

The first 40 minutes or so were not recorded, so that part is written from the slides. This lecture covered Chapter 7 of Mishkin & Serletis. It started with how to value a share of common stock: price equals the present value of expected dividends and the future sale price, which leads to the one-period model, the generalized dividend model and the Gordon growth model. It then turned to how people form expectations, contrasting rational expectations with adaptive expectations. Finally, it applied rational expectations to financial markets as the efficient market hypothesis, which says prices reflect all available information, so price changes are unpredictable.

Valuing common stock

This builds on equity and residual claimants (Lecture 2) and present value (Lecture 4): a stock is valued the same way as a bond, by discounting its expected cash flows.

Common stock

From the slides: the recording missed this part.
Common stock is the main way corporations raise equity capital. A stockholder owns a share of the firm equal to their percentage of the outstanding shares.

Why: A stock is just a claim on future cash, so it is worth what those future payments are worth in today's dollars.

One-period valuation model

From the slides: the recording missed this part.
If you buy a stock, hold it for one period and then sell it, its value today is the present value of the dividend you get plus the present value of the price you sell it for.

Why: Those two payments are the only cash you will ever receive from the stock, so discounting them at your required return gives what the stock is worth to you.

P0=D11+ke+P11+ke

where P0 is the current price (period 0 is the present), D1 is the expected dividend at t=1, ke is the required rate of return on equity (it depends on the particular stock), and P1 is the expected price at the end of the first period.

Example: Should you buy Intel stock?

Intel sells for $50 a share and pays an annual dividend of $0.16. You require a 12% return and forecast a price of $60 in one year, when you plan to sell.

  1. P0=0.161+0.12+601+0.12 -- put the numbers into the formula
  2. 0.161.12=0.1429 -- present value of the dividend
  3. 601.12=53.5714 -- present value of the sale price
  4. 0.1429+53.5714=53.71 -- add the two present values
  5. 53.71>50 -- compare the value with the market price

Answer: $53.71 -- the stock is worth more to you than its $50 price, so at a 12% required return it is worth buying.

Generalized dividend model

From the slides: the recording missed this part.
Extending the holding period to n periods, the stock's value is the present value of every expected dividend plus the present value of the final sale price. As n grows, the final price stops mattering, so the stock is worth the present value of its whole future dividend stream.

Why: The sale price Pn is itself just the discounted value of the dividends after period n. Under the standard no-bubble condition, its present value shrinks toward zero as n gets large, so only dividends are left.

P0=D1(1+ke)+D2(1+ke)2+⋯+Dn(1+ke)n+Pn(1+ke)n

where Dt is the expected dividend in period t, Pn is the expected price at the end of period n, and ke is the required return on equity.

P0=∑t=1∞Dt(1+ke)t

where the sum runs over every future period t, so the intrinsic value is the present value of all future dividends.

Made-up example: Holding a stock for two years

A stock is expected to pay a $1 dividend in each of the next two years, then sell for $20 at the end of year 2. Your required return is 10%.

  1. P0=11.10+11.102+201.102 -- put the numbers into the formula with n=2
  2. 11.10=0.9091 -- present value of the year 1 dividend
  3. 1.102=1.21 -- discount factor for year 2
  4. 1+201.21=211.21=17.3554 -- present value of the year 2 dividend and sale price together
  5. 0.9091+17.3554=18.26 -- add everything up

Answer: $18.26 -- that is the most you should pay for the stock today.

Gordon growth model

From the slides: the recording missed this part.
A shortcut for the generalized dividend model when dividends grow at a constant rate g forever, and that growth rate is below the required return (g<ke).

Why: With constant growth, the infinite sum is a geometric series that adds up to a simple fraction. The rule g<ke is needed because otherwise each future dividend would be worth at least as much as the last, and the sum would never stop growing.

P0=∑t=1∞D0(1+g)t(1+ke)t=D0(1+g)ke−g=D1ke−g

where D0 is the most recent dividend paid, D1=D0(1+g) is next period's dividend, g is the expected constant growth rate of dividends, and ke is the required return on equity.

Made-up example: A steadily growing dividend

A firm just paid a $2 dividend. Dividends are expected to grow 4% a year forever, and you require a 10% return.

  1. D1=D0(1+g)=2×1.04=2.08 -- next year's dividend
  2. ke−g=0.10−0.04=0.06 -- the denominator
  3. P0=2.080.06=34.67 -- divide

Answer: $34.67 -- the intrinsic value of one share today.

Financial crises and stock prices

From the slides: the recording missed this part.
The financial crisis that began in August 2007 led to one of the worst bear markets in 50 years. The Gordon model explains it with two effects, and both push prices down:

Similar forces contributed to the COVID-19 stock market crash.

Why: In P0=D1/(ke−g), a lower g and a higher ke both make the denominator bigger, so the price falls.

Monetary policy and stock prices

From the slides: the recording missed this part.
When the Bank of Canada lowers interest rates, stock prices tend to rise, for two reasons:

Why: Both changes shrink ke−g in the Gordon model, which raises the price.

Stock prices and information

How stock prices are set

From the slides: the recording missed this part.
Owners have prices at which they will sell, and potential buyers have prices at which they will buy. A trade happens when a buyer's bid matches a seller's offer, and the market price changes as bids and offers change.

Why: The price is set by what buyers and sellers expect, so anything that changes those expectations moves the price.

Rational expectations

The valuation models need forecasts of future dividends and prices. This part asks how people form those forecasts.

Rational expectations

From the slides: the recording missed this part.
Expectations are rational when the expectation of a variable equals the optimal forecast: the best prediction using all available relevant information.

Why: If people ignored useful information, they would make avoidable mistakes, so it is natural to assume they use everything they have.

Xe=Xof

where Xe is the expectation of the variable X and Xof is the optimal forecast of X.

Even rational expectations are not always accurate:

Adaptive expectations

Under adaptive expectations, people predict a variable using only its own past values, and they adjust slowly as new data come in. For example, to forecast inflation you would look at last year's inflation and slowly update as new numbers arrive.

Why: The lecturer's example: a new government wins an election this month and will appoint a central bank governor who will cut rates a lot, so inflation will explode next year. Adaptive expectations barely react, because they only look at the past. Rational expectations take in this news and quickly raise next year's inflation forecast.

Rational expectations still use past data. They use all available information: past, present and anything known about the future. The slides add that rational expectations may be more realistic, because people often use more than past data and their expectations can change quickly.

Expectations change with policy

The first implication of rational expectations: if the way a variable behaves changes, the way people form expectations about it changes too.

Why: In the lecturer's example, if it is announced that a new central bank governor will run monetary policy a certain way, people adjust their expectations right away. They do not wait for interest rates to actually start changing.

Forecast errors average zero

The second implication: forecast errors are zero on average and cannot be predicted ahead of time. A single forecast can still be wrong, sometimes too high and sometimes too low.

Why: The lecturer argued it by contradiction. Suppose your errors were always off in the same direction. Then you would notice the pattern and fix your forecast, so a rational forecaster cannot keep making the same error. If you keep making it, something in your model is biased.

E(X−Xe)=0

where X−Xe is the forecast error (the actual value minus the expectation) and E means the average or expected value.

Example: A biased inflation forecast

You keep forecasting 5% inflation. Your misses go both ways (sometimes 4%, sometimes 6%), but over time actual inflation averages 6%.

  1. X−Xe=6%−5%=1% -- the average forecast error
  2. E(X−Xe)=1%≠0 -- the error is systematic, which breaks rational expectations
  3. Xe=5%+1%=6% -- revise the forecast up by the systematic error

Answer: Forecast 6% -- after the revision your errors should go both ways and average zero, which is what rational expectations require.

The lecturer added that "always" is not obvious: should you look over 1 year, 2 years or 10? Spotting bias is easier with high-frequency data. If you predict whether a stock goes up or down every 10 minutes, you get many forecasts and can see quickly if you are making the same error consistently.

Exam

The lecturer spent the most time here and stressed that zero average error "doesn't mean that you will always be accurate... Sometimes you will say 6% [and] it's actually five. Sometimes you'll say it's 4%, but it's actually five... On average, expected error is zero."

The efficient market hypothesis

The efficient market hypothesis was developed around the same time as rational expectations. It applies the same logic to financial markets.

Efficient market hypothesis

The efficient market hypothesis (EMH), also called efficient market theory or the theory of efficient capital markets, says that expectations in financial markets equal optimal forecasts using all available information. So security prices fully reflect all available information.

Why: The incentive to get forecasts right is strong in financial markets, because better forecasts earn profits, and that trading pushes prices to reflect the information.

Example: A stock priced below its optimal forecast

The optimal forecast says a stock is worth $50, but it trades at $40.

  1. 40<50 -- investors see the stock is cheap
  2. Investors buy -- demand for the stock rises
  3. The price rises -- buying continues while the price is below $50
  4. The price reaches 50 -- the gap is gone, so the buying stops

Answer: The price ends at $50 -- trading pushes the market price until it equals the optimal forecast.

Expected return

This is the rate of return from Lecture 4, rewritten with expected values. The return is the capital gain plus any cash payment, divided by the purchase price. For a one-year bond, the end price (the face value) and the coupons were known. For a stock, both the next price and the dividend are unknown, so both must be forecast. That gives the expected return, marked with the superscript e.

Why: At the start of the period you know what you paid, but you only have expectations about what you will get back.

R=Pt+1−Pt+CPt

where R is the rate of return, Pt+1 is the price at the end of the holding period, Pt is the price at the start, and C is the cash payment during the period (a coupon for bonds, a dividend for stocks).

Re=Pt+1e−Pt+CePt

where Re is the expected return, Pt+1e is the expected price at the end of the period, and Ce is the expected cash payment.

Made-up example: Expected one-year return on a stock

You buy a stock for $40. You expect it to pay a $1 dividend and to be worth $44 in a year.

  1. Re=44−40+140 -- put the numbers into the formula
  2. =540 -- capital gain of 4 plus a dividend of 1
  3. =0.125 -- divide

Answer: 12.5% -- the return you expect from holding the stock for one year.

Prices reflect all information

Under the EMH, the expected future price equals the optimal forecast based on current information, so the expected return also equals the optimal forecast of the return. In short, a security's price fully reflects all available information. So a stock price responds to an announcement only if the information is new and unexpected.

Why: News that was already known, or new but expected, is already in the price, so it cannot move it.

Pt+1e=Pt+1of⟹Re=Rof

where Pt+1of is the optimal forecast of next period's price and Rof is the optimal forecast of the return.

Exam

Repeated twice in the lecture: prices respond "only if the information being announced is new and unexpected... if it's new information, but people expected [it], it doesn't change the price. If they are old news, it doesn't change the price."

Arbitrage

Not every investor has to be rational for a market to be efficient. Arbitrage eliminates unexploited profit opportunities. A few well-capitalized investors (with "deep pockets") who have optimal forecasts can keep buying or selling until the price matches their forecast.

Why: The lecturer suggested big players such as large hedge funds, BlackRock or Warren Buffett. They likely have the information, can get it cheaply, and can trade enough to remove mispricing. The lecturer added this is a possibility, not a proven fact: "It's impossible to test if that's actually true."

Random walk

The main prediction of the EMH is that price changes are unpredictable. In mathematical terms, stock prices should roughly follow a random walk.

Why: If we could predict where a price was going, we would buy or sell ahead of time, and the price would jump to the predicted level right away. So, on average, nobody can predict where prices go next.

Exam

The lecturer called this "the main prediction of this hypothesis": prices are unpredictable, which is what "random walk" means here.

Investment adviser reports

Published reports by investment advisers, and news in newspapers, come out with a lag after the information is available. So it is old news, already public and already in prices. Acting on it should not earn above-market returns on average.

Why: Under the EMH, public information is already in the price. The lecturer added that empirical evidence generally finds published recommendations do not consistently earn higher risk-adjusted excess returns after costs.

Advice for investors

The EMH gives three prescriptions for most investors:

Why: In the lecturer's words, buying and holding will, in expectation, "probably pay you the same return as if you try to guess what would be the next Apple," and frequent trading costs more.

Fundamental value efficiency

Some financial economists believe prices are always correct and reflect the firm's fundamental (intrinsic) value, so markets are efficient in that stronger sense. The EMH does not say this. It says prices reflect all available information, and because new information is unpredictable, prices are unpredictable. That is all.

Why: If information about a firm is not public, or not known to most investors, it is not in the price. So a price can differ from the fundamental value and the market can still be efficient in the EMH sense.

Exam

A common mix-up the lecturer warned about: "The efficient-market hypothesis is not saying that a stock price will reflect exactly all the fundamentals of that firm. That's not what the efficient-market hypothesis says." The slides add that the semi-strong form of the EMH makes price changes from public information unpredictable, but does not make prices equal fundamental values.

Exam checklist

Admin & deadlines


Transcribed automatically from the lecture recording. Slides used: EC 223 - 2026-10-01 - Lecture 07 - The Stock Market, the Theory of Rational Expectations, and the Efficient Market Hypothesis (slides).pdf. Course info used: EC 223 - Syllabus - Fall 2026.pdf. Audio archived at /mnt/porsche/configs/lectures/archive/2026-10/EC 223 - 2026-10-01 - Lecture 07.opus.